Too Perfect to Last (boyxboy)

Chapter 8

Tyler POV
I woke up to see Evan on top of me.

"Evan! What're you doing?" I asked and his face went red as he say me awake.

"No no it's uh nothing bad I swear. I was just trying to get my phone which is on the table next to you. Heh." He said,awkwardly.

"Um ok then. Here." I grabbed his phone for him and pushed him off me.

I my then did I notice the head splitting pain ricocheting around my skull. Man I have a hell of a hangover.

"Hey looks like you had a fun night. Who's the lucky girl who got to give you those?" Evan asked, pointing to my hickeys.

I sighed.

"Evan these are from you." I said, I knew he wouldn't remember.

"What? From me? What did we do? We didn't...? Oh." He said and I could tell he was starting to remember. "Oh"

"Yeah. Also Michelle and Penny saw us under that table." I said, scooting closer to him in the bed.

"They did? Aw man now Penny's gonna think I broke up with her to be with you." Evan said, pulling the blankets up over us.

"Yeah. And you wouldn't do that. It's not like we would ever be together right."I laughed but it hurt my head. I knew he didn't like me like that.

"Um yeah. Haha. Never." He said, but he seemed almost sad. " I'm not gay."

"Yeah. Same bro." I said, interrupting him.

"I wasn't finished. I'm not gay, but I might be bisexual." He said, looking away from me.

Bisexual? Maybe I have a chance. Wait do I even like him? Ugh I don't know.

"Oh. That's cool. I um. I guess I don't know what I am anymore." I said, avoiding eye contact.

"Oh. Maybe I could help you figure it out then." Evan said,

"How?" I asked him.

"Um. I don't know if you would like this idea but we're both guys so if we pretended to date then you could know if you're straight or not." He said, confusing me even more.

"How does that work. Like how long would we pretend for and what are the boundaries in this fake dating." I asked him, excited at the prospect of dating him, even if it was fake dating.

"Um we could pretend for like a week I guess and as for boundaries um anything goes?" He said.

"Umm. Ok. Let's do it." I said, a bit too enthusiastically.

I don't really get how this will make me know if I'm straight or not but this means I get to touch him so I'm in.

"Ok. Umm I guess starting now you're my fake boyfriend." He said, smiling awkwardly.

"Cool." I said, not really knowing how to respond.

I have him a quick peck on the lips before getting up to change my clothes.

"Could you turn around while I change?" I asked him and he did.

Once we were both ready we went downstairs into the kitchen to get food. My mom had left a note on the table saying she was at work and that she had made waffles for us. We sat on the same side in my booth table and aye our waffles without talking. After we finished I put our dishes in the sink and we sat on the living room couch.

"So you wanna play a video game?" I asked him.

"Sure. Mario cart?" He asked.

"Alright. Just warning you I get competitive." I told him, putting the disc in and starting it up.

We both chose our characters, he's luigi and I'm Mario, and I chose rainbow road.

"Aw man I suck at this one." He said and I grinned evilly.

I won. And then I won again. And again. He was getting pretty fed up with losing. When I started the next course he bumped me, making my car fly off the edge. I bumped him back making his hit a wall. He tried to pull my remote out if my hand and I pressed buttons on his. He tackled me to the ground and we fight for my remote. The remote ended up flying out of our hands and it left us laying on the ground with Evan on top of me. The game was forgotten as I pulled him down to kiss me. He fumbled with my shirt and pulled it off, doing the same with his. I moved down to leave hickeys on his chest, not above the neckline like he did to me. I unbuttoned his pants and pulled them halfway down but the sound of keys in the front door stopped me from going all the way.

"Shit!" I said, pushing Evan off me and throwing my shirt back on and he did the same, hopping on one leg to pull his pants back up. We both grabbed our remotes and system playing just as my mom walked in the door.

"Hey boys. I came back because I forgot some paper work. Oh Evan, your shirt is on backwards." She said, grabbing her stuff and leaving.

"Oh." Evan said, quickly turning the shirt around.

"So uh. What should we do no-" I was cut off by a loud clattering noise coming from the hallway.

I got up to investigate and Evan followed behind me.

Michelle POV
I leaned farther to the side to observe the boys from the hallway but failed, instead falling and knocking a picture frame to the ground. Penny looked at me, eyes wide and we heard the boys get up. Her eyes darted around wildly before settling on the closet. She pushed me and her into the closet full of blankets and pushed the blankets in front of us, hiding us from view. Her body was pressed up against mine and she squeezed my hand for reassurance. I squeezed back and we tried to stay perfectly still. After a couple seconds. The closet door opened and light flooded in through the cracks. We held our breath as a hand reached through the blankets and groped around blindly. It grabbed Penny's shirt. For a couple seconds it felt the shirt and we held our breath. Then the hand retreated and the closet door closed. We both breathed a sigh of relief as we heard the boys leaving. The front door opened and closed and we burst out of the closet to follow them.

Hola. How are y'all doing. Bigfoot Booty here I hope you liked stalker! Michelle and Penny. Seeya next time my lovelies. Love you! <3