Same, Same but Different (completed)

Bring up the past

Dorth was determined to ruin Louis's and Liam's friendship by using Evangeline as bait. This was set out to destroy Liam for he did not know what other secrets Dorth had hid from them. She was planning something big and no one knew what it was. So she moved them away from there traps and palced both Liam and Louis in one room. She brought Evangeline after. All mouths were sealed with tape but Evangeline's one was sealed with a rope. She did not have the right to speak for this one. Dorth then removed the tape from both boys mouth and began whipping Evangeline as she wriggled her way begging for the pain to stop. Both guys could not take it for they both felt the pain she felt in their hearts. Dorth then decided to stop her torture. Evangeline was crying while her mouth bleed. They could not handle seeing her in so much pain. 

Dorth: This was all a test to prove my point guys. The mere fact is that both of you cannot handle seeing this girl in pain. It renders you helpless doesn't it. I bet Louis would do anything to be in Liam's place, right?

Louis: Wrong. 

Liam: Is this about how he was with her?

Dorth: Well isn't it obvious

Liam: This was all your fault. If you never did this to us in the first place we won't be in this situation. Sometimes I think you planned to ruin her like this just for spite.

Dorth: Liam, you do know Louis was keeping a secret from you right that the guys knew. I'll bring them out to prove my point.

Dorth brought the rest of the guys and bet them into telling the truth but they still never revealed anything. She planned a cunning plan once more to pull Evangeline by her hair. She then slapped her in her face once more. The guys could not handle Evangeline getting into so much trouble of because they didn't want to tell Liam the truth.

Harry: Okay we will tell you the truth, just stop hurting her stop it.

Niall: The truth is that Louis was in love with Evangeline still

Zayn: Believe us he never wanted to but he just admired her a lot. He never wanted to be any where close to her when Liam came back to his senses. You see it's sort of a faze someone goes through. I mean come on he was in love with her for goodness sake.

Harry: It's quite obvious it would hurt him a lot after knowing that the girl he fell in love with was in love with someone else.

Niall: Even though you tried your utterly best to wipe our memories, you could not wipe away our friendship or what we had. No machine in this world could do that. That's why it lasted temporarily than forever. You see when you do things with bad intentions it always falls back on you.

Zayn: That is why your plan failed and it is why we remembered.

Harry: I noticed Louis when he saw everything. Poor guy was heart broken and he didn't want to say it. I troubled him until he told us the truth. That where he came clean and said he's ashamed of being in love with her because he does not want to hurt his friend. Now tell me Dorth is that wrong? It was you who created trouble for us only you.

Dorth: You stupid worthless guys, you don't get it do you. Louis is still in love with her.

Harry: He's not. He just can't handle anyone giving her pain, it's in his nature. You can't use that against him. I see, you're trying to put them against each other. Well it's not going to work. Louis say something.

Louis: It's true I did love her. Liam I told you this already, I just cannot bare to see her in pain just like the other guys cannot as well.

Liam: I believe you. I do not need an explanation. I know what she is, I was not going to let her do what she wanted in the first place.

Dorth got so furious that nothing went according to her plans then she thought why was she letting all of them live when she could kill them all.