Same, Same but Different (completed)

Maybe because I care

Evangeline then slowly approached her with such sorrow in her eyes. "I forgive you. It's my father's fault that you ended up in this state. You were too kind. I knew you were always good at heart. Even though you hated me so much you kept me around. If you wanted to kill me you would have done it by now. I know you never killed step father either. You just sent him away. I know you hate me a lot. I never knew that my father was evil. I always thought he was a good man. I never knew that my mom was so kind. I never knew that they weren't so in love. I thought they were the ideal parents. It was good what you did. I knew how you probably felt that day when you saw your sister in that car. You know the funny thing is that you tried so hard to hide that diary but I found it one day.

That time you locked me up in prison. You never knew you left that book there. I read it. I always knew you were good at heart. I know how everything you did to me was unwilling. I understand your situation. I look a lot like my father but I'm not to blame for his wrong doings. I know you got angry that day when your daughter died. You actually did not want to hit me but you just had to. Your daughter actually died saving my life. She was like a sister I never had, I'm so sorry for what my father did to you but my friends don't deserve this pain and I don't deserve this pain. I don't deserve your hatred. I don't deserve anyone's love. I only hurt everyone I love, I don't deserve it all I just don't I.....I.....I...."

Evangeline then had a mental breakdown right in front of everyone and the guys tried their best to comfort her. Dorth on the other hand started to cry.

"I was so mean to you and you forgave me. I'm the one at fault here, I caused you all the troubles just because I hated that man so much. You know it's not my fault, I liked you so much. I was mentally unstable the doctor said so. Seeing you would trigger that breaking point in me that became so unstoppable. I could not help myself. Then some guy fell in love with you and I was reminded of Nate and I hated him. It's not Louis's fault either, it's mine. I hated everyone so much. I guess I have to go to jail for all of this."

Evangeline: Who said anything about jail. I forgive you. I don't think you deserve to suffer because of the mistake my parents made. I understand you well now. You finally realize you're mistake and I'm contended with that. The truth is all I ever wanted was to get that love I never got and I got it from my friends and Liam of course.

The guys started to cry and also forgave her for this mistake. It seemed as if everything was all well and good.until tragedy struck.