You felt your arm move and your hand connect with Ben's. His smile changed into a more perverted one the longer he looked at you.
"Damn you're so hot." He breathed out looking down at you. You blushed and pulled your blanket up.
"Please don't hurt me..." You squeaked. Ben looked down at you confused.
"Why would I hurt you?" He asked.
"You're a murderer." You pointed out. Ben laughed and sat down next to you. He let out another childish laugh and wrapped his arms around you.
"But you're so cute I couldn't do it!"
"If you're not going to kill me... What are you going to do..?" You asked.
"Take you home and let you meet the family." Ben said with a smile. And with that, you passed out.
~
You woke up in a bedroom, but it wasn't yours. Shelves of video games filled the walls. Green laundry was left scattered on the floor and a good sized TV hung on the wall. You sat up from the beanbag you had been sleeping in and called out the first name that came to mind,
"Ben?"
"Sorry (Y/N) I was getting changed." Ben said pulling a shirt over his head as he exited a bathroom. You nodded and looked at some of the video games that littered the floor.
"I'm sorry." Ben mumbled. You looked up in shock.
"For taking you away like that I mean... You're probably terrified. Right?" Ben asked crouching in front of you. You nodded slightly and said,
"But you said you wouldn't hurt me, I'm expecting you to keep true to your word." Ben's face softened and he pulled you into a hug. You stiffened at his touch but relaxed when he said,
"I promise."
"So, meet the family?" You asked.
"Oh yeah!" Ben said pulling away. He grabbed your hand and pulled you into the hall. He turned left and knocked on the first door that came up. A loud metallic bang came from inside the room and then the door opened. A boy emerged from the room, brown hair, normal clothing, but his mask and black gooey sockets made you curious.
"Oh wait!" You yelled. You tapped your foot trying to remember what Damian had told you about these types of people, creepypastas.
"Jack... Jack... EYELESS JACK!" You yelled in victory. The boy nodded and pulled up his mask a little to reveal a smirk.
"Good work," he said holding out a hand.
"(Y/N)." You said slightly terrified, his smirk was attractive yet scared you. You were in a house full of murderers right?
Ben pulled you away and knocked on a pink door. A laugh echoed from inside the room and the door swung open as fast it could.
"Ben-Ben!" A girl cried out. "When are we going to have our next-" she looked at you and her words slowed. "-tea party..."
"Hi." You waved. The girls eyes widened.
"She looks like-!"
"Sally." Ben said sternly. The girl frowned and waved.
"I'm (Y/N), nice to meet you Sally!" You said.
Sally's smile returned and she asked you an unexpected question,
"Will you come back later and have a tea party with me? You seem nicer than the other girls."
"S-sure." You said looking at Ben. He smiled and pulled you into what looked like a kitchen.
"Okay, from now on I want you to be in guard." Ben said sternly, his playful behavior gone. You nodded and looked around and Ben pulled you to the far edge of the kitchen where two people stood at the counter.
"Mm, B-Ben t-this is amazing." One of the figures said. You gasped when you saw a cheesecake sitting perfectly cut in the counter. You didn't notice you were drooling till one of the two people wiped some spit off your face.
"Are you drooling cause of the cake or me?" Ben whispered into your ear. You blushed and looked at the cake.
"Can I have a piece?" You asked.
"NO!" The two yelled.
"Hoodie, Masky, I can always make another one." Ben said. The hooded one handed you a piece and looked down nervously.
"H-here y-you go." You smiled and thanked him before Ben once again dragged you away. He pulled out and chair from a table and sat down. You say down as well and ate the cake fast. Ben looked at you intensely and you froze.
"You promised you wouldn't hurt me." You said. Ben shook his head and smiled,
"That's not why I'm staring (Y/N)."
"So... When can I go home?" You asked. Ben frowned but then his smile returned just as fast.
"Soon!" He said excitedly. "You have school soon."
"BENNNNNN!!" Someone roared from down the halls. You froze and gripped your fork tightly.
"Oh no..." Ben breathed out.
"YOU HAVE A GUEST AND DIDN'T INTRODUCE ME?!" You felt a metal object touch your neck and you knew that someone was behind you. You knew who too, it was obvious. You grabbed the persons arm and twisted it before you flung up from the chair and knocked the person to the ground. You grabbed the knife and held it to the persons throat.
"Heya Jeff." You said with a smirk. He smiled and pulled you towards his face. You tensed up and shook with fear. You felt arms wrap around your waist and pull you up off of the grinning boy.
"(Y/N), it's time you went home." Ben said pulling you protectively away from Jeff. Once you made it to Ben's room you felt yourself start to pass out.
~
You woke up in your room and sighed.
