Jay

143 2 1
                                    

"Remember when I walked in on you and BEN trying to do the nasty?"

"Yes, I do. Why must you remind me of my misery?"

"That was hot."

What the hell.

What

The

Hell.

"Uhh....Excuse me?"

"You have a nice ass." He said blankly, staring into space

"Is this you trying to flirt? Work on it, bro."

His hand trailed slightly up his thigh

"Please?"

"No?"

Masky stared into Toby, lust seeping from his big brown puppy eyes. "Toby, I haven't had sex with anyone since Jay. I haven't wanted to since Jay. Not with anyone but you, of course. Please Toby. God fucking damn just a make out session? Something!? I like you, Toby. Not Brian, not BEN, Not Jack, Not Jane, I didn't even like Schere! You, Toby, I want you!"

I could help but want to cry. His heart broke so many times I couldn't stand to break it another.

"You know I'm with BEN..."

His head hung low, I could tell he was trying his hardest not to cry, but his voice trembled too much for that to not be happening.

"You remind me so much of Jay, I just miss him so much.... Give me one last chance, Toby. Just a kiss. I want my Jay back so badly."

"Alright.."

Ticked {TICCI DROWNED TOBY X BEN LOVE STORY}Where stories live. Discover now