Screaming To Death ¥ Noah Foster

~ I thought it was Kieran ~

Olivia's eyes fluttered open. She heard muffled screams next to her and she saw her mom strapped to a chair. "What the hell?" She questioned. She looked around and figured that she was on the dock at Wren lake.

"Oh my god!" She heard a gasp as Emma came running onto the dock.

"Emma, he anywhere. Go." Olivia said to her sister.

Emma took the duck tape off of her mother's mouth. "Emma, listen to your sister. Get out of here."

"No." Emma shook her head. "I never should have let you go to that party." Emma sighed, hugging her sister. Emma gasped as she saw the stab wound in Olivia's shoulder.

"Girls, he's here." Maggie stated.

Olivia watched as the killer stepped closer to them. Emma stepped out, holding a knife behind her back. "I'm here, just like you wanted." She said to him. "No more games. No more masks."

The killer slipped the hood of the raincoat off, and pealed the mask off their face. Olivia's mouth dropped as she saw that Piper was under the mask. "Hey, sis. Surprise."

"Piper?" Emma gasped.

"That's not what I was expecting." Olivia gasped. "I thought it was Kieran." Emma glared at her sister.

"I seriously wish that you could see your face right now." Piper smirked at the two girls standing in front of her. "Hashtag, mind blown."

"No, you can be." Emma sighed, shaking her head.

"I can."

"So, when we were bonding about your dad being murdered," Emma spoke softly, "you were talking about Brandon James."

"Yes." Piper nodded, still smirking. "And you were so easily convinced that it had to be his son swinging the knife, but it's twenty-fifteen, Emma, sexist much?"

"You pretended to help me." Emma snapped at her. "You pretending to be my friend."

"And it stings when someone breaks your trust." Piper looked back at Maggie, who was still tied to the chair. "Right, mom? Dad trusted you, and look how that turned out." Piper laughed. "Dad got shot, I got tossed, and Olivia and Emma had the perfect life."

"Piper, I swear to you." Maggie spoke up. "I never meant for Brandon to get hurt. I was trying to protect him."

"You were trying to protect yourself!" Piper shouted at her. Obviously, the girl was a nutjob. "For twenty years, you let everyone think that my dad was the monster, but you were the monster."

"You're right." Maggie nodded. "But they were my mistakes, not the girls'. If you wanna hurt someone, hurt me."

"I plan on it." Piper chuckled as she spoke. "But I kinda put a lot of thought and time into this, so I'd like to savor the moment a little bit before I slice you open, kay?"

"I get it. I get it." Emma spoke. "You hate us. But why did you kill my friends?"

"They had nothing to do with this." Olivia said to her.

"To watch the two of you suffer, of course." Piper smiled in a sinister way. "But, I mean, they did kinda help. What did they do to, Olivia? Oh that's right, they filmed your first time with Jake. And Emma? You're best friend slept with your boyfriend. Of course, both of them are dead now, so..."

"They're going to figure out who did it." Emma growled at Piper.

"No they won't." Piper smiled as she looked down at the knife in her hands. "Because the bad guy did it. And I have him, back there, tied up in my trunk."