Jeremy x Reader One-Shots

Best Friends Better Off As Lovers

You looked at your boyfriend, Fritz and smiled at him. He smiled back and booped your nose, "You're so adorable, y'know?" You giggled and pecked his cheek, "You are too, Fritzy!" He hummed and you rested your head on his shoulder.

You two were sitting like that until your phone buzzed. You took out your phone and looked to see the message.

Jerebear🐻🌝: Hi, fren. Wanna hang out?

You looked at Fritz for permission and he smiled and nodded. You whispered a quick 'thanks' and quickly replied.

Cupcake🍰🌚: Sure, fren. Usual?

Jerebear🐻🌝: Yes, fren. See you in 30.

Cupcake🍰🌚: See ya! 🐻

You sat up and fixed your hair a little bit. You put on some skinny jeans and a fresh FOB shirt.

You and Jeremy were bestfriends as long as you two can remember. You two were inseparable up until now, but ever since Fritz asked to be your boyfriend, he seemed... distant. Sure, you two are hanging out every now and then, but it just wasn't the same.

You put on your shoes and opened the door, "Bye, Fritz!" You waved. "Have fun! I love you!" You froze, "I... love you too." You saw him frown in the corner of your eye and you closed the door.

Love...? Why did it felt so weird? Why was I hesitant?

You shook the thoughts and you went to the park, where you were supposed to meet Jeremy. You felt giddy inside.

You saw a messy flop of brown hair by the swings. You immediately ran and tackled him.

"G-Geesus christ, (Y/N)! Y-you scared me!" You snickered and messed his already messy hair. "Oh come on, Jerebear! Are you still not used to that?" You giggled and he eventually joined in. The giggles turned into loud laughter that made your stomach hurt.

"W-we seriously need to s-stop," you said in between laughs. He wiped the tears that was forming in his eyes and sighed.

"You want pizza?" He asked, but you knew that he already knew what's the answer. "Is that even a question? Come on!" You grabbed his hand and you swore you felt something when your skin came in contact with his.

The two of you wentz (it autocorrected went to wentz. i'm leaving that in lol. thanks pete) to your favourite pizza place, Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria. You smiled at him and entered heaven. Freddy greeted you and you greeted him as well. The old animatronics were there as well as the new ones.

You two sat down and ordered the usual. It was nice to finally talk to Jeremy again. The two of you went back to your normal selves again. The two of you chatted until the pizza was served. You eyed the pizza and you were slightly drooling. Freddy's pizza is the best.

"I swear, I'll never get tired of their pizza." You said as you swallowed a bite. Jeremy nodded in response, swaying a little bit.

A few moments later, the two of you finished the pizzas and decided to order another one for, uh, safety reasons?

You and Jeremy went to his yellow checkered car, he opened the car door to the passenger seat and you thanked him. He went to the driver's seat and put the key into the ignition.

"Where to, M'lady?" He said with a cute accent.

"Anywhere, kind sir." You giggled.

He started driving to an unfamiliar direction, and you couldn't care less. The roads were open; not a lot of cars were there. You rolled the windows down and popped your head and torso out in the wind. The chilly air was hitting your face, your locks of (H/C) hair is blowing carelessly by the strong wind.

"W-woah, (Y/N). You might hurt yourself!" You laughed, "Oh, come on, Jerebear! It's fun!" You heard a sigh and a window rolling down.

You looked back to see Jeremy popping head out a bit and smiling widely. "That's the spirit, Jere!"

The two of you raced through the city in the night sky, windows down, and living life to the fullest.

~

"That was fun," you said while opening the car door and stretching. You were outside Jeremy's house, planning to sleep at his for the meantime.

You and Jeremy went to the doorstep and he stopped. He put a hand on your shoulder and sighed, "(Y/N)... Can I tell you something?" You nodded, telling him to go on.

He took a deep breath, "I-I like you." You smiled and patted him on the shoulder, "I like you too!" He sighed again and looked at you deeply in the eyes.

"N-not that kind of 'like,' (Y/N)! I like you as lovers do. I want to hold your hand whenever we go. I want to kiss you under the moonlight with thousands of stars above us. I want to be your prince. I want to be your savior. I love you!" You gasped in shock. "But damn it, you have a boyfriend. I was too late. I never had the chance to do the thing I want to do. I know you won't like me back. Besides, I'm just that bestfriend of yours and it will forever stay like that."

"J-Jeremy..." A tear rolled on your cheek and you hugged him tightly. "I love you, too. But Fritz-"

"I understand." A voice said from behind you two said. You whipped your head and saw Fritz standing with tears flowing from his eyes. "I love you, (Y/N). But I know that Jeremy will take care of you better than I would. He knows you better than I do. I saw the look on your face when I told you I love you. I'm letting you go, (Y/N). I'm letting you go because I love you. I want you to be happy."

You ran to him and hugged him, "Thank you, Fritz. Don't get me wrong, I loved you." He smiled and nodded he kissed your forehead and guided you to Jeremy. He patted Jeremy's shoulder, "Take care of her, man." He went to his car and drove away.

You sighed and looked at Jeremy, "I'll miss him." He nodded and put his arm around your shoulder. You wiped your tears, "Let's go inside, (Y/N)." He opened the door and waited for you to go inside.

You sat on the couch and Jeremy went to grab a blanket. He put the blanket around you and you rested your head on his shoulder. "I love you, Jeremy. I'm an idiot for not realizing that sooner." He smiled at you. "I love you too, (Y/N)."

The two of you fell asleep in each other's arms. 

~

When you woke up, you saw a note in your arm written in a red lipstick. "Brb, cupcake. Just went to buy pizza. I love you ❤️." You smiled and thought,

Best Friends ARE Better Off As Lovers.

------------
TGIS IS TOO CLICHÉ HAHAHAHAHAH

kill me. brb just gonna cry because patrick stump