The New Neighbor (Andy Biersack x Reader Fanfiction) 《!》Discontinued《!》

Chapter 16

We woke up about a half hour later to Amanda's crying.

"I got it," Andy mumbled as he got up. I went to the kitchen and warmed up a bottle for her just in case she's hungry. Andy comes into the kitchen with Amanda crying in his arms.

"Do you want to feed her or do you want me to?" I asked.

"I'll do it." I handed him the bottle and he held it as Amanda stopped crying and started drinking her milk. He quietly started singing 'Done For You' as she slowly falls asleep in his arms while drinking her milk. He carefully handed her to me and I brought her upstairs and carefully put her back in her crib. She woke up when I took my hands away so I quietly started singing 'Saviour' until she fell back asleep. I continued to sing it after she fell asleep because it's the first song that Andy sang for me when I officially became his girlfriend. I obviously can't scream so I just sang those parts normally as I went downstairs.

"You have a beautiful voice," Andy said as I sat next to him. "We've been together for like 3 years and I've never heard you sing. Not even once."

"I usually sing when I know that I'm alone but I just love 'Saviour' so much that I had to finish singing it."

"I probably asked you this once before but what are your-" he paused to think for a minute. "Top 5 BVB songs," Andy asked.

"No, I don't think you've asked me this before but my top 5 are...'Saviour,' 'Lost It All,' 'In The End,' 'The Mortician's Daughter,' and 'Coffin.' It's not in any specific order but those are just my top 5."

"What's your favorite BVB album?" Evie asked.

"Ummm....Set the World On Fire," I replied.

"What about top 3 Twenty One Pilots songs?" Josh asked.

"Uhh.. 'Friend Please,' 'Oh, Ms. Believer,' and 'Johnny Boy.'"

"We should play truth or dare," Evie suggested.

"Sure, why not," Andy agreed.

"Who's going first?" I asked.

"I'll go," Josh said. "Umm Alex. Truth or dare?"

I thought for a minute; then finally decided, "dare."

"Okay..." he paused to think. "Lick the the person on your right's neck." I turn to my right and see Evie. I lick her neck.

"Okay, my turn. Evie, truth or dare?" I say.

"Truth-wait no, dare!"

"You already said truth so..have you ever shoplifted?"

She stopped to think for a minute. "No, I don't think so. Okay, umm..Andy. Truth or dare."

"Dare."

"I dare you...to go put on the Andy Sixx makeup."

"Which one?"

"The original one from when BVB first became a band."

"Alex, can I use your makeup?"

"Yeah, don't even bother to ask, I don't really care."

"Okay thanks," he said as he ran upstairs to put on his makeup.

"I'll be back," I said as I went upstairs to check on Amanda. She woke up as I walked in her room. I picked her up and held her close. Andy comes in with his makeup half finished and eyeliner in his hand.

"Is she okay?" He asked.

"Yeah, she's fine, she just woke up," I replied as I walked towards the door. "I'll be downstairs," I said as I kissed his cheek.