CreepyPasta Boyfriend Scenarios (DISCONTINUED)

When He Starts to Like You

Slenderman

Slender made sure you guys saw each other again. You had grown closer with Slendy. You and him had become best of friends. The side effects of his presence soon fade. It was fun hanging around with Slender. He understood you and he listened, unlike your other friends.

He also loved your presence. You made him feel as if everything was fine. He had found himself falling for you. He was there for you when you needed help. He wanted you to be his forever. But thought you would never love a monster like him.

Jeff the Killer

Jeff had been hanging around your house more lately. He protected you from the harsh world you lived in. But he found himself falling head over heels for you. He would sneak in without you parents noticing. You both laughed at each other. 

He noticed that you liked it when he flirted with you. He took note and used it to his advantage. Knowing what your favorite color was. He gave you flowers and gifts. But you thought nothing of it, you just thought he was trying to prove himself 'nice'. But he was dropping hints that he had a HUGE crush on you.

 Eyeless Jack

E.J. threw rocks at your window when he wanted to come in. You thought it was cute. He thought you were cute. Jack and you had become best friends. Your friends even thought you were dating. Which E.J. thought was cute, but you got annoyed. He took note and thought you would never love him.

But he still loved spending time with you. He wanted to get closer to you. Why? Because he was madly in love with you. But you didn't like him that way. Well not really. You felt you could like him if you thought about it. You just didn't think about it as much as he did.

Lost Silver

Silver and you played Pokemon together...alot. More than usual. Sometimes when you were nervous, you had a stutter like Silver's. He found it cute. Not knowing what to do if you found out that he liked you. He was cared you would hate him.

But the truth was, you never would hate him. He's too adorable to hate. Plus you had become best of friends. You couldn't hate him. Even if you tried. It just wasn't possible. 

Masky

Masky wanted you to meet him in the park. He really liked you. And you were starting to take note to that. Every time he was around you, he would start to fumble around with something or stutter. You thought it was cute how he fumbled around with things.

You laughed as he tried to get your attention by being idiotic. He always hung around you and your friends, creeping them out a bit. But you didn't mind. You liked it when they were scared. Which made you and Masky the perfect pair.

Hoodie(Hoody)

Hoodie(Hoody) would always see you with cheesecake. You took note to his...love of cheesecake. It was funny to watch him do tricks for cheesecake. But that wasn't really the reason he did tricks. Sure, he loved cheesecake. And I mean loved cheesecake. But he did tricks to entertain you.

Thinking he would win your heart by doing silly tricks or cool flips. Well he defiantly won your friendship. You laughed as he ran around the house trying to get your attention. He knew it was embarrassing, but he liked you. What else could he do?

BEN Drowned

BEN took you to the arcade more than once or twice. He loved seeing you play the games you played. You would play shooting games with him. Of course he won, but at least you tried. Plus you didn't want him to get mad.

What you didn't know was that he really liked you. He was over the moon when you talked to him. It was like he was madly in love with you. Which apparently he was.