Pretty Little Liars Preferences

#38 You Lose Your Virginity To Him

Ezra: You're laying, legs spread as you look up and see your boyfriend's eyes staring into yours. "Baby, are you sure you're ready?" You nod quickly, biting your lip. "If you're not, I don't want to hurt you, tell me if I shou-" "Fuck, Ezra just get inside me already!" you scream, and he chuckles. He slowly slides in, and all you feel is pain. Your eyes squeeze shut and only his tip is in. "Shhh, it's okay beautiful. It'll be over soon, I love you and this is the most pain I will ever cause you." You nod and tears spill out as he shoves the rest of himself in you. You lay there waiting for yourself to adjust, when he says, "You know, you feel amazing babe," with a smirk on his face. You laugh, and tell him to start moving. The pain turns into pleasure, and you're glad you both waited to lose your virginity to each other.

Caleb: Your hands are intertwined with Caleb's on either side of your head, your breathing heavy. "Hey, hey, it's okay. Don't be nervous, I only want to do this if you're sure you want to. I'll wait forever if I have to babe." You take a deep breath and nod, "Caleb, I want you. I'm ready." He kisses you and starts to slowly thrust in, and you squeeze his hands. He notices, and whispers how much he loves you against your lips. You start to tear up, and your boyfriend feels guilty. He rubs his thumb against your hand soothingly, and feels his heart drop seeing you like this. He kisses you until you feel the pain ease away, and you tell him to move. He smiles, kisses you while thrusting in and out slowly, being the first and only to make love to you.

Toby: You're straddling Toby, feeling your heartbeat go a million times a minute. His hands are on your hips while he's looking into your eyes. "You know baby girl, we don't have to do this. If you don't want to, it's okay. I don't want to force anything upon you." You smile and kiss him, before you position yourself. You slowly sink down, and you feel a sharp pain. You start to cry, while he moves his hands from your hips to your face and kisses you, while you push yourself all the way down. You stay still, feeling the pain slowly go away. You look into his eyes while gripping his shoulders, "I love you." He smiles, puts his hands back on your hips, and helps you out. You see nothing but love on his face, and you know you made the right choice losing your virginity to him.

Jason: It's no surprise that you and Jason got things heated in his car after a romantic midnight picnic, but you didn't realize it would get this far. You were nervous and your boyfriend seemed to notice. "We don't have to do this if you're not ready. I'm going to wait until you are, because you're the only one I want this with." You smile, and you realize you only want him. You look into his eyes and he sees it. He massages your thighs lovingly while he holds them open, "Are you ready, babe?" You bite your lip and nod, while he slowly pushes in. You scrunch your face and try to hold everything in, but Jason notices. He holds you close and kisses your face until you notice the pain is gone. He thrusts as if he's afraid to hurt you even more, and he doesn't lose eye contact, making you fall even more in love with him.

Mike: It was a rainy night, so your boyfriend made it as romantic as possible. There were candles everywhere, and you felt a feeling towards him, knowing you were ready. You passionately kiss him, and before you knew it, you were looking up into his nervous looking eyes, and you knew yours were too. "Are you sure you want this, princess? I can stop at any time, just tell me and I will." You lean up to kiss him before whispering in his ears, "Go ahead, get in me." He smiles down at you, while easing in. You wince and the further he goes, the more the tears fall. "Princess, I am so sorry. I don't mean to ever hurt you. I love you more than anything." You nod, "I know baby, I love you too." You then tell him to start moving. You look into his eyes and see that they're filled with love, making your heart melt and love him more than you thought possible.