Pretty Little Liars Preferences

#45 He Cheats

Ezra: You'd come home after a long day at work, expecting a relaxing evening, but instead you found a tearful Ezra sitting on the couch staring blankly at the wall. "Ezra, what's wrong?" You asked rushing over to him. "I need to tell you something Y/N, I think you should sit down." He didn't even look at you, eyes fixed on the beige wall. The seriousness in his tone made you sit like an obedient dog and your heart beat faster, he'd never used this tone with you before. "The other day, when I was at the club with the guys, I got really drunk and this girl came onto me and we-" You didn't need to hear the rest of what he said, you knew what was coming and tears came pouring out of your eyes as your world tumbled down around you. The love of your life, your husband, had done something you never thought he would. Betrayed you. You couldn't stop the sobs that escaped your body and you weren't even focused on Ezra's apology anymore. He immediately pulled you into his arms, whispering the three words that used to mean so much. " I love you, I love you so much, I really do, she meant nothing, please forgive me baby, I love you." You didn't know what to think anymore and you didn't know what to do.

Caleb: You were just out and about in town with friends when you decided to grab some lunch in a bar you had stumbled across. Caleb had told you he was working today and that he wouldn't be back until late. Your friends grabbed a table, whilst you went to queue to buy the drinks. Joining the back of the queue, you noticed the man in front of you had the same familiar hairstyle as Caleb but he and the girl next to him were snogging each others faces off so you brushed it off. They got to the front of the queue, the man ordered and that's when your heart stopped. There was no doubting the fact that is was Caleb's voice. You gasped, threw your arm over your mouth and stepped back, "Caleb?" Caleb's head whipped around faster than humanely possible and stared you straight in the eye looking like a deer in headlights. "Princess, oh my god, baby, no,no,no." You turned and ran out of the bar, eyes like a waterfall and Caleb screaming your name.

Toby: It was late afternoon in yours and Toby's shared apartment when you heard a knock on the door. You opened it expecting Toby to have forgotten his keys or something as it wasn't like you were waiting for anyone. But it wasn't Toby, it was the last person you were expecting, his ex girlfriend. "Can I come in?" She asked, pleading with her eyes. "Uh, yeah sure, sure." You stepped aside and showed her to the sofa, offering her a seat and a drink. "No thanks, I won't be long, I just need to get something off my chest." She started, " Last week, I bumped into Toby in a club, we got chatting, had a few drinks and before you know it, we were back at mine and I think you know where this goes and I just wanted to say I'm so sorry,I really am." A single tear fell down your cheek as you processed the information, to say you were shocked would be an understatement but anger was burning in your chest like a wild fire. " Thanks for letting me know, now get out." You said, venom dripping from your words. You slammed the door behind her and let out a frustrated scream, the tears following shortly after.

Jason: He told you he was just going to meet the guys, but after you couldn't get hold of him and you'd called Ezra to ask about him, Ezra had no idea where he was. That was when you got the text. The text from your best friend which broke your heart. The text which told you Jason was at a restaurant with another girl, having a VERY intimate dinner. You had to see it yourself so you sped into town and rushed into the restaurant ignoring the waiter who tried to speak to you and that's when you saw them. Holding hands and grinning like idiots at each other. You marched up to the table, paused for a moment and then slapped him, hard. " Your such a piece of scum Jason." You grabbed the wine from in front of him and threw it in his face, much to the horror of his date. "Oh sh*t, Y/N let me explain." "Save it." You walked out of the restaurant and back to your car feeling proud, but also heart broken.

Mike: You and Mike had been fighting a lot lately and when your best friend told you about him cheating, you were ready to explode with anger. As soon as he walked in the door you were onto him. " Who is she, Mike?" You asked throwing the phone in his face. "Just some girl, I don't know, I was drunk, these things happen." He replied shrugging it off. You didn't know what to do, you were expecting him to deny it, fight about it and tell you he loves you but no. A straight, blunt answer which was like a stab in the chest. Speechless you dragged yourself up the stairs to your shared bedroom and started packing your stuff. Once you'd finished you trudged down the stairs and slung your bag over your shoulder. "I'm going now." You barely whispered towards Mike on the sofa. "Wait, what?" He seemed confused as he got up and came towards you, "Why are you leaving, I was drunk, it meant nothing." " You don't love me anymore." "Of course I love you, Y/N." He almost cried, face pained and eyes pleading. "Then show me." You didn't even look at him as you left. You just couldn't.