Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When he asks you out

Got the problem fixed :)

Jeff

You walked into your room, smelling blood. On your bed was a note written in blood.

You rolled your eyes. Jeff was probably playing a prank on you, the note would probably say something like "Go. To. Sleep." Or "I am coming to get you Y/N" He always was playing practical jokes on you like that.

You picked up the note anyway. You were surprised at what it said

Y/N,

Ten seconds after you read this note, you will get a surprise.

About ten seconds later (more like five) Jeff popped out of your closet, holding his knife. You thought he was finally going to kill you, that he was faking your friendship just to get close to you and then kill you. Jeff stepped close to you, set his knife down on your bed, held both of your hands in his and said, "Y/N, I love you. I need you. Will you be mine?" He asked, blushing. "Of course I will. I love you too." You responded, getting a bit teary eyed. He immediately threw his arms around you and embraced you into a tight hug. He squeezed you tight, obviously enjoying having a pair of boobs pressed against him. You tried to break free, but he just held you tighter. "Nobody is going to tear you away from me~ I'm never gonna let you go~" he cooed into your ear.

You smiled, glad he didn't murder you.

BEN

You were sleeping, you had started leaving your console on at night so BEN could come and see you. He was usually respectful of when you slept, you typically went to bed at 10:00-10:30 and woke up at 9:00 or so. Tonight, he came in around midnight.

BEN stroked your hair gently, and whispered in your hear "Hey Boo..." He said, being really sweet. You woke up, and smiled at him being sweet like this. "I'd go swimming for you~ Be mine?" He asked, stroking your hair gently. You smiled. "Of course. Now, let's go swimming." He shook. "U-Uh... Lets do that some other time. I don't exactly own any swim trunks..." You laughed. "You could always wear a suit of mine..." You said, laughing. "No. How about I stay here tonight though?" BEN said, getting under the covers with you. "Sure" you said, cuddling him, knowing he probably wouldn't go swimming at all, even with you.

Masky

Masky came by, like normal. You had a cheesecake prepared for him, like usual. But today, he brought over a cheesecake. You removed the foil from it, and it had something written on it in strawberry syrup. It said:

I love you more than I love cheesecake, Y/N. Be mine?

You smiled, grabbed a knife and carved in the following;

Yes, Masky!

He smiled, and hugged you. "Yay!" He got a spoon, took a big spoonful, and slowly brought it to your mouth. You opened your mouth, preparing to eat the creamy dessert. Right as it was to your mouth, he brought it back and ate it. "Masky!" You laughed. "Why'd you do that?" "Because I wanted to torture you." You took he whole cheesecake, and smashed it on his head playfully. He got the cheesecake that you had made for him, and smashed it over your head. You both looked like idiots with cheesecake for hats, but you didn't care.

Hoodie

Hoodie had come to your house today, instead of meeting you at the cafe. You walked down to the cafe together, and when you arrived, it was totally empty except for a few employees. Hoodie led you to the center table. On it, was a note that said

Dear Y/N,

Sorry I'm too shy to tell you this, and I know you'll think I'm an idiot and will never want to speak with me again, but I love you so much. Will you go out with me?

~ Hoodie.

You looked up at him. He was crying. "Hoodie, look at me." He looked up. You could see tears coming from the bottom of his mask. "Don't cry. I don't think you're an idiot. I think it's very brave of you to tell me this. I love you too. I will go out with you. He was still crying, but out of happiness. Hoodie immediately embraced you into the warmest hug you have ever felt. "T-Thank you Y-Y/N. This h-has t-to be t-the best m-moment of m-my l-life." He said. You had no idea how happy he was.

EJ

You had just got done with a long day of school/work. You were going to take a nap, because you had gotten yelled at for causing trouble. When you opened the door to your room, a bunch of kidneys spelled out

"Will you be mine, Y/N?"

You just smiled. "Yes, EJ!" You said, he crawled out from underneath your bed, eating a kidney like normal. He brought you into a warm hug. "By the way, those are all kidneys from the right side, so go ahead and eat them." You just laughed at EJs silly rule, and picked up a kidney from the arrangement, forgetting all about getting yelled at by your teacher/boss

Toby

It was breakfast time one morning, and you and Toby were cramming your faces full of waffles, when he kissed your cheek and asked "Be mine?" You smiled. "Of course, Toby." He brought you onto his lap, and embraced you tightly. You buried your head in his chest, and he rested his head on yours, still eating a waffle. You heard chomping, and looked up to see Toby eating a waffle messily. "Toby!" You laughed. "Way to ruin a moment!" "Oh, you wanted some?" He asked, shoving a "generous" piece into your mouth. You laughed, taking a whole waffle from his stack, and cramming it into your mouth. Toby scrunched up his face and said, "You win this round..." You guys then returned to your waffles.

Darkness

You guys were being crazy, dancing around to Dixie Chicks (Or whatever your favorite band is) when it came to a slow song, Darkness held you close. "Be my Dark Zelda?" He asked, shifting his arms so they were a little more... Low set. "Of course." You said, as he picked you up bridal style and danced around with you. Your favorite song came on, and you smiled. "This is my favorite song" You said, as he set you down on your bed. "Then stand up and sing like the star you are." He said, playing with your hair. You blushed, and reluctantly stood up, and sang along with the song. "Dance." Darkness demanded. You blushed more, and started dancing along with it. He eventually got on the bed with you and danced and sung along with you.