Jeff
You guys had a cookout, just the two of you. You both were in your swimming suits, and were sitting up on the pool deck. It was a beautiful evening. The sunset was just starting, and the colors were beautiful. Everything was perfect, until the burger slipped out of the bun and landed on your chest. Jeff reacted immediately and ate the meat right off your chest. You blushed, leaned over him (you guys were sitting in those pool chairs) and stole his food, your breast right in his face. He blushed, got up, and ran into the house.
BEN
You were playing video games in your room late at night, wearing nothing but a gray hoodie of yours and panties, when BEN appeared behind you, staring down your hoodie. "BEN?!??!! What the fuck are you doing?" You screamed as you paused your game. "Looking at my boos boobs." He said smiling pervertedly. That's when you felt something poke you in the back. "BEN, you have a boner. Leave." You demanded, folding your arms across your chest. "Fine, fine." He said, leaving and covering his... Spot.
Masky
You were getting ready for a party, and you were looking for something to wear. At the moment, you were in lingerie. Masky burst in, seeing you in your bra and panties.
You gasped, and hid behind the closet door. "Masky, Leave!" You yelled, pointing to the door. He rushed out, and you found a beautiful purple dress. Masky was right outside, and you noticed he was facing away from you. "Masky, why are you facing away from me. I wan to see your face, not your butt." You said, placing a hand on his shoulder. He turned around, his hand right over his crotch. "Masky..." You laughed. "I'll be home in a few hours. You kissed his cheek and left.
Hoodie
You guys were cuddling, trying to fall asleep, when you felt something poke your leg. "Hoodie?" You asked. "W-what b-babe?" He asked, facing the other way. "I think.. Um... How do I say this without being awkward?" You blushed. "I know w-what you're t-talking about Y/N." Hoodie then got up, and walked straight to the bathroom. He was there for several minutes until he came back. You never talked about that again.
EJ
You guys were always creating new ways to eat kidneys, when you dropped a kidney on your shirt. You went to go change, when EJ barged in. "Y/N! I just found a new way to-" He was cut off when he saw you topless. "EJ!! Leave!" You pushed him out of the room and put on a shirt. "Why were you peeping on me?" You asked, punching a fist into your hip. "Well... I made a kidney smoothie. I wanted you to try it. But-" You cut him off. "Why are you sitting in that girly position?" He was crossing his legs, in a rather feminine way. "Well I-" he started. "Move your leg EJ." You demanded. He moved his leg, to show a bulge in his pants. "Oh EJ.." You said, facepalming. He then got up, and left for five minutes. It was the most awkward five minutes of your life.
Toby
You guys were being childish, and were out in your yard, having a fight with whipped cream cans in your swimming suits. The rule was, you have to lick off wherever you sprayed whipped cream on. The most awkward so far was when Toby got cream on your lower back. You tripped over a stick and accidentally sprayed cream on his crotch. You guys both blushed. "Lick it..." Toby said, Turning bright red. You reluctantly licked it. So. Awkward. You licked all of the cream off, and continued your fight. Elbow, cheek, foot, wrist, stomach. You know, the average stuff. Then Toby hugged you from behind, and sprayed cream between your breasts. He went in front of you, and licked of all up. "Toby!" You exclaimed. You guys then started chasing each other. He tackled you, and you felt something poke you. You pushed him off, and you both went inside,
Darkness
Darkness got boners regularly. It was usually when you were taking a shower, and he would come in and spy on you, or when he forced his way into a heated make out session.
YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios
Fanficonce upon a time I hated this story and my younger self and took the anger out on you guys, who were also young and new to the world of fandom. i wrote this when I was 11 and as I grew out of it I made some questionable decisions on how to handle my...