Jeff
You were moping around at the park. Why? Because Jeff said he'd meet you here at 3:00 and now it's 3:30.
You sighed, and messed around on your phone when you felt a knife blade poking you gently in the back.
"Jeff?" You said as you turned around.
"Who else could it be?" He chuckled and sat down next to you.
You laughed, and you started scaring all the children in the playground (Because you're just that evil) until a grandmother came up and yelled at you "young hoodlums" for scaring all the "youngsters silly" You guys laughed and walked around town for the rest of the day.
And that moment, when Jeff told a fat kid he needed to lose weight, was the moment you knew you loved Jeff the Killer.
BEN
You were playing Majoras Mask once again, when it started glitching up.
"BEN!" You yelled, and he popped out of the screen making it make that awful screeching noise.
"I thought you'd like to hang out with me today" He said "We'd hang out in here" He was gesturing to the tv.
"Okay!" You said ecstatically. You had always wanted to be in a video game, and how's your chance!
BEN extended his hand and you took it; he dragged you into the game.
It. Was. ERSHERM
BEN made sure to stay by you, he didn't want you getting hurt in this world. He didn't want you to get hurt at all, in any world.
"Y/N, stay by me, he said holding your hand, which made you blush.
He brought you back into the normal world around 9:00 at night.
"Goodnight, Y/N"
"Goodnight, Benny-Boo" You said, teasing him with that nickname he hated,
"GRRRRRR..." He growled slipping back into the TV.
And that moment, when BENS feet slipped into the television, was the moment when you knew you loved BEN drowned.
Masky
He had been coming over everyday, just to eat your delicious cheesecake. One day, he came over in the early morning. He sat in your desk chair, watching you sleep (Sooo creepy!!!!) He walked over to your bed, and kissed your forehead gently.
"Good morning, Strawberry" Strawberry was his nickname for you, because you always drizzled strawberry syrup on your cheesecake and served it with two strawberries.
You fidgeted around and sat up. Masky blushed upon seeing you in your bra.
"M-M-Masky?!?? What are you doing here?!?!?" You exclaimed covering yourself.
"I-I w-was going to a-ask if I could have some c-c-cheesecake, but you were so cute when y-you s-slept, so-" You cut him off. "I don't care what you were don't in here, just please leave for a second so I can get dressed" He scrapped right outside your door and got dressed.
He came back in with Two plates of cheesecake, and you it's hung out in your room eating cheesecake all day.
And that moment, when Masky shoved a piece of cheesecake in your mouth, was the moment you knew you loved Masky.
Hoodie
You guys had been at the cafe everyday, at around 3:00, eating cheesecake. One day, he asked you if you'd like to go somewhere else after this... Snack time? (What else would it be?) Of course, you said yes. He took you to a beautiful field of Wildflowers. He picked a bouquet of them for you, and you hugged him. "Thank you!!" You said while squeezing him.
He was blushing like crazy, but you didn't notice. "Thank you, Hoodie" You said again. "I-I'm g-glad you l-liked t-t-them, Y/N. I-I t-thought t-they w-were b-beautiful, Just l-like y-y-you." You blushed, and kissed his cheek. you guys were there all night. You never got tired of talking to him.
And that moment, when Hoodie pulled you a bit closer, and kept his arm around your waist, was the moment you knew you loved Hoodie.
Eyeless Jack
You were sleeping, when EJ came in through the window. He poked you in the face with the butt end of his scalpel. You woke up, grunting.
"grr... EJ..." You growled. "I was wondering if maybe you'd like to hang out with me? I'm not sure if you like kidneys... But..." You smiled. "Of course I'd like to come, EJ. I'd like to try a kidney. I'm sure they're delicious." He smiled. He said he'd meet you outside, and you got dressed in a hoodie, jeans and converse.
"You look nice" He said reaching for your hand.
"Thank you" you said, allowing him to hold it.
You guys went around, stealing kidneys. You tried one, and... LOVED it. He always gave you the right one, while he took the left. You asked him why
"Because left is a boy and right is a girl" he said. You never questioned him again about that again.
And that moment, when Jack handed you another kidney, was the moment you knew you loved Eyeless Jack
Ticci Toby
You were at the park again, reading your favorite book, when Toby came over.
"H-Hi Y/N!!" He said, sitting down right next to you. "I-I w-was wondering I-I-if maybe y-you'd like t-to hang out with m-me?" You smiled. "Of course I would." You said standing up and putting the book in your purse. He took you through downtown, through all the cute little exotic shops. You bought a lot of stuff with your own money, but he bought you a pair of f/c (favorite color) converse hi-tops. In return, you bought him a t-shirt that said 'waffles are my life' with a kawaii waffle on it.
And the moment he hopped out of the dressing room, with the waffle t shirt on, was the moment you fell in love with Ticci Toby.
Dark link
You were taking a nap one day, when you forgot to turn the console off again. (That's a frequent habit of yours) when Darkness came out to see you again. Instead of being nice and gently waking you up, he grabbed the f/d (favorite drink) from your nightstand. You immediately woke up " WHAT THE HELL DARK!" You yelled. "IM COVERED IN F/D" Darkness was cracking up. You just glared at him "What so funny?" You snapped.
"You. It's hilarious how you're acting. Now, ima take you into my world" he said, and without warning he grabbed your arms and pulled you into his world. It was lovely. He
showed you around. Your favorite part was when he took you to a beautiful lake.
"Oh Link, I love it!" You exclaimed as you threw your arms around his neck.
"Somebody say my name?" A voice said, as Link (the one you play as in LOZ) came around on Epona. Darkness immediately stood up, pulled out his sword and chased after Link. You laughed, as they were behaving like children fighting over a toy.
When Darkness swung his sword high over his head, as Link dodged it, was the moment you realized you loved Dark Link
YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios
Fanficonce upon a time I hated this story and my younger self and took the anger out on you guys, who were also young and new to the world of fandom. i wrote this when I was 11 and as I grew out of it I made some questionable decisions on how to handle my...
