Bucky Barnes & Steve Rogers Imagines (Discontinued)

Decision P.1 (Steve X Reader)

. . . .

Characters Name: (Y/N)

Plot: During A Date Steve Makes A Shocking Decision.

Type: Angst

. . . .

(Y/N) was brave, strong, much stronger than most people Steve knew, and definitely more brave. He knew he had to get to know more about her.

Steve Rogers was the all American good boy, the perfect boy. (Y/N) needed him in her life.

It was no surprise when the two started speaking more and more.

It was no surprise that (Y/N) was the one to ask Steve out.

Their first date was magical. They didn't do the cliché movie or a meal. They went climbing up the side of a waterfall.

They were the couple everyone envied. They could joke around, tease each other and they rarely argued. They knew when they had to be serious and supported each other through thick and thin.

It was obvious the couple were madly in love. Everyone believed nothing could tear them apart.

(Y/N) was sitting down reading a book. She loved to read, especially books about History, not because she was dating Steve, she loved history before she met him.

She often imagined what her life would have been like if she was born a century or two ago.

A smile was on (Y/N)'s face as she thought of all the time Steve spoke of the past. He loved talking about his life before he was frozen.

She fought a frown as she recalled all the times Steve would talk about Peggy.

(Y/N) loved listening to him speak, but when he spoke often and lovingly about his old love, it broke her heart. Steve would never love her like he loved Peggy.

"Hey doll" Steve greeted. "Hi Fossil." Steve laughed as he kissed her forehead.

"What's the plans for today Captain."

Steve froze. (Y/N) knew what that meant. Steve forgot to make plans, again.

It was always (Y/N) who planned the things they did. She knew what they'd both enjoy. It felt like Steve didn't know her anymore.

"If you haven't got anything planned it's fine. I'm sure I can think of something" (Y/N) told him.

"No, no I can think of something. It's my turn. You always pick, I-I mean plan, it's my turn" Steve replied.

"Let me know when you decide and what I need to wear."

Steve's eyes went wide. "I know exactly what we can do" he grinned at her. "I'm all ears."

They got off Steve's motorcycle and Steve grinned. "Follow me Ma'am." (Y/N) followed Steve, she trusted him with her life.

He took her down a small path, holding her hand during all the walk.

(Y/N)'s eyes went wide as he took her into a cave. "Steve Grant Rogers, did you take me to a cave" she asked. "It's more than a cave."

When they got further in (Y/N)'s eyes went wide. She knew where she was, the rumoured enchanted pond.

"Is this what I think it is" (Y/N) asked. "The enchanted pond, rumoured to grant your deepest wish" he whispered in her ear, causing a shiver to go through her body.

"How does it work?" "All you do is step in the pond and it grants your wish."

Steve held out his hand. (Y/N) smiled as she took it and he led her into the pond.

Once they were in the pond a thick mist went around them.

"Steve Rogers, (Y/N) (L/N), two different, yet similar people" a deep voice spoke. "One cares more deeply for the other."

(Y/N) and Steve look at each other confused.

"(Y/N), your deepest wish is so sweet, so pure. You're deepest wish is to have a simple life, without the need to safe the world" the mist went around her as the voice spoke.

The mist went around Steve. "Steve, your deepest wish is to spend one more day with Peggy, back in the 40's."

He looked at (Y/N), who's mouth was open slightly. She was shocked, she knew he loved Peggy, but for that to be his deepest wish, it hurt her.

"I will grant your wish Mr Rogers" the voice spoke. Both (Y/N) and Steve were shocked.

"You will have 24 hours with Miss Carter, back in the 40's." The amount of mist increased as it went around (Y/N).

"However, if you choose to go back I will have to take something from you." "What is it" Steve asked.

"If you go back, you will never meet Miss (L/N) here, you will forget all about her." "Deal."

(Y/N)'s eyes went wide as Steve agreed. She couldn't believe her boyfriend was willing to forget her existence, just to spend one more day with someone else.

"Steve" she couldn't stop the tears falling from her eyes.

"I'm sorry (Y/N), but I'd give anything to spend more time with Peggy. She is my one true love, nothing or no one can change that" he confessed.

He went to touch her cheek but she moved away.

"You'll forget me, you won't remember me" he said. "Oh no, Miss (L/N) here will remember you, but you won't her."

Steve looked up at her. "I'm sorry." "Me too" (Y/N) whispered, confusing Steve.

"I'm sorry I wasn't good enough for you. I'm sorry I will never be Peggy. If you really love her, then go back. I just want you to be happy, even if I'm miserable."

Steve kissed her cheek before smiling. "I have made my decision."

. . . .

. . . .