Creepypasta x Reader Oneshots

I Hate You Masky x Reader

"Masky, (Y/N), you'll be taking the stakeout mission."

Inside, I wanted to protest. Beg Slender not to put me inside a room with that asshole. Masky is insufferable. A self-righteous dumbass with no purpose but to ruin my day. I knew he was smirking behind that stupid mask of his. Carefully strategizing what horrors he was planning to employ on me.

Swallowing my protests, I simply nodded. I saw Masky doing the same out of the corner of my eye.

"Dismissed." Slenderman says, waving his hand at the four of us.

All of us proxies filed one by one out of Slender's office. Hoodie and Toby both quickly left to their respective rooms. I wanted to do the same, but knew I had to discuss things with my fellow proxy.

"You can take one side of the room and I'll take the other. Keep in mind I won't hesitate to fight a girl." Masky spoke. I rolled my eyes. I wasn't going to be the one causing any trouble.

"Finally, someone not afraid of losing." With that, I walked off.

DAY ONE

Masky and I walked in silence. Neither of us willing to speak because it would undoubtedly start a fight.

Plus, he was the silent type.

Upon arriving at the apartment I set my things on the left bed. Masky walked in shortly after myself.

"I want that bed!" He whines. I glare at him. "Why? They're the same." I deadpanned.
"This one has a giant stain!" He yells. I look over, and sure enough there's a giant brown stain in the middle of the sheets on his bed.

I grin. "First come first serve."

I could feel his glare on my back as I turn to unpack my things. All of a sudden I feel strong hands on my waist as I'm lifted up and thrown onto Masky's bed. Right. On. The. Stain.

"MASKY!" I squealed. I look over to see him lying on my bed. I could feel his dumb grin from across the room.

DAY TWO

Masky's P.O.V

It was pitch black outside. I was staring out the window looking for any signs of movement. Thank god I can see in the dark. (Y/N) and I are supposed to be looking for a rumoured new creepypasta that seemed to target people living alone. The building across the way was full of them. I look to (Y/N)'s sleeping body on her bed. Her eyes were closed, and her face was just...so at peace. A smile crossed my face as I stared at her. I knew I'd fallen in love with her, I just couldn't ever admit it. She despises me and I know it's my own fault.

My smile twists into a frown. I have to wake her for her shift soon. I dejectedly turn my head to gaze out the window once more.

DAY THREE

"That was my goddamn cheesecake." Masky growls.

I slowly slide another forkful in my mouth.
"Oh was it?" I laugh, mouth full.

"Oh you're gonna pay." He lunges at me as I shriek.

DAY FOUR

"Move." Masky sneers.

"No I got here first." I reply.

"Fine then." He mutters.

I was calmly trying to brush my teeth when Masky decided he wanted to do the same. He refused to wait his turn.

He walked up behind me and reached for his tooth brush. I could feel his 'ahem' against my butt. My face exploded in red.

He proceeded to nonchalantly brush his teeth. Once I finished I turned to leave, but soon found I couldn't.

Masky's arms were locked on the countertop, boxing me in. He stared at me, lips parted slightly. His mask was lifted to expose his mouth. My face was bright red as I stared up at him.

He slowly leaned down, arm lifting to my waist. I used this opportunity to slip out of his arms.

I run out of the bathroom, face ablaze with anger and embarrassment. Masky calls my name from the bathroom.

"(Y/N)!" He yells, chasing after me.

I turn to face him. "Why?" I ask, glaring at his frame.

"Why what?" He asks confusedly.

"Why are you being like," I gesture to him, "this! Flirty and being nicer than usual! And don't think I don't know you watch me sleep!"

Masky freezes, before advancing on me. I let him back me up into the wall. He reaches up to his mask and lifts it off.

His chocolate brown eyes meet my own (E/C) ones. I'm taken aback by how handsome he is.

His eyes are half liddled as he looks at me. He pins both of my arms to the side. "Because I love you." His eyes widen, as if he's shocked by the words that came out of his mouth. However, he couldn't be more so than I. He goes to pull away, after receiving no response from me. I quickly grab his shoulders and pull him towards me.

His lips meet mine in an awkward kiss. I pull away, staring at him. He stares back. This doesn't last long as he pulls me in for a second, more passionate kiss. His arms wrap around me to hold me against his body. My arms wrap around his neck as I moan into his mouth.

He lifts me up and I wrap my legs around his waist. Masky pulls away from my lips and immediately attacks my neck with feverish bites and kisses. My lips part and I let soft moans escape me. This only encourages him and he bites more aggressively.

"M-Masky~" I whimper.

"Tim." He mumbles against the soft flesh of my neck.

He bites my neck, holding on and sucking.

"A-ah! Tim!" I moan.

He grabs my ass, supporting me as he pulls away from the wall. I squeak after he throws me on the bed. Tim stands at the edge of the bed, taking in my slightly parted legs, flushed face, and neck covered in hickeys. He slowly climbs over top of me, reminding me vaguely of a predator. His leg slips between mine as he connects our lips once more. His hands slowly trail down my body.

"AH! TIM!"



Ben: Wow, sexual.
Joy: The request was a lemon. I didn't wanna be mean and entirely ignore that.
Masky: I don't enjoy my features being shared Joy.
Joy: Awe calm down Masky-boy. It turns on a lot of teenage girls!
Masky: O/////O
Jeff: You're embarrassing him.
Slender: TWO PROXIES?!?!? FORNICATING?!?!!?! NOT IN MY DAMN HOUSE!!!
Joy: Oops.
Slender: WHAT NEXT?!?!?!? HOODIE AND TOBY?!?!?!
Hoodie: My partner must have some dignity sir. Not to mention a brain.
Toby: Hey! I have din-gity.
Hoodie: I rest my case.

Requested by Marionette352