Free! x Reader Boyfriend Scenarios {UNDER EDITING} REQUESTS CLOSED

When You Date Their Rival Character (Iwatobi)

This scenario was requested by @ReeKleinS2, sorry for the long wait! Hope you enjoy!

Haru: You'd date Kisumi. He was a total playboy, and you knew his antics, but somehow you managed to fall for him anyways. When he asked you out, you were a bit hesitant, but you said yes anyways. After you started dating you thought that you weren't good enough and he was out cheating when he wasn't with you, or at school, or at practice. What you didn't know was that once he was committed in a relationship, he was as loyal as a dog, with the exception of flirting with other girls once in awhile. Dating Kisumi would include him being distant once in awhile and you would think he's cheating, but in reality, he was just planning a nice date for you because he thinks you've been working too hard. For example, for weeks on end, Kisumi was being distant. He would only say a quick hello to you in the morning and sit with you at lunch, but otherwise he was MIA. Turns out he was working overtime to make money for a nice venue he wanted to take you to. The night of your date, Kisumi called you and told you to dress up and to meet him at a certain restaurant that was fairly expensive. When you got there, the place was decorated with beautiful lights, and there was a path made of rose petals. At the end of the path, Kisumi was holding a bundle of flowers and smiling brightly at you.

Makoto: You'd date Nitori. Nitori was caring and a hopeless romantic. He would do the sweetest gestures for you and he was the dream boyfriend for you. Not too tall, not too short. Although, he was kind of on the short side, but he was perfect for you. You favorite thing to do together is to cuddle up in comfy pajamas and watch movies all day while eating snacks. The one downside to this is that, you can't watch horror movies with Nitori. What you saw in the movies deceived you. You'd sometimes envy the girls in the movies, because their boyfriends would hold them as they watched horror movies together, whisper caring words to them when they were scared, being their castle, and reassuring them that they would be alright. When you were with Nitori, he was just as scared as you were. Crying, whimpering, and hiding under blankets. Nitori soon noticed that you were longingly at the girls whose boyfriends held them during horror movies and he felt guilty. "Hey, (y/n), am I manly enough for you? Am I not the strong knight that in shining armor that you hoped to have one day? If not, I'm sorry to have let you down," Nitori told you one day. "Nitori, of course you're manly enough, and you're my dream boyfriend, why?" You asked. "Because I see you staring at the girls in the movies with their boyfriends and I feel like I just don't match up," Nitori responded, quietly. Now it was your turn to feel a little guilty. "No, don't ever think you're not enough, Nitori. I love you for you and if I didn't, why would I have gone out with you in the first place?" You told him. "Are you sure I'm enough?" Nitori replied. "You're everything I've ever hoped for and more."

Nagisa: You'd date Sousuke. When you first met Sousuke, he was mysterious; he was manly; he was strong; he was brave; he was your dream guy. After you guys started dating, you got him to loosen up around you and he became less mysterious, but he was still manly, and strong, and everything you'd hope for in a guy and more. Sousuke was the silent type. He's your guardian angel, the one that watches over you and is at your side when you needed him. Many girls swooned over Sousuke, but he ignored them. His heart and eyes were for you and only you. When you saw the girls swarm to him, and you'd feel a pang of jealousy; but as you looked at him, he stood taller than everyone else; but not because he actually was taller than everyone else. It was because his personality was harsh and cold, and he was like a wall, blocking them all from coming in. However, as soon as you were alone, he would be the most open person. You guys would cuddle, or cook, or play video games, and you would be having the time of your life, all because Sousuke was there with you.

Rei: You'd date Rin. Rin was cocky and confident in everything he did. He would be confident that he would succeed in anything he did, and his confidence wasn't faltered when it came to you. At first when you guys met, he was cocky and arrogant and gave off a jerk-like vibe. You didn't want anything to do with him. Eventually, he continued to weasel in way into heart. One date became two and your friendship blossomed into a relationship. You were stubborn and didn't give in easily. Your personalities clashed often and it usually resulted in petty fights. "Rin, did you eat the last donut?" You called from the kitchen. "Yeah, why?" He replied. "It was mine and we agreed on that!" You screamed. "Well, it's too late now, isn't it?" Rin asked. "You're so annoying!" You said, pulling out the last piece of cake that Rin was saving for later. You were nearly done eating it when Rin walked into the kitchen. "Hey! That's my cake!" He exclaimed. "Well it's mine now," you said, shoving the last of it in your mouth. "I bet you regretted taking that donut now, huh," You retorted. Rin scoffed, "as if, I'll make you pay tonight," he smirked. "Nope. No action for you," you said. Placing the plate and fork in the sink. "We'll see about that," Rin told you. That night Rin ended getting what he wanted, because, whatever Rin wants, Rin gets.

Why I chose those boys:

Haru/Kisumi
• They are somewhat rivals in the show, although it is more known that Rin is Haru's 'rival'
• I didn't do Rin, because I wanted to throw a curveball at you guys
• Kisumi is also different from Haru; louder, flirtier, more pervy

Makoto/Nitori
• For some reason I wanted to do one where their personalities are similar
• Their personalities are similar, but their physical traits are not
• Nitori is cute and he deserves a scenario

Nagisa/Sousuke
• Both their personalities and physical characteristics are opposites
• Sousuke is taller, more muscular
• Sousuke is more mysterious and quiet

Rei/Rin
• Rin is cockier and has more confidence then Rei
• Their personalities are different, so is how they carry themselves
• Rei has a straighter posture, and carries himself professionally
• Rin is more carefree and carries himself with a cooler attitude