Sofia the First: The Alien Prince

Sofia isn't convinced

Later, James, Sofia, Hildegard, and Amber flew back to Enchancia Castle, and now Amber and Hildegard were ready to tell Sofia what they found out about her boyfriend.

"Sofia, are you ready?" Hildegard asked.

"What for?" Sofia asked.

"You heard us say that we have something to tell you, and I said it's best to share it with you at home, and here we are," Amber declared.

"Okay, let me hear," Sofia declared.

"Well, we found out that Hugo and his family are evil aliens," Hildegard revealed.

Sofia was shocked to hear that. "Unbelievable!" she gasped.

"Yes, we know," Hildegard said.

"I can't believe we never knew he was an alien," Amber chimed in.

But Sofia wasn't talking about the theory. "No, not that—I can't believe you actually think Hugo is an evil alien!" she growled. "What, are you trying to spread a rumor about him?"

Amber and Hildegard were shocked that Sofia was angry with them for telling her this.

"No, we're not spreading a rumor—it's true that Hugo is an alien," Amber said.

"Amber, I don't know where you got this idea or why you believe it, but you really need to get out of your fantasy world," Sofia frowned.

"But, Sofia, this is for your own good," Hildegard protested.

"You call this good?" Sofia glowered. "If this is your idea of trying to get me to break up with Hugo, you girls are out of your minds!" Then she stormed away, leaving Amber and Hildegard shocked.

James had heard the conversation, and he wasn't happy. "You just can't resist, can you?" he asked.

"Resist what?" Amber asked.

"You're trying to trick Sofia into thinking Hugo is an alien, so she could break up with him and one of you could get him for yourself," James scolded the girls.

"But that's not true—he really is an alien, and Sofia doesn't know that," Amber protested. "Well, we just told her the truth, but she got mad and didn't listen."

"Why should she?" James frowned. "She's smart—I suppose after the way you treated her when she first came to the castle, she's not going to fall for another one of your pranks. If you really want Sofia to believe that Hugo is an alien, you need some proof. Remember when you left all your tiaras scattered in your room and thought your emerald tiara was stolen? You accused Sofia of stealing it because her Emerald Green With Envy tiara looked almost like yours—except hers is gold with darker emeralds, and the edges around the jewels were rounder. That wasn't real proof she stole it. It turned out your real tiara was buried under the other ones. You wouldn't have blamed Sofia for that had you cleaned your room in the first place."

Amber was hurt by what James said—he assumed that Amber was trying to play another prank on their younger sister. He retreated to his room, leaving his twin sister shocked. Then Amber and Hildegard went to the former's bedroom, thinking about this.

"James is right—we need to prove to Sofia that Hugo really is an alien," Amber declared.

"But how exactly are we going to prove to her that Hugo is an alien?" Hildegard asked.

"I read in Hugo's diary that the Olympians' choice of food is air freshener, which is consumed by spraying it in the air and sniffing it through their noses," Amber said.

"We should check it out—Sofia is planning on seeing him again tomorrow," Hildegard said.

"Great, then we'll prove to Sofia that he really is an alien," Amber nodded.