Mermaid from Hell ~BEN Drowned x Siren! Reader~ [DISCONTINUED]

2. Mystery Girls

3rd Person POV
Once Jeff, Sally and BEN got back to the mansion, Slender was there already, quicker than usual when there is some business with his brothers.

"Slendy!" Sally yelled as she ran to him and literally pounced and latched onto his leg, the boys followed shortly after.

"Sally? What's wrong?" Slender asked as Sally's grip tightened on his leg, clearly showing she was scared. "What did you 2 do to her?" Slender questioned the boys in a threatening tone. Jeff and BEN put their hands up in surrender.

"They did nothing Slendy. It was 2 girls in the lake with fishtails instead of legs. They were screeching really loudly and it hurt my ears." Sally whined and she looked up at the tall creature but his head stayed focussed on the boys.

"In other words, we found sirens in the lake. They started singing but since we had Sally, she heard shrieking so I knew straight away." Jeff piped in and BEN nodded.

"Ok, I'll have Masky, Toby and Hoodie take a look." He said as he pat Sally's head. "Sally, how about you go see Dark and Electric Shock? Their PDA is doing my head in..." Slender grumbled as he rubbed his forehead. BEN rolled his eyes.

"I regret ever letting them date. She knows I hate Dark but no, I had to so she wouldn't hate me." BEN added, crossing his arms. Sally nodded and let go of Slender's leg and ran off giggling.

"You 2 are gonna go with the other 3." Slender informed BEN and Jeff and they groaned.

"But I wanna play video games." BEN whined as he pouted and Jeff yawned.

"Yeah, and I wanna sleep." He stated as he stretched. Slender sighed.

"If Sally can't get Dark Link and your sister to have a tea party with her, do you really wanna see them sucking each others faces off?" Slender asked and BEN contemplated the thought before cringing and shaking his head violently. "Exactly. And Jeff, go get my proxies, then you can go on a mission for me, I sense 2 auras in the forest. 2 girls." He added and Jeff nodded before walking out, but not without being knocked down by a green flash, followed by 2 small beings trampling him.

"Ugh... the hell..?" Jeff mumbled, holding his head and sitting up then looking behind him.

"Slender! Tell Sally to leave us alone!" The green flash whined before materialising into BEN's sister, Electric Shock, floating near the ceiling while her elf like boyfriend, Dark Link, was being squeezed by Sally.

"No. It's for the sake of everyone's eyes." Slender replied and the floating girl pouted.

"Shockie! Help me! I can't breathe!" Dark choked out and Electric Shock helped him out of the young girls death grip. Sally pouted and reached up for them both.

"Play with me!" She shrieked, jumping for them. Electric Shock rolled her eyes and started to fly away until a tendril wrapped around her leg and pulled her back. She screamed as she got threw to the floor.

"Just play with her or I'll ban you from seeing each other for a month." Slender threatened and Electric Shock pouted.

"Fine..." She mumbled in defeat and got up.

"I wouldn't mind the month ban." BEN piped in and his sister's head shot in his direction then her face lit up.

"Hey Benny!" She yelled happily before putting Dark down and tackling him in a hug. He returned the hug and gave Dark a smug look. "Slender, can't I be with Ben instead of Sally? I never hang out with him." She asked/stated and Slender contemplated and nodded as Dark's jaw dropped before pouting.

"You're leaving me with a hyperactive 8 year old?!" He exclaimed, being childish. His girlfriend giggled then turned to him.

"Don't worry Darkie, I'll be with you again before you know it. I just wanna spend some time with my brother." She reassured before kissing his head. Dark nodded glumly and walked off with Sally following.

BEN's POV
As Dark trudged out the kitchen in defeat of losing my sister and gaining Sally, Masky, Hoodie and Toby walked in.

"You wanted us?" Masky asked and Slender nodded.

"BEN and Jeff informed me that the lake not far from here has sirens lurking in it. I want you guys, along with BEN and his sister, to find them." He ordered and they nodded before walking out, followed by us.

—— TIME SKIP BC CBA TO WRITE THE JOURNEY ——

We arrived at the lake and I was clinging onto Twyly for dear life as we searched the lake.

"There's nothing here." Hoodie piped up as he looked at Masky, who agreed.

"But we definitely saw some! They were on those rocks!" I exclaimed, pointing to the rocks we saw them on and Twyly floated over to inspect them.

"There's nothing on here. No scales or anything." She said as she looked over at the proxies and they nodded slowly.

"I guess there was a false alarm." Toby sighed as I was still searching the rock, only t find something.

"Aha!" I shouted and picked up a piece of jet black hair off the rock. "I found something Masky!" I shouted as Twyly floated back and gently put me on the floor before I ran to Masky and gave him the hair.

"Ok, this is odd." He mumbled before putting it in his pocket. "Let's head back and show Slender." He stated and started walking back.

—— TIME SKIP AGAIN BC I CAN ——

We got back to the mansion and walked inside, only to be met with 2 girls. One with snow white, messy, shoulder length hair and super pale skin and one with jet black, wavy, waist length hair and slightly tanned skin. Their clothes were all torn and ripped with blood all over them.

"Uhh... Who are they?" Toby asked and Slender stood behind the girls.

"These are Sirena and Y/n. They're gonna be new Creepypastas!" He announced and all our jaws dropped, except my sister who was, glaring?

———————————————————————