Mermaid from Hell ~BEN Drowned x Siren! Reader~ [DISCONTINUED]

3. How Can They Become Creepypastas??

BEN's POV
Masky, Hoodie, Toby and I stood by the door with our jaws on the floor. Slender wanted to make 2 random girls one of us?

"Slender, why would you wanna make these girls one of us?" My sister asked with slight bitterness in her voice before crossing her arms.

"Because, they apparently challenged Jeff and hurt him pretty badly. I see potential." He replied and she growled before walking off, probably to find Dark.

"Someone doesn't like us." The one with wavy hair mumbled and her voice was so angelic that my immediately mind went blank.

Y/n's POV
Before we came to this creepy mansion, a snow white, smiley faced guy tried to kill us but we put up a fight before we spoke to him and he was immediately under our control. Just the very sound of our voices will put any guy under a trance and they'll be nice to us, so we asked to take us back to where he lived and he agreed.

—— Flashback ——

"So, what's your name?" My sister asked and the smiley faced freak smiled more.

"Jeff, Jeff the Killer. What are your names?" He replied/asked before sighing dreamily at my sister. I guess she got to him first.

"Mine is Sirena, and this is my younger sister, Y/n." She replied and he nodded.

"Beautiful names for beautiful girls." He complemented and Sirena giggled. She has definitely found her next victim.

"Thanks, yours is cute too." She complemented, smiling. I just walked awkwardly as they flirted before we came across a large mansion.

"We're here, follow me." Jeff said as he lead us inside. "Let me just go get Slender." He added and walked off. I looked around before Sirena grabbed my shoulders.

"Isn't he cute?" She asked, probably referring to Jeff. I shrugged and looked around at the people here. I saw an emo like elf playing with a young girl. I walked over to them and tapped the elfs shoulder then he turned around.

"Can I help you?" He asked and I smiled at him.

"My sister and I are new here. Jeff bought us and I was wondering if you wanted to be friends?" I asked and he just stared at me while the little girl glared. I forgot girls instantly don't like us.

"Uhh... Why did you come straight to me?" The elf asked and I shrugged. My power clearly wasn't affecting him but I don't know why.

"You guys where the closest people here." I replied and the little girl rolled her eyes.

"Well we don't wanna be friends with you!" She shouted as she got up and dragged the elf away from me. I rolled my eyes and walked back to my sister.

"So, how did that go?" She asked and I shook my head.

"My power didn't affect him in the slightest." I replied and she sighed.

"That means that he already loves someone and their bond is strong." She told me and I nodded, understandingly. After, Jeff came back with a super tall, faceless man.

"Hello sir." Sirena greeted so he wouldn't question us.

"Hello girls. What brings you here?" The man asked and I piped up.

"Our friend Jeff bought us here." I replied and the creature nodded.

"Yes, I saw how badly you 2 beat him up. You have potential." He informed us and we gave him a weird look.

"Potential for what sir?" Sirena asked and he leaned down to our height.

"The potential of becoming a Creepypasta of course!" He exclaimed and Jeff ran in and jumped up and down next to Sirena.

"So can the stay Slender? Can they, can they?!" Jeff asked, acting like a child and the creature named Slender nodded. Just as Jeff was about to jump around again, the door opened, revealing 4 boys and 1 girl, but one stood out and was really cute. A blonde version of the emo elf.

—— Flashback end ——

Since that girl with pigtails left, the blonde elf walked up to me. He was a little small but he reached my shoulder.

"H-Hey." He stuttered and I smiled at him.

"Hi, what's your name?" I asked and he started shifting his weight from one leg to another, clearly showing nervousness.

"I'm B-BEN Drowned." He stuttered again and my smile dropped a little. He drowned? Poor thing. I definitely can NOT fall for him! I don't wanna drown him again. "A-Are you Y/n or S-Sirena?" He added and I shook my head slightly.

"I'm Y/n. Sirena is my older sister." I replied and he nodded.

"I have an older sister too!" He exclaimed and I tilted my head.

"Who?" I asked and he looked around before rolling his eyes and walking somewhere. My head followed to where he was walking and I saw the girl with pigtails and the emo elf, she had her legs crossed with the elf sat in the gap of her legs, kissing her neck, collarbone and shoulders as she giggled quietly. 'Now I see why my magic didn't work on him, he must really love her.' I thought before seeing BEN pull the emo elf off the girl and drag the girl off the couch while the emo elf pouted. BEN pulled her towards me and she was Huge, height wise.

"Y/n, this my sister, Electric Shock!" He exclaimed and I just stared between her and BEN. HE'S ONLY UP TO HER HIPS IN SIZE! Electric Shock rolled her eyes.

"Do you wanna picture? It'll last longer." She snarled and I shook my head. BEN looked up at her and frowned.

"Shockie! I'm getting lonely over here!" The emo elf yelled, pouting. Electric Shock looked back at him.

"Give me a minute Darkie." She replied and 'Darkie' just sat on the couch, acting like a child as she turned back and looked down at BEN. "Don't give me that look Benny." She mumbled as BEN frowned more.

"Be nice to her. Please?" He whined, giving her some big cute eyes which she sighed at and nodded, almost defeated.

"Fine... Just for you... Now can I go back before Dark starts acting like a baby? Not that I mind but still." She asked and BEN smiled and nodded. She smiled and literally Flew back to the emo elf dubbed 'Dark' and pinned him before getting pinned herself and having her neck attacked by Dark's lips. BEN rolled his eyes.

"That's your sister?" I asked and he nodded. "What a ray of sunshine." I said sarcastically and BEN gasped and turned around.

"She is a ray of sunshine! She's a lovely girl!" He yelled and I raised my eyebrow at him.

"Then why does she hate me?" I asked and fluttered my eyes at him.

"She hates all new people. She did it to Rebecca, E.J's girlfriend." He replied and I nodded understandingly.

"So she just has to get used to me?" I asked and he nodded. I looked back up at the 2 on the couch to find them cuddling. "They're a cute couple." I chimed and BEN scoffed.

"They can't keep their hands off each other. I'm surprised there isn't little versions of them running around yet." He said bitterly and I giggled. I'm guessing they heard BEN because his sister blushed and Dark just stared at him like he was planning and watching his death again.

"Uhhh... Why do you say that Benny?" His sister asked and he shrugged.

"Because you're literally attached at the hip. How can you guys not have kids yet?" He asked them and they looked at each other then back at BEN.

"Do you want us to have kids?" Dark asked and smirked at BEN and his girlfriend blushed darker. BEN contemplated then shook his head and they both sighed before Dark snuggled up with his girlfriend as she giggled.

I think I'll like it here, but... I think I'm falling for BEN already...

———————————————————————

Before you ask, yes I'm crossing all my x Readers in these books