All Our Souls

Author's Opinion: Gamora

Is Gamora's soul trapped inside the Soul Stone?

There has been some debate as to whether or not Gamora is trapped inside the soul realm with the other beings affected by the snap or not. I wanted to talk about it because I referenced it and will reference it in this book. So is she in that same realm?

Actually, backtrack, where did this whole idea of the soul realm come from? Is it confirmed by Marvel or the Russo brothers?

That's what we're talking about today! Pay attention, Marvel Cinematic Students, there'll be a quiz on this tomorrow.

(Not really, I'm joking but I'm also not THAT mean.)

Get back on track, the viewers are getting bored of you carrying on! Oh, hey viewers! It's Deadpool here and I -

Shut up Wade! They don't want you carrying on either!

Ooh, look, readers! She gave me the special italic font! Fancy!

Mr. Wilson, you will be paying to fix the wall this time.

Which wall?

The fourth wall.

Fourth wall my ass! Why do we even need that thing if I just keep breaking it? Also, you know what? You break it too! Therefore, I should not be the only one held responsible!

Wade, I'm the author. It's different.

Well, Miss Author, if you really are the author, I hope you've written me right.

We are not going through this right now.

No, it's just that I know you worry about your writing and if it's bad or not and if you've written the characters the right way, so I know I can annoy you with that fact! I hope you got me right, but would I know if I wasn't written right? Hm... I'll save that to ponder later when I'm not annoying you or kicking someone else's ass. I have to say, though, your Peter Parker writing is -

Wade! Stop! I actually have something to talk about today!

Really? Well if you ask me, talking to me is probably a lot more interesting than talking about one of your bullcrap theories. They suck.

Thanks for your support, now go away so I can talk about one of my "bullcrap theories." Don't give me those puppy eyes, maybe I'll let you come back later. Depends on what the readers think.

But -

Nope. None of that. I am the author and I have the power to take you out of this book all together, so I suggest you shut your mouth before I shut it for you by deleting you from my book.

You can't do that!

I can and will.

F*** you!

Same to you, buddy. Now let me talk.

Thank you. Anyway, where were we? Ah, yes. Where did he theory of the soul realm even come from?

According to an article on nerdist.com, the Soul Stone has been known in the comics to hold the souls of its victims, so the whole "soul realm" thing is the real deal.

Also, in a Q&A with the Russo brothers, they confirmed the theory that Thanos's "vision" with young Gamora was not a vision, but Thanks visiting her in the soul realm.

From this we can confirm that Gamora is definitely present in the soul world. This is contrary the what many people believe, as they believe Gamora is not in the soul world and all the others affected by the snap are.

Nerdist.com, however, wonders if those affected by the snap would be in the soul realm, not confirming or denying it.

I believe that they are in the soul realm because they are victims of the soul stone, because all the stones worked together to perform the action of the snap. As we know from the comics, the souls of the victims of the soul stone are trapped inside it. This is what I believe, so that's how I depict it.

This brings up another question - is Loki in the soul realm? Short answer - no. This is because Loki was killed before Thanos possessed any of the Infinity Stones, specifically the Soul Stone, so his soul was not preserved in the soul realm. Also, I have a different theory for what actually happened to Loki, but that's a story for a different part. (Hehe)

This also brings up the speculation of dead people returning, which in my opinion is plausible and likely what ends up happening. Gamora was resurrected from the soul realm in the comics, so the speculation is either that time travel or ressurection from the soul stone is what happens in Endgame. I don't know, though, if they just turn back time that's a little boring, so I don't know what I want to happen.

Anyway, that's my theory, that Gamora and all others affected by the snap are in the soul realm together, and Loki isn't for a number of reasons. If you don't agree, that's cool, but it's how I depict it.

Vote if you want more of this sadness, and also it will be a decision whether or not Mr. Wilson comes back. Depends on how he fits and how well anyone reading takes it.

Can I come back now?

No.

F*** you.

I don't care.

Comment and tell me if you'd like the Merc with the Mouth to return, and vote for more. Check out my other books, one about your romance with Peter Parker and one of Peter and Shuri being BFFs and meme machines. They're kinda cool. Just saying.