Why Don't We Imagines and Preferences *ON HIATUS*

Hard (song series)

(A/n: again, since it's a song, the order will be different to match the song)

Jack: It was my birthday, right at the end of the night, it was the first time he hurt you bad and you cried

It was Jack's birthday and he had invited you to his house, along with his family and the other Why Don't We boys, but you had to unfortunately skip the party. 

You realized after he invited you that your boyfriend told you he needed to talk to you about something important. Max took you to dinner, a fancy place for the first time since you started dating, and he said that he'd buy you anything you wanted on the menu. You figured that it was purely because something had happened. 

You had recently had a birthday as well, and Max had to miss the party for a "family thing", so you thought it was just a way of making it up to you. That wasn't the case. After you finished eating, while you were waiting for the check, he sprung it on you that the night of your birthday party, he wasn't at a "family thing". 

Instead, he was at a party of his own. And he kissed another girl. He didn't go into detail, but based on Max's history, you assumed it went further than a kiss. You might have forgiven him if he seemed to regret it at all, but no. Instead, beyond his frown, his eyes seemed happy. 

Of course, you left him there in the restaurant, deciding against causing a scene by slapping him.

By this point, it was about 11 and you assumed Jack's party was close to over, so you went to his house. You figured he would be there for you. 

You knocked on his door and when he saw you, he was prepared to be mad at you for ditching him on his birthday for a boyfriend that was a jerk to Jack anyway, but when he saw your tears, he changed his mind. 

He simply comforted you. Helping you dry your tears and convincing you that it wasn't your fault. But through it all, he wished he hadn't fallen for you. It only made seeing you broken like that worse.

Corbyn: Do you know how hard it is to be the one to fix you and all you do is run back to the one who breaks your heart 

Corbyn had been your friend since kindergarten. He had always been there for you, and when you started dating Kade, he still tried to make sure you were ok. Problem being that Kade was a jerk and broke your heart. 

Same with Josh...and Marcus...and Ian. 

Whenever you would get your heart broken, he would only be there for you more. Eventually though, you found Aiden. Aiden was the perfect boyfriend. Or, at least, seemed as such. 

But after going on a few dates with him, he started flirting with other girls, paying more attention to your dog than to you, and only replying to text messages if he can respond with 2 letter answers. You could only put up with this for so long, so you dumped him. 

It really hurt though. Not because you were in love with him or anything, but because you thought that maybe he would be your first good boyfriend. After being broken hearted for a while, you finally tried to get over him. 

So, you went to a party with Corbyn. But you saw someone there. Aiden. He was sitting alone on a couch with a drink in his hand and a bored look on his face. You tried to avoid making eye contact, but he soon saw you and instead of forgetting about seeing you like you wished he would have, he approached you, a smirk playing on his lips. Corbyn groaned inwardly as soon as he saw the sleazbag and tried to pull you away but you seemed to want to talk to him, so he didn't stop you. 

After talking to Aiden, you forgave him for what he put you through and he asked you if you wanted to give it another try. You agreed. 

Unfortunately, he didn't change for you like you had hoped and you ended up crying over him again. And of course, your best friend was there for you. Corbyn helped you pick up the pieces of your broken heart and never said "I told you so." This happened multiple times, over the course of a few more years, but overtime, Corbyn was wearing down. He couldn't do it anymore. He couldn't fix what this guy did and then have you go back to him.