"Hey. Look who finally decided to show up," hummed a familiar, playful voice. It was none other than Kenny McCormick, one of Craig's close friends. He had that giant smirk on his face that was hidden behind his orange jacket. He'd always had a habit of sticking his nose where it didn't belong, so he immediately went over to Craig and Tweek with a curious gaze. "Hm, I didn't know you had a date with such a cutie, Craig," Kenny teased lightly, eyeing Tweek up and down. Tweek blushed when Kenny looked at him that way.
"We aren't dating, asshole. He is my friend. You probably remember each other, honestly, considering what a small school South Park is," Craig blushed furiously and refuted his commented.
"Ack!" Tweek squeaked loudly, jumping at being complimented by the kind of attractive Kenny, who was Craig's friend, instinctively and accidentally bumping into the Craig and falling forward toward the guy. Kenny was taken aback as the blonde suddenly fell towards him. He reached his arms out to catch Tweek, letting him fall gently against his warm chest. Kenny blinked, his blue eyes meeting another pair of sparkling, blue eyes that belonged to the other blonde. He smiled softly. Tweek blushed a bit, unable to properly function
"Whoa, you okay? It's a good thing I have good reflexes, huh?" he smirked playfully. Tweek should not feel what he was feeling when this man held him, but he suddenly couldn't breathe as he was looking into the beautiful eyes of the man. Kenny had seriously matured both physically and a little mentally by this year and fuck.. He looked so much older and.. more mature than most of the guys st school. What was Tweek thinking? He was in love with Craig, right? Someone can't feel anyway like that for two people and he also didn't even know thatmuch about Kenny anymore. They hadn't exactly hung out ever besides the few times in elementary school when Stan's gang . What the hell was Tweek's brain doing and what did his body want?
"I'm so sorry! I- I didn't mean- sorry.." Tweek spluttered at the taller guy with a bright red face. Kenny smirked some more at the blonde, taking his hand to plant a gentle kiss to it to tease this unclaimed cutie.Tweek squealed at Kenny when he kissed his hand and it was like a fire in his body and it made him so much fidgety than he usually was. He backed away just barely so he was between Craig and Kenny because he couldn't breathe or even try to concentrate with Kenny so fucking close to him. Tweek was so shocked that anyone else could have this impression on him besides Craig.
"It's no problem, hot stuff- ow! Craig!" Kenny spoke before whining at getting a smack on the head from his friend who looked a bit frustrated with him.
"Quit being weird and make a regular first impression for once. Jesus," Craig scolded him and shook his head, rolling his eyes as well. Kenny only laughed.
"Okay, okay. Geez, Craig. I'm Kenny McCormick by the way~ it's a pleasure to see you again, Tweek. I'm sure we will have loads of fun hanging out and whatnot! Also, if you ever need any good porno mags, I've got tons of limited edition stuff if you want the goods. All the titties, my bro. All of them. Unless you would like guy mags-ow! Craig cut it out!! That hurt," he fake sniffled and pouted over at Craig and back to Tweek. Tweek shook his head and made a noise.
"Jesus, Kenny, let's just go already," Craig said, so done with Kenny's shit already. He sighed softly.
"I-I don't want any- any- any of that!" Tweek told Kenny with a bright face.
"Good. Don't tempt Kenny, Tweek. Please don't ever be tainted by his evil ways," Craig joked, earning a smirk from Kenny. Then, Kenny decided to wrap his arm around Tweek's shoulder as they began walking into the house.
"Oh, I can definitely help taint that pure, sweet, and innocent soul of yours, Tweek~" he teased with a wink down at Tweek. Tweek felt electricity flowing over the skin where Kenny's long arm touched and he suddenly had the thought that he wanted to touch more of Kenny's skin before making himself control his horny ass thoughts. He barely knew Kenny and here he was. He'd been in love with Craig Tucker for so long and it wasn't ever requited so maybe he could just be Craig's friend? Maybe letting Kenny be like this might help Tweek get over Craig and let him even be around Craig without feeling so many bittersweet feelings. Craig was straight, he told himself again. He thought he'd heard about him dating a couple girls here and there over the many years now and Tweek didn't know what he should do and he didn't know what he wanted. He did know he loved Craig and that he wasn't ever even a possibility for Craig Tucker. Kenny on the other hand... He blushed as he let Kenny keep his arm around him and tried to breathe normally after the flirty remark about tainting his soul.

YOU ARE READING
Why Not Both?
FanfictionAfter not talking to Craig Tucker for so long, since their fake dating days, when they were the best of friends, Tweek finds himself sitting 'alphabetically" on the first day of their senior year of high school. Enter Kenny McCormick.