The gifted awards (closed)

How judging works

Each judge will be given 10 books to read from one of their chosen genres. They will then have to read the first 5 chapters of each, or 3 chapters if it's short story. Then, fill in the scorecard down below and pm it to this account. You will be given a deadline for when this has to be done, once which books you have to judge are announced. You may have an extension, but only if there's a valid reason. And please be honest.

Fiction
Title (5)
Blurb (5)
Cover (5)
Descriptions (10)
Grammar, punctuation and spelling (10)
Plot (15)
Character development (10)
Originality/creativity (10)
Vocabulary (5)
Writing style (10)
Overall impression (15)
(Out of 100)
Judges comment: (please leave a comment that contains something kind and something constructive)

Poetry
Title (5)
Summary (5)
Cover (5)
Vocabulary (10)
Message (10)
Spelling, punctuation and grammar (10)
Writing style (10)
Originality/creativity (10)
Overall impression (15)
(Out of 80)
Judges comment: (please leave a comment that contains something kind and something constructive).

Once all the genre winners are announced, we will look over all the scorecards, and whoever scored the highest out of everyone will win the grand prize. If there is a tie, there will simply be 2 winners.

Judges, when sending the results, please send the entire scorecard, not just the overall score, as it is good for participants to see how to improve.