Based off AHS 1984. Amy Bennett is a survivor of The Night Stalker. She escapes being held captive by him, and ends up meeting and falling for Xavier Plympton. After a few months of hanging out with her new friends Montana, Chet, Brooke, Ray, and of...
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
"Amy babe, I'm leaving you the room key. I gotta go make us some money. Remember the rules?" I asked through thr bathroom door.
"Don't open the door for anyone but you." She answered sighing.
"And?" I said.
"No, fuck him he's got his own room. Now can I please blow dry my hair to make sure the dye took this time?" She asked.
"Alright baby girl. I'll be back soon." I laughed remembering the first box made her hair orange.
And with that I left the key on the night stand, and walked out the door in my usual all black attire. I met key man out front. We walked about a block away into an alley. He scoped it out as I hotwired a car. We hopped in and went for our next burglary/murder. We owed father this for bringing us back. Amy knew about the burglaries and that I killed people, but she didn't know the brutality of it. And I intended to keep it that way.
🔪 🔪 🔪
AN: this chapter is mainly Amy and Richard
I finished blow drying my hair. Finally it came out right. Made me think of Monty's hair. But mine looks better. Then I started thinking about Xavier and wondered if he would be on the big screen by now, but I'll never know. I decided to push those thoughts down and watch some tv. I was getting hungry and craving pizza but I knew I couldn't go out or answer the door due to technically being a fugitive. So I settled for the last snckers bar.
I jumped awake to knovking on the door. Didnt realize I had fallen asleep. I slowly got up and grabbed the small handgun Ricky leaves for me, and hid it behind my back as I crept my way to thr peephole. I saw it was Ricky and opened.
He didnt really look at me as he sat a bag down from the gas station and box of pizza down on the dresser. How the fuck did he know I wanted pizza? I went into the bathroom to brush my now bed head and he leaned in the door way.
"Damn ..." I heard and looked over to see him biting his lip and his eyes roaming my body.
"Ya like it?" I asked.
He nodded in approval. And cleared his throat "I got some pizza. I figured thats what you wanted." He said stepping back to let me out.
He lit up a joint as I rummaged through the plastic bag to see what he got. Some cigarettes, a bottle of Jack, and rolling papers. I turned around and walked toward him.
"Yes, I do want pizza but right now I want this." I said snatching the joint from his lips and taking a drag.
We stayed silent for a while as we passed the joint. I passed it to him to put out because it was spent.
"Ya know, theres something else I want right now too besides pizza." He said in a low raspy voice. I already knew what it was. And seeing as he stole my virginity, I was hoping he wasnt thinking about raping me again. Although I had to admit he looked and sounded fucking hot right now. Maybe its the weed talking.
🔪 🔪 🔪
"Oh yeah? What's that?" She asked.
"Don't play dumb Amy, what have I always wanted this entire time." I whispered in her ear nibbling on her neck.
I noticed her pulse pick up and her breath hitched. Probably from our last sexual encounter. I knew I was the only one Montana told me she didn't sleep with Xavier. To my surprise she straddled my lap and kissed me. I didnt hesitate to kiss back, my hands roaming her body. She tugged on my hair deepening the kiss.
"That's my girl." I said before biting her bottom lip and earning a sigh/moan.
Suddenly we had our clothes off and I realized even though I took her virginity. We'd never seen eachother naked until now. Sure I felt her body and she felt how big I was but that is nothing compared to seeing it.
🔪 🔪 🔪
I couldn't help myself. Maybe Lilith is becoming more dominant because I wouldn't/and shouldn't be doing this with the man that raped and kidnapped me. But I had no control over my strange attraction to him now. He pushed me down on the bed and held my hands above my head with his. He trailed kisses down my body until he reached my pubic line. He then softly licked my clit.
"Mmm." I moaned before I could stop myself.
He then proceeded to devour my core. I hissed through my teeth and my breathing increased. He stopped because he knew I was close. I opened my eyes at the loss of friction. I wimprerd needing more.
"Somebody's needy. Don't worry baby. Papi won't leave you hanging." He said slowly crawling his way back up.
🔪 🔪 🔪
"Then just fuck me already." She said. Which turned me on even more.
"Yes mam." I said lining myself up with her entrance.
"Ok mami, I'm going to be gentle this time until you say otherwise. I want you to enjoy it." I said as I slowly entered her tight pussy.
We both moaned and soon she was clawing my back and grinding her hips with mine. I bent down sucking on her nipples earning louder, breathy moans from her. I guess I really turned her on because she flipoed us over and was now on top.
I had never let a woman take control but Amy is different. I love her and shes mine. She doesnt really act like it yet but shes coming around, lets me call her babe, baby, mami, and baby girl. I shook my thoughts away focusing back on her. I could feel we were both almost there. I needed her to go faster.
"Rapida mami." I said in my native Mexican tongue.
It worked because she growled and went faster her tits bouncing. I sat up careful not to slip out of her and thrusted my hips to meet hers. I held onto her sides as she hels onto my shoulders.
"Fuuuck, I'm gonna c-cum Richie." She gasped.
"Me too, come for me baby." I said thrusting as hard as I could up into her.
We screamed eachothers names and some profanities as we climaxed.
🔪 🔪 🔪
That was the first time in my life I had consentual sex and an orgasm. We both stayed in position breathing heavily coming down from our high.
"Damn, that was good." He said grabbing the back of my head and pulling our foreheads together.
We stared at wachother for a while, sobering up. And I still realized I was in love with him. I know how wrong and fucked up that is but I cant help it. He smiled at me as if he could read my mind.
"I love you." He said and took my chin with his index finger and thumb and kissed me.
