The Outsiders Preferences, and Imagines

SodapopX readerXPonyboy lemon-Competition

PLEASE DO NOT STEAL MY STORIES AND REPOST THEM ON OTHER SITES!! I HAVE ALREADY HAD TO REPORT ONE PERSON ON TUMBLR FOR DOING THIS!

(WARNING!! EXTREME DETAILED LEMON!!

This story was requested by undreamlike on Tumblr, Hope you guys like it ^_^)

To you, Soda and Pony were the perfect brothers, they always got along, always there for each other, and pretty much would give each other the shirts off their backs. So it struck you as odd when they began acting a bit off lately, little things really, but you would notice them. Like when Ponyboy would glare daggers at his brother when Soda and you were talking, or how Soda would suddenly sit beside you and start complementing you when you were sitting next to Pony. As you said, a bit odd, the other boys didn't seem to notice though, and so you just brushed off your friend's behavior. You figured it was the right thing to do, just like how you covered up your own feelings towards the young Curtis brothers. Yes it was true, even since you first met the gang, you had found yourself falling for not only Sodapop, but Ponyboy as well. It wasn't your fault, you couldn't help it, Soda was so charming and sweet, always there to cheer you up. Pony was the same way, but you two could spend hours talking about books and movies. You wished that you could choose between them, but alas, you could not, so you kept your feeling hidden as to not start a rift in the gang. But little did you know, that all of that was about to change.

The heat was unbearable that day as you sat on Pony's bed. He had invited you over to work on a project you two had to do for school.

"I feel like I'm melting in hell" You whined as you tried to fan yourself, only resulting in simply exerting energy.

"Sorry {y/n} We should have the ac fixed soon though" Pony shyly smiled at you, trying not to focus on the way your {h/l}{h/c} locks stuck to your face, or the sweat that dripped down your neck and between your...

"You ok Pony?" You asked, snapping him out of his thoughts, his cheeks flaring a bright red as he realized that he had been caught staring.

"Y-Ya, I'm fine" he answered, his eyes darting back to his textbook that he tried so hard to concentrate on. He knew it was futile though, you were all he ever thought about these days. The way your hair shined in the sun, the way your {e/c} eyes lit up when you saw an old book, or movie you loved, even your laugh had his heart racing. It was little things like that that first had his heart beating for you, but only recently had he began to notice other things...Like how long and smooth your legs were, how your hips swayed with every step you took--and right now, how your sweat soaked shirt seemed to hug your every curve, giving him a very good view of your breast size. He mentally scolded himself when he felt the familiar tightness of his pants, he couldn't let you know what he was thinking, what would you think of him? Would you hate him? Would you not want to be friends anymore?

"Pony!"

"Ya!" He said snapping his head in your direction only to come face to face with you. He swallowed hard as his eyes darted from your own to your lips that were only inches away, and back.

"I have been calling you for the past minute" you laughed as you leaned on his desk.

"S-Sorry, I was...Just thinkin'" he replied looking back down, though he kept glancing at you from the corner of his eye.

"Ok come on Pony, you can tell me anything. Why have you and Soda been acting so weird lately?" You asked, plopping back down on his bed.

"We haven't been actin' weird" he replied, to which you only crossed your arms.

"My butt you haven't, you guys are always sending each other glares when I'm around" You told him. He sighed, going quiet for a moment with a look that said he was battling with himself about something. Finally after a minute he stood, and made his way over to you, sitting down beside you on the bed.

"{y/n}...We've been friends for awhile now, you're the toughest and tuffest girl I have ever met, You're beautiful, smart, carin' and....{y/n}....I'm in love with you" he told you, his cheeks taking on a red hue as he shyly met your gaze. You stared at him, shocked by his confession, but he took your silence as rejection.

"I knew I shouldn't have said anythin'" he said as he was about to stand, but you grabbed his arm to hold him still.

"Pony I...I love you too" You smiled, causing a smile to grace his own lips.

"Really?"


"Really" you giggled, your laughing soon quieting as you watched him lean in, you leaned in as well to share a gentle kiss. Both of you were new to this, and that suited you just fine. You felt his hand rest on the back of your neck, pulling you closer as the kiss began to get heated, his tongue running along your bottom lip asking for entrance that you happily gave. You both were so into the make-out session that you didn't hear the front door open, or the footsteps that came down the hall. No it was only until the voice rang out that you two broke apart.

"What the hell is this?" You both looked at the doorway to see a slightly ticked off Sodapop.

"What are you doin' home? Yours and Darry's shift don't end for another three hours" Ponyboy asked obviously shocked and a little ticked himself at his brothers sudden appearance.

"The day was slow so they let me come home early, though I didn't think I would walk into this" he glared at Pony.

"Ya well--" You cut Pony off before an all out war started.

"That's enough guys! See this is what I was talking about Pony, even time I am around this is how you guys act, what is with you two?" You asked standing up.

"{y/n} there is somethin' I need to tell you" Soda said stepping forward and grabbing your hands.

"Soda don't" Ponyboy said standing up as well.

"{Y/n} I love you, I have since I first saw you. You're smart, funny, caring, and one of the most gorgeous and amazing girls I have ever met" He told you, for the second time that day your eyes widened, and you stared in shock, both of the guys that you loved just confessed their feelings.

"See she's not sayin' anythin', she already told me she loved me" Ponyboy stated, Soda searched for any sign that Pony was lying, but when found none, his hands dropped yours.

"I see" he said, his voice almost a whispered, before he turned to leave.

"W-Wait!" you called, causing both of them to turn to you.

"{y/n}?" Pony asked.

"I...I have something that I need to confess now...I'm in love with...Both of you" you stated, looking up to be met with two shocked faces.

"I never said anything cause I knew I could never choose between you two, and I never wanted to start a rift in amongst the gang" You sighed, making your way to the door.

"It's probably best if I just leave-"

"Hang on a minute" Soda said grabbing your waist and pulling you against him, your back to his chest.

"You love us both?" Pony asked stepping closer, you simply nodded. He shared a quick look with his bother before you heard Soda chuckle.

"I guess we could give that a shot" he said

"Give what a shot?" you asked before you felt lips upon your own. You slowly closed your eyes as you gave into Pony's kiss, his hands resting on your hips as his tongue entered your mouth once more. You were completely into the kiss, until you felt soft lips press along your neck. You gasped when Soda reached a certain spot, and after hearing your reaction he began sucking and biting, earning a moan of approval from you. Only then did it suddenly hit you what they were giving a shot, an idea you would have objected to if your body wasn't yearning for both of their touches at that moment. Ponyboy broke the kiss and began trailing kisses down the other side of your neck when Soda turned your head and pressed his own lips against yours, his tongue playfully flicking your lip until you gave him access. While Pony's kiss was gentle and sweet, Soda's was more playful and experienced. You couldn't hold in the moan that Pony's lips on your soft spot caused though. Your head was officially spinning, so much so you almost didn't even feel Soda's hands lifting up your shirt, both boys pulled away as he pulled it off and tossed it aside. His hands running down your sides, crawling back up to grasp your bra clad breasts.

"Soda" You moaned as he massaged, his lips soon finding yours again as another heated makeup session began. Pony watched for only a moment, jealousy taking hold as he moved to unbutton your pants and gently slide them down until you could step out of them. His lips met your neck once more as his hand ran over your clothed heat, a louder moan emanating from you, causing a smile to spread on his lips. He added more pressure, feeling your wetness seep through the thin cloth, you whined when his fingers left, though you were soon rewarded with something better when you felt his fingers slip inside your panties. And here you thought Pony was sweet and innocent, seems he could be a bit more experienced when in competition with his brother, who had by now discarded your bra and was pinching and teasing your hardened peaks.

"Mmph, you two..Stop teasing" you whimpered as you pulled away from Soda, Pony pulled away from your neck and nodded at his brother before you felt your body being lifted and carried over to the bed. Pony's lips met yours when you were set down, while you pulled his head closer to deepen the kiss, his hand began playing with your breast. Soda trailed kisses down your stomach before pulling off your panties, running a hand along your dripping heat.

"My, you're awfully wet {y/n}" he smiled, leaning down and blowing on you, earning a slight squeak of shock, one to which he laughed at. Your lips broke away from Pony's as you let out a loud moan when Soda's tongue ran along your core. He draped your legs over his shoulders before he grabbed your hips and pulled you closer to him, his tongue soon beginning it's work that had you moaning out his name in a matter of seconds.

"S-Shit!" you gasped, your hands quickly tangling in Pony's hair as he latched onto one of your hardened peak, his tongue flicking over it before grabbing and pulling it with his teeth.

"T-This isn't fair" you whimpered; Pony pulled away to ask what you meant but he was answered as you reached for his shirt and began tugging it up, getting the message he quickly pulled it over his head while you worked on unbuttoning and pulling down his jeans.

"{y-y/n}" he moaned as you began rubbing the bulge in his briefs, you smiled up at him before pulling them down as well. You wrapped your hand around him, pumping slowly while you looked up at him, his head lulled back as he let out a moan. You run your tongue over the head, earning a sharp breath, before you took as much of him in your mouth as you could.

"F-Fuck {y/n}" he moaned, his hands tangling in your hair as he bucked his hips in time with your bobbing. You let out your own moan when you felt Soda enter two fingers into your throbbing core, his pace was quick and hard while he sucked on your clit. You could feel your end approaching very quickly, and Soda pressing another digit into your heat successfully pushed you over the edge, and you pulled away from Pony to let out an almost scream. The boys pulled away as well while you laid their panting, Soda undressing himself while Pony tried to catch his breath from your previous actions. You crawled to the edge of the bed where Soda had just finished taking his briefs off, you reached your hand out and began pumping him before taking him in your mouth as well.

"D-Damn {y/n}" He moaned, his hand knotting in your hair as he guided your head along him. You felt the bed shift before feeling a tongue glade along your heat, causing you to moan, and Soda to groan due to the vibrations. Pony inserted his on fingers, starting out at the same fast and hard pace that Soda had as he kissed along your spin. You were already so  oversensitive that it didn't take long for him to have you tumbling to your second release.

"S-Shit guys" You panted, your mouth and hand releasing Soda as you tried to catch your breath.

"{y-y/n} I don't think I-I can wait anymore" You heard pony all but groan in your ear as he grabbed your hips, his hardened member rubbing against your soaked folds while you pushed back against him.

"Here" you heard Soda say as he handed Pony a small package, one that was quickly torn open while Soda pulled you up to stand. Pony got off of the bed next and Soda laid down, realizing what was happening, you crawled back onto the bed. You positioned yourself. Soda's hands guided you as you lowered yourself down. You had never had any type of sex before, and it seemed today you would be having them all, thankfully though it seemed that the boys had lube stashed somewhere.

"Fuck" You heard Soda groaned once you had taken all of him, you laid back a bit, trying to get used to him, once you had you nodded at Pony. He crawled over you, taking a hold of your hips once Soda had left them to message your breasts, and slowly began to enter. It took a little bit to get used to both boys, you had never felt so full before, and your body twitched with anticipation of what was about to come. Once the boys felt that your body was calm enough, it was Soda who started; he began to slowly pull out, effectively pushing you down harder onto Pony before suddenly entering you again, drawing a moan from both of your throats. The rhythm was slow and hard, and once Pony got into it, you started bucking your own hips into their thrusts.

"Shit {y/n}" Pony moaned leaning down to kiss you, you tangled your fingers in his hair, your other hand tangling in Soda's as you rode them both. Soda's lips landed on your soft spot, sucking and biting and you moaned into Pony's mouth, before Pony pulled away to attack the other side of your neck. But as both boys sped up their thrusts they both hit a certain spot inside of you.

"FUCK!" You screamed your vision leaving you for a moment. You weren't sure what happened, but the boys must have because it didn't take long for their thrusts to increase in power as the both aimed for that spot.

"D-Damn it, you're so tight" Soda groaned; his hands tightening on your breasts as his thrusts sped up, he could feel his own end drawing closer, your walls tightening around him was not helping, nor did your moans of his name. Pony's end was approaching just as quickly, your increasing wetness letting him slide in and out easily as he sped up once again, his thrusts becoming faster then your own as well as Soda's. He could feel your walls tighten every time he hit that spot and that alone had his vision blanking, but the way you moaned his name had his peak coming ever closer.

"G-Guys..I don't think I" You started but were cut off as a moan escaped your throat.

"Cum for us {y/n}" Pony moaned before leaning down to capture your lips.

"Scream for us {y/n}" Soda groaned in your ear, his hands pinching and pulling your peaks.

"S-Shit! Ahhh!" You threw your head back as nothing but the sounds of sex filled the room for a moment, before...

"SODA! PONY!" You screamed as your vision left you, your walls tightening around both of them as they called out your name, meeting their ends as well. You slowly drifted down from cloud nine as the sound of panting met your ears, your hands slowly leaving the boys hair as you tried to catch your breath.

"W-Wow" you smiled before you felt arms wrap around you from behind. Pony slowly pulled out, you both groaning slightly as he did, before he laid down beside you. Soda helped you off of him before you crawled in between them both, where soon two sets of arms wrapped around your frame.

"Love you {y/n}" they both said into your skin, you smiled as you heard their breathing calm.

"Love you too boys" you told them, sleep taking you as well.