CreepyPasta Story: It Starts

Chapter 5: Retaliation

Slendy tried to make sense out of the chaos but everyone was talking at once, which was very confusing for the slender man. However, thanks to him being the leader, this isn't the first time talking over was a problem. He was able to understand what the angry Pastas were saying.

"Is Max the reason we're all in danger!?"

"What did that kid do THIS time?"

"Are we gonna die? I JUST got here!"

The horde of monsters and humanoids ranted and rioted, all blaming Max for the events that were unfolding. Snake Eyes was worried as well, was Max lying to her? It wouldn't be the first time people have lied to her and put her in danger. Slendy put his hand up which immediately silenced the angry crowd. He looked at them all and shook his head no, trying to make them all believe that there was nothing to be afraid of and that Max is in no way responsible for the actions at hand. Pinkimena however, was not believing a word of Slendy.

"Max said himself that this creature tracked his scent, and could lead it back here! If we're not careful it could kill one of us easily! Don't think for a second I didn't recognize those wounds!" The pink pony ranted, pointing her hoof at Slendy's shoulder.

He looked over and saw indeed his suit was torn with a claw mark, he tried to cover it up fast, but the crowd was wiser to the situation.

"If this creature can harm Slenderman, imagine what it could do to us if we had our guard down! Slendy was going to keep this information from us just to protect Max!"

The tall faceless man grabbed Pinkimena's tail and lifted her to his face level and even with the lack of a face, she could tell he was scowling. Slendy in his own way, told the small pony to quit planting ideas into all their heads, that the creature was sealed in a cave. He would figure out a way to kill it so everyone could move on with the rest of their lives. He warned her that if she would not stop with this constant barrage of hate towards Max, and trying to get others to turn against him, there would be consequences for her actions. Pinkimena, being the unhinged and stubborn pony she was, wasn't convinced.

"You always had it out for me Slendy! Ever since our "rehabilitation". We were the best of buds back in the day. And as soon as that little SHIT showed up, you changed."

Slendy looked away, he didn't want to admit it but when he did find Max, things did indeed change. Perhaps it was because he had a soft spot for children, especially the ones with supernatural powers and abilities.

"This is not our way Slendy and you know it! We're monsters! Creatures! Beings that live for the KILL!" Pinkimena said, holding up her knife with an unhinged look.

The crowd was getting restless and looked at each other. Her words hit them all.

"Some of the CreepyPastas are content with this "Hotel Life", but not all of us. Some of us LIKED our old lives, no matter how much we had to stay in the shadows." She explained.

Seedeater growled and scraped his claws against the ground, tired of eating fake humans. Sonic.exe laughed as he was tired of scaring the same people over and over, without taking any souls. Slendy looked at Jeff, thinking his BEST friend would back him up, but to his dismay, Jeff twiddled his knife, cutting his cheek a bit.

"Sorry Talls, but the pony is right. I miss making people go to sleep." He said eerily.

"I bet you! This creature is an attack by the humans! They found us, and now want to rid of us since we're all in one place now! Well, I say NO MORE!"

The CreepyPastas cheered and yelled, all of them wielding their weapons or making their iconic scary faces.

"We're CreepyPastas! We've scarred the Internet! We've horrified children AND adults! We've killed MULTIPLE humans!" Pinkimena continued.

Slendy tried calming everyone down, but to no avail, everyone was too riled up.

"We're not taking this one sitting down! We're taking back our old lives! And we're taking the fight to that BEAST! Once it's gone, we go back to the Mainland and KILL whoever we want! WHO'S WITH ME!?"

Everyone cheered and roared, they wanted to fight, they wanted to kill. Before Slendy could silence everyone with his scream, Pinkimena kicked him back into his darkened room. As the door shut, Slendy tried opening it, but with Sonic.exe's powers, the door was locked and would not open.

"Enjoy your stay old man. The time for peaceful island life is over. Now it's time we CreepyPastas do what's best." the demonic blue hedgehog laughed, his bloodied yellow fangs glistening in the light.

Slendy tried teleporting away but to no avail. His .exe powers were stronger than when they first met. Slendy before could teleport circles around Sonic, but since then he's improved. As the CreepyPastas walked away, a few stayed behind. The red-haired girl, Colette. The twisted magician, Clarity. The reptilian girl, Snake Eyes. And the small little girl, Sally. Slendy growled and paced around his room, worried about the safety of his family, yes the CreepyPastas are tough, some even seem to have god-level powers, but they all bleed. And if it bleeds, you can kill it. And to add up, what the other CreepyPastas didn't know that Slendy did, was that the humans were getting smarter, and their technology and weaponry were getting stronger. What no one was aware of is that Dead Bart was indeed dead. The humans were able to gain his TV signal every time he would infect a channel with a new signal tracker invented by a mysterious company. One day when Bart infiltrated a station and began to play his episode, people were ready for it. As soon as his face appeared on screen, they shut the station down, permanently. The signal being cut as soon as Dead Bart appeared, killed him and to this day, Slendy has no idea how to bring him back.

If everyone gets what they want, both humans AND CreepyPastas will die. He leaned against his door and began to hear it banging.

"Yo, Slenderman. Is it true this ain't Max's fault?" Snake Eyes asked, leaning against the door, her eyes looking at the carpet.

Slendy knocked once, Sally stated that means yes. She and Slendy had a way of communicating through knocks when she couldn't see him face to face. It was a little game they played when they first met each other. Snake Eyes and the others pondered for a bit, and after a few minutes, they all were on Slendy's side fully.

"Slendy? What should we do? I don't want my family to get hurt." Sally said, her little voice being filled with dread at the thought of losing another family.

Slendy stood up and took a paper from one of his blank journals. He slid it under the door which the gang proceeded to grab and read. The handwriting was sleek and in cursive, say what you want, but the man could write beautifully. The gang nodded at each other, Snake Eyes and Clarity went off to get Max, meanwhile, Sally stood by the door, waiting patiently for the plan to go underway. Meanwhile, as the Pastas were at the edge of the island, they all smiled and grinned. They all talked about how they could cross miles and miles of ocean. Suddenly the blank-eyed, dark-skinned man, known as Herobrine stepped forwards, the sand squished beneath his feet as the tides crashed into the shoreline. He raised his hand, his white eyes beginning to glow brightly as materials began to swirl and spin around him. Dirt, gravel, stone, obsidian, and more. With a single swift motion, he balled up his hand into a fist. The earth was struck and rumbling soon followed, making some of the CreepyPastas tremble and fall over. A stone bridge began to form from the bottom of the ocean floor and rise to the top, paving the way to their new objective. The Pastas clapped in amazement as Hero blew on his hand.

"That's my boyfriend..." Ben said, in a lovestruck state.

As the killers growled and stared at their new bridge to their old lives, they all rushed off, laughing, roaring, or silently staring at the darkness. Eyeless Jack was riding on the back of Seedeater when he suddenly stopped. The blue-faced killer asked the beast what was wrong. What he got as a response was a low guttural growl. The beast turned around and snarled, his claws scrapping against the stone as the other Pastas ran past him. Jack patted the head of the creature, saying whatever was there it can wait. Seedeater however, could not take this for an answer, he proceeded to sprint off back to the island, taking Eyeless Jack with him in the process!

"SEEDEATER SLOW DOWN!" The frightened man shouted.