Don't Catch A Case (FP Jones X OC) [In Progress]

2 *edited*

"How did you do that? I've been playing forever and you started last month!" Archie threw his controller down. Well, maybe we didn't know what was going down. But it was Super Smash Bros, so I guess we weren't too off if you think about it.

"I guess I'm just that good," Riley giggled and kissed Archie's cheek. Archie looked at his phone.

"Shoot, I've gotta go! I've got 5 minutes to be at Pops!"

"Okay, well, I love you."

"I love you too," they leaned in for a quick hug and Archie ran down stairs to go meet Betty.

Riley climbed into bed and started to nap.

☆☆☆

It's easy to say, but it's never the same. I guess I kinda liked the way you numbed all the pain. And now the day-

Riley heard her phone ringing. It was from "My Future Hubby 💍❤"

"Hello?"

"Riley, do you think you could go get my jacket from Jughead's?"

"Yea, sure. Enjoying your night with Betty?"

"Yep."

"Can you tell her I said hi?"

"She said hey."

"Okay. Bye Arch!"

"Bye babe!"

Riley hung up and quickly threw on Archie's hoodie and a pair of skinny jeans. She ran down the stairs and out the door.

☆☆☆

Riley knew exactly which trailer Jughead lived in. When she was struggling to find a place to stay, she always knew Jughead would let her sleep in his room.

"Hello? Jug?" Riley knocked on the front door. The door flew open.

"Who's there? Oh, hello there doll." FP slurred.

"Hey Mr. Jones. Do you mind if I-"

"Honey, call me FP." Riley refrained from rolling her eyes.

"Whatever, I just need Archie's jacket."

"I'm sorry love but I don't know where that jacket would be. And why do you care?" Riley, yet again, refrained from rolling her eyes.

"Because he left it while he was hanging out with Jug."

"Why doesn't he come get it? It isn't your problem. Anyways Jug isn't here, never is."

"Well, I'll just go then-" FP laid his hands on her waist. Riley looked up at him confused. He looked at her hungrily. "Uhm, Mr. Jones? What are you doing-" he cut her off putting his lips on hers. She pulled away.

"What the fuck!?"

"Aww, honey, you know you deserve this. Obviously Archie only sees you as an errand girl. Please. We both need this."

"But this is wrong, we shouldn't."

"But we both know... how nice.. it would feel... right baby?" Riley had two options: leave or have sex with FP. She though hard. It was smart to leave but FP was right. Archie left her to go on a date with the girl who obviously likes him and he told her to go pick something up for him.

"Whatever." Riley put her lips to his and he reacted quickly, picking her up and laying her down on his bed.

☆ smut warning ☆

Riley slipped everything off, FP following behind her. Everything was a blur. It was slow and passionate. And amazing. It was perfect. After they finished, Riley thought to herself, Archie has never made me feel like that.

Something you might want to know about the sexual aspect of Riley and Archie's relationship is that they don't have sex often. It's more of a once and a while thing. And it was mainly a blow job and... well and nothing. It was just for Archie.

☆ smut over ☆

Riley curled up on FP's chest. She had felt amazing, but then the guilt washed over her.

"Damn that was amazing."

"I have to go."

"What? Am I not good enough?"

"FP, you were great, but that wasn't supposed to happen. I have a boyfriend and you just happen to be the father of my best friend! None of this is okay!" Riley frantically pulled her clothes back on. FP pulled her against him. His kissed her neck.

"Who cares? Fuck them." Riley wanted to stay there. More than anything. But she couldn't let herself.

"No. I'm leaving, okay! Bye Mr. Jones." She stomped toward the door. FP grabbed her wrist and spinned her so they were facing eachother.

"I said to call me FP." He smashed his lips on hers and gripped her back tightly. Riley tried to pull away but eventually gave up. She enjoyed being with him, plus what harm could a few more moments do?

"Dad? Riley! What the fuck?!"

Well, it looks like having your best friend walk in is what harm it could do.