Bensler 2

Choices

Elliot went down to the precinct realizing that it was Kathy, he didn't know what she wanted. She just waited for him smiling with her blue eyes and long blonde hair. Elliot was so confused.
"Hey El we need to talk" Kathy said holding onto his arm. Elliot smiled.
"okay sure lets go to the diner" he replied. They went to the diner and talked. Then Kathy said something that shocked Elliot. He didn't know how to feel.
"I want us to try again." She said slowly. Elliot kept replaying that in his head. He loved Olivia so why was it so hard to choose? He didn't have to choose.
"I'll have to think about it Kathy." He said paying the bill and walking Kathy to her car.
"Goodbye" Kathy said kissing Elliot.
--------
Elliot went back to Olivia's apartment with Chinese food.
"Hey liv I'm back" he said yelling. Olivia hid the test and the box she put it under the sink. She ran back out.
"Hey who was at the precinct for you" she asked in curiosity. Elliot had no secrets to hide.
"It was Kathy, she wants to get back together." He said looking down.
"Oh." She said uninterested. She felt like Elliot would choose Kathy over her she wanted to get drunk but she couldn't she knew she couldn't.
Elliot walked over to her. "I love you" he said walking to the bathroom to take a shower. He was looking for his body wash, he went to the sink and looked under it to see that there were pregnancy sticks and one that had two lines. His face was in shock. He thought to himself 'why would she hide this from me'.
Elliot got up with the box and pregnancy test and walked out to Olivia.
"Liv..." Elliot said quietly. Olivia turned around and as she saw the box and the stick she ran and took it away from him.
"It's not mine" she said without hesitation. Elliot looked at her, he knew he wasn't gone that long. She was lying.
Elliot grabbed her by her arm. "Why are you lying to me Liv." He said looking at her.
Olivia pulled away. "Because you love Kathy so just be with her." She said wiping her tears away.
"So you are pregnant." Elliot reassured.
"YESS....NO." She said changing her answer. She cried hysterically. Elliot walked over.
"I love you...why would I choose her over you. We got divorced. I want a family with you. Nobody else. You" he said.
"It's yours" she said still crying.
Elliot's face lit up. A family with Olivia? That was just perfect. It was more than perfect. But what happens if Kathy finds out? Would she destroy it or will she just let it be?