wwe imagines

last christmas ➵ finn balor - pt. 2

it's been about a week since the night reader spent with Finn fixing their relationship. New Year's Eve arrives, and reader has yet another run-in with Finn, and this time he brought his fiancée with him ...

WARNINGS: mentions of cheating, actions involving cheating, drinking, being drunk, jealously, angst, dirty talk, drunk sex
WORD COUNT:

******

Candice drags you out to yet another party for New Year's Eve, as if the last one you went to didn't get you into a ton of trouble.

Yes, she knows you slept with Finn several times in one night. No, she does not care. She just wants to have fun with her best friend.

"Stop mopping around about Finn and get your cute ass ready," she told you about two hours over the phone.

So, you got your cute ass ready. You're wearing a two piece dress. The top is a long sleeve, off the shoulder black piece that hugs your body. The skirt is a high-low style with a red floral design. The skirt flares out a bit. You added some natural makeup and are wearing black heels to complete the look. Y/H/C colored hair is in a tight ponytail on top of your head.

This party is more lowkey than the last one. There were hundreds of people at the Christmas party you went to. There's definitely less than one hundred people here at the rooftop party. The party is on the roof of a fancy hotel that the Gargano's rented out. Yeah, they rented out the roof for their New Year's party.

When you arrive to the party, you immediately get a drink. You order a Whiskey Sour and three Fireball shots. The shots are gone within a few moments, and you're halfway done your Whiskey Sour.

Your eyes are on the entrance to the rooftop, just in case he decides to make an appearance.

"We can't do this again."

"Why not? Ya liked it. I liked it."

"Of course I liked it but you're engaged, Finn. You're getting married. We can't be doing this. It's not fair to her."

Those words ring in your head and you chug the rest of your drink before asking for another. You're served a second drink as Tegan Nox comes limping over.

She smiles at you and says, "So, you gonna explain where you disappeared to after talking to Mr. Balor or are you gonna keep ignoring the fact that I know where you actually went."

Sighing, you say, "I fucked Finn Balor when he's engaged to be married, and I liked it. I'm such a hypocrite."

Tegan's eyes widen and she says, "Damn, I knew you left with him but I didn't know you went and slept with him."

You rub your face and take a gulp of your drink before you say, "His fiancée probably doesn't even know. I'm such a hypocrite. He cheated on me and now he cheated on his fiancée with me. Why does this happen to me, Tegan?"

She says, "You love him, he loves you. Neither of you realize that. He's changed for you."

"He's engaged to someone else and he fucked me," you say, already tipsy from the alcohol you've ingested so far tonight. "And it was a good fuck too. It was all night and I loved every second when I shouldn't have."

Tegan laughs and says, "You need to let up on the drinking, missy."

Your eyes are on the doors as you say, "I kinda hope he actually does come. I know Candice and Johnny invited him. Especially after Candice found out what happened with us. Is that bad? I think it's bad." You sip your drink again.

Candice walks up and says, "Hey, ladies. What's going on?"

Tegan looks at Candice and says, "Y/N is horny for Finn Balor."