Creepypastaromance Stories

67 Stories

CreepyPasta Boyfriend Scenarios by Nyghtfall
#1
CreepyPasta Boyfriend Scenariosby Nyghtfall
CreepyPasta: Fictional Horror Characters Includes: SlenderMan; Eyeless Jack; Jeff The Killer; Laughing Jack; Lost Silver; BEN Drowned( Doctor Smiley And Homicidal Liu Ha...
Heartless Proxy (Hoodie x Reader) by DemonGirlMe
#2
Heartless Proxy (Hoodie x Reader)by Qhim
You couldn't stop it. The evil that was taking over, you couldn't control it. You needed to kill. It was telling you to. You've done it before, so why do you stop the...
Laughing Matter  (Laughing Jack Fic) -Completed- by CodeNameFanGRL
#3
Laughing Matter (Laughing Jack Fi...by Code
Felice Fiore Grande always had rotten luck. She never knew her biological parents, she was always stuck in the abusive or just down right creepy foster houses. And to to...
A Smile of an Angle That touch a Killers Hearth (creepypasta Dr.smiley's love) by Jinx_Vinx
#4
A Smile of an Angle That touch a K...by Yuuna Uchiha
What can a bind girl like her do to a killers who is amused on killing and making others suffer? Can she really be the one?
Killer Lover by creepypastagirl9384
#5
Killer Loverby Michelle Woods
What happens when a killer falls in love with you? You will find out in this story. (BEST DESCRIPTION EVER!!!)
Ticci Toby x Soundwave (Oc x Toby) Twitchy Hearts are the Best kind by KAIRI_AKASHIEYA
#6
Ticci Toby x Soundwave (Oc x Toby)...by SoundWave
This is a Toby x Oc story so yeah ENJOY! Her name is Soundwave well Raven and she is best friends with Ticci Toby. They both have the same disorders and they both end up...
Walk in the Forest by Bubbles__14341
#7
Walk in the Forestby BubblesOtaku
Just a Little ONE SHOT About what would happen if Toby and Ben were dating, and they had a falling out....
Trust Me ( Jeff the killer romance ) by TwistedEcho
#8
Trust Me ( Jeff the killer romance...by TwistedEcho
Siren, your average teenage girl.. somehow ends up in debt to a murderer. When the same kïłłęr who saved her life tries to end it, how will she react to her saint and de...
Unlikely Romance by AlexMasters0
#9
Unlikely Romanceby Wolf
Lizzy is a sassy feminist who loves being alone. She was pampered her whole life, and thus has everything. Everything, except love and peace. She finds these two importa...
Ally Glitch by AllyGlitch_EmoisLove
#10
Ally Glitchby AllyGlitch_EmoisLove
Hi im Ally Glitch and im telling you how i became a creepypasta/OC My Creater is Alicyn Shaw :)
Blood can shine brighter by Waterspark
#11
Blood can shine brighterby Waterspark
Jakkios is a girl born with a rare deformity,albinism. Her whole life she has been locked away by her father and because of this she has never had any other human contac...
Killing me softly by Pastel-Godqueen
#12
Killing me softlyby Pastel-Godqueen
y/n is an average high school senior, she gets good grades, gets invited to parties and even has a perfect Harvard boyfriend. One day she comes across a wounded man in t...
A night with the smiling killer (Jeff the killer x reader) by lemonartist04
#13
A night with the smiling killer (J...by lemonartist04
You have had a rough life and a smiling killer is going to make your life change completely.
Candor and Curiosity  (A Slenderman Romance) [REWRITTEN] by cupcaketwinkle101
#15
Candor and Curiosity (A Slenderma...by Mel Tyler
"He's not who he says he is." Elizabeth Black is a newspaper journalist who has dedicated her life to the people and causes that matter most to her. When she's...
Forbidden by Creepypastafordinner
#16
Forbiddenby Creepypastafordinner
Jeff has been best friends with slender forever but now are they more than just friends.