It's summertime in the idyllic New England town of Greyport, and Diana should be happy, but her twenties are proving to be more lackluster than she expected. Her career and social life are not where she wants them to be. Following a particularly dreadful date, Diana runs into an old friend; but this isn't any old friend. This is Delmar Lennox, her childhood crush and first boyfriend who left their hometown eleven years ago under mysterious circumstances. Can things go back to the way they were, or have they been too changed by mythical and human forces outside of their control?