Stiles POV After about an hour of waiting for Malia to fall asleep I looked over at her and tried to slowly climb out of bed.
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
I quickly but quietly but back on my clothes and walked out the door. I went outside and hopped inside my jeep.
*knocks on door*
"Stiles what are you doing here it's late are you okay" Brenda asks as I barge into her living room
"No no I'm not okay you wanna know why?... because of you"
"Me? What the hell did I do"
"You were in love with me and had those feelings too back then didn't you?" I ask
"Stiles!"
"Tell me"
"Stiles this really isn't the best time right now"
"No Brenda tell me I wanna know"
She didn't say anything but after a few seconds she finally let it out.
Yes I did"
"Oh my gosh I knew it I knew this is why you came back after you had said something at the photoshoot I just knew"
"It honestly shouldn't even matter anymore you're married"
"So why did you come back especially since you knew about Malia"
"I thought things might've changed"
"Well they haven't"
"Yeah I can see that so it doesn't matter" she tells me
"It does matter"
"So what do we do"
"I don't know but I have to go though before Malia wakes up and sees I'm not there"
"Wait I have something for you"
"What is it" I ask as she opens up a drawer and hands me a photo
"Where did you get this"
"Your dad sent it to me a while back"
"That's crazy"
"Look what you wrote on the back"
"To Brenda the first girl I ever loved and the only girl that has my heart there is nothing that will change that" I read out loud
"Like I said things changed right"
"What did you expect I wasn't just gotta sit around and wait for you besides I was just a kid with a crush Brenda"
"So look me in the eye and tell me you don't love me"
"It's that simple"
"Just answer the question stiles"
"Yes I still love you but I love Malia more than anything and I'm not going to hurt her" I explain to Brenda and walked out her house
Next morning Malias POV I rolled over to wrap my arm around stiles but he wasn't here. I stood up and headed downstairs to find him passed out on the couch.
"Stiles" I say nudging him
"You scared me"
"I'm sorry why did you sleep on the couch"
"I came down to watch tv but I fell asleep"
"Oh okay well do you wanna go get breakfast"
"Sure" he says agreeing to go
At the cafe "I will never get over this cafe like this cafe is our spot for us and all our friends" I exclaim then seeing Scott Allison Lydia and Brenda walk in but as soon as I saw her my smile disappeared
"Hey guys" Scott says as they all walked up to us
"Hey buddy you guys sit down we're just having some coffee" stiles tells them
"How long you guys been here" Scott asks
"Not long what are you guys up too" I ask
"Nothing really" Brenda says
I couldn't help but notice that stiles didn't bother speaking or looking at Brenda but he also got really quiet while Brenda started talking to us
"I'm gonna go get a refill" I tell everyone as I get up
"Hey you ok?" Lydia asks
"Yeah something just felt a little off like awkward"
"What do you mean"
"Nothing nevermind forget it"
"Okay"
Brendas POV As we were all sitting at the cafe everyone kind of spread out and it was only me and stiles.
"So you're just not gonna speak to me now or even look at me"
"What do you want me to say I told you how I felt isn't that enough"
"No stiles because I want to be with you but you're choosing someone else"
"Because I've known malia for a long time now since the 5th grade and so on I've only known you for four years but we were still just kids I may know you but not like I know Malia"
"I just wish you'd give me a chance"
"I'm married nothings gonna change that" he says then getting up and walking towards Malia
Stiles POV "Hey you wanna go somewhere" I ask Mal
"Sure do you wanna go home or..."
"No like we should go somewhere just us"
"Stiles we just got back you really wanna leave again?"
"Yeah I like it better when it's just us"
Malia couldn't but help but notice how stiles body language changed and that he was so quick to leave like something was up.
"Are you okay" she asks
"Yeah why"
"I don't know I just feel like ever since Brenda got here you've been acting a little different"
"What do you mean?" I ask
"Well when she got here literally 2 days ago you were so happy to see her and now you seem to barely even acknowledge that she's here" Mal explains
"What's your point"
"Is there something going on I should know about stiles"
"No!" I shouted and suddenly notice everyone staring at us
"Let's just go home" I tell her
"Ok let's go"
Brendas POV I see stiles and Malia about leave but before they could I stopped them.
"Hey can I talk to you for a second" I ask stiles
"I'll meet you outside" Mal tells him
"What Brenda?"
"Take this" I say reaching into my pocket and handing him the picture of us from when we were kids
"I want you to keep it"
"Brenda"
"Please stiles just take it I want you to have it"
"Fine" he says sliding it into his back pocket
"I gotta go"
As stiles walked out the cafe Brenda couldn't help but just watch him leave. ________________________________ Oh Brenda! What is she trying to do!? 🤨
