Choosing Him

11.6K 144 14
                                    

I looked down at his hand on my wrist.
"Don't go." He repeated.
"I can't keep doing this! I can't just leave one of you for the other. I'm tired of going back and forth." I knelt down on his floor placing my hands on my head.
He knelt back down with me.
"I've known Marco my whole life... he won't change. Not for you, not for me, no one." He said calmly.
"You're with Bella!" I said muffled as I lifted my head up.
"Nothing happened... she just stood their hogging all the water." He chuckled.
"Well you were with Marco." He added.

He walked us toward the coach. "I can't be with him." I said as I let out a sigh of relief.
"I know." He said as he placed a hand on my leg.
"So this is the other place?" I asked, changing the subject.
"This is it." He said standing up readjusting his towel.
"Stay here with me." He looked down at me still sitting on the couch.
"Maybe I should just be alone tonight." I stood up.
"Please." He insisted.
" I guess it is a Friday night." I said rethinking his offer.
"We can just talk and stuff." He brushed his damp hair back.
"I didn't bring anything with me." I said unsure.
"Then we'll go to your place." He offered.
"Mmm...fine." I gave in, I always give in.
After he dried off,changed, and grabbed his things we took the subway to my apartment.

The rest of the night we talked, laughed, and cuddled. We stayed up all night until we finally fell asleep.
I woke up to many missed calls from Marco.
My phone rang again! I shut it off and rolled over to see a peacefully sleeping Luke. I brushed the hair in his face out of his eyes. He smiled lightly and opened his eyes. "Your so pretty when you sleep."I said lightly as I ran my fingers through his hair once more.
I sat up in the covers when Luke pulled me back down and closer to him.
"Don't leave me in this big bed all by myself." He whined.
"You are so stubborn." I groaned.
"You know you like it." He flirted.
"Mm fine." I rolled my eyes.
We stayed in bed for about an hour exchanging kisses and cuddling.
We finally got up, and he made breakfast.
He set down a plate of scrambled eggs and his famous pancakes.
"Do all the girls you sleep with get special treatment, or just me?" I teased.
"Your one of the only girls that hasn't snuck out on me yet." He said rubbing the back of his neck nervously.
"Well you haven't scared me off yet." I giggled.
"I have to go say goodbye to my parents tonight, but after do you want me to come back?" He asked taking a bite.
"Yeah sure. I'll be here." I took a bite of food.
We finished up and shortly after he left.

I put the dishes away and started the shower. I got in and ran my hands through my hair as the hot water poured down my body. I kept thinking about the past two months and everything that had happened.
I felt good about leaving Marco, he was too much!
I definitely cleared my head in that shower. I grabbed my towel, stepped out and walked into the living room where I saw Marco on the couch. "How did you get in?" I asked holding the towel tighter.
"Oh please I've seen it.." he turned his head.
"Your land lord takes tips." He remarked sarcastically.
"That's not funny." I said angrily.
"You didn't return my calls." He groaned.
"Yah it's because we aren't together anymore." I grabbed water from the kitchen.
"Let's talk about it." He said as he rolled his neck.
"I will call building security." I glared at him.
"Fine. See you Monday." He got up and left.
I promptly locked the door behind him.
I can't believe him. Showing up here all high and mighty. That Asshole!

I went out on a run.
When I got home I was locked out.
I called Marco.
"Did u take my keys?!" I practically shouted.
"I don't know are they dangly with a red keychain?" He shook the keys.
"I'm locked out!" I barked.
"Oops." He chuckled.
I hung up.

I called Luke.
"Hey what's up." He said
"Marco stole my keys!" I said angrily.
"What? How?" He asked
"He tipped my landlord to let himself in while I was in the shower." I explained.
"Damn. Ok. I'll be there in a few hours. You can use the subway and come to my place I'll text you the code to the elevator access." He offered.
"Yeah I guess I can do that." I answered annoyed.
"Don't worry we'll handle it." He reassured me.

I made my way over to Luke's place and waited till he came back.
"Sorry that took so long." He said as he entered.
He walked over and kissed my forehead.
"Ready?" He asked me as he set down his coat.
"For what?" I asked.
"To get your keys back."
I followed him down to his car and we drove to Marco's.
"Let me handle it.Stay here." He told me.
"What? Why?" I unbuckled my seatbelt.
"I'm gonna handle it." He reached across me and pulled a gun out of his glove compartment.
"L-Luke... he's your brother." I stuttered staring at the gun.
"Don't worry I'm just gonna shake him up a little." He got out of the car. I tried to open my door but he locked me in. Since it was one of those old cars I couldn't unlock it from the inside.
"Asshole." I muttered under my breath as he went off without me.

He came back about 15 minutes later. With the gun in his hand, he put it back in the glovebox and dropped the keys in my lap.
"You didn't shoot him did you?" I asked concerned.
"No...but I wanted to." He smirked.
"Jessica..." he said sternly.
"I will never let anyone hurt you." He leaned over and kissed my neck.
I loved how possessive and protective he was over me. It really turned me on.
He drove us back to my place.

A week passed I had been staying at Luke's almost every night things were getting pretty hot and heavy. Marco stayed out of our way for a while it was nice.

It was 3pm. I had no work to do and I was bored. I strutted past Marco's office and right over to Luke's desk.
"Hi." I said happily, as I sat down across from him.
"Hi!" He looked up from his desk full of papers.
I tapped my phone and he unlocked his.
I sent him a picture of me topless.
He cleared his throat adjusting in his seat.
I sent another one I took on his bed in front of a mirror in his bedroom.
Luke: Stop teasing me.

He kept wiggling in his seat.
I got up and left his desk.
It was around 7 and Luke and I left the office pretty late.
We stepped into the elevator and a few moments later so did Marco. Marco cleared his throat.
"These are yours." He handed me a pair of panties I'd accidentally left with him one of the many times we'd had a little too much fun.
"And these." He reached into his back pocket and pulled out another pair.
Luke glared at him.
"Thanks." We left the elevator in opposite directions I followed Luke.
"So I was thinking.." Luke started the car.
"Why don't you just move in." He said as he glanced over at me backing out of his spot.
"When?" I asked curiously.
"This weekend?"he glanced over again.
"Can I think about it?"
"Of course." He placed his hand on my thigh. I felt a rush of butterflies feeling his warm hand through the thin fabric of my stockings.
He ran his hand a bit higher. I bit my lip, and he noticed.
He stroked his hand down the seam of my stockings, making me wet. "Stop teasing me!" I squirmed.
"It's frustrating isn't it." He smirked.
Fuck I was getting wetter by the second.
He placed his hand on my chest and ran his hand down under my skirt into my panties. "Mmm your so wet." He growled keeping his eyes on the road.
He pulled over into a side street.
He unbuckled himself, reached over and laid the seat as low is it could go he climbed over on top of me. He took off my stockings ferociously. He barely had room to do it. Then he lowered my skirt off my hips and down my legs. He took my panties off using his teeth and placed them in the glove compartment behind him. He rolled a condom onto himself as he leaned over me.
He forced himself further over me. Teasing my aching opening with his tip. Applying just enough pressure to make me whine for more. "Luke." I whined as he kept teasing me. He grabbed both of my hands stretching behind my head and inserted himself into me slowly. "Oh fuck." I let out a moan of relief. He pumped in and out of me every inch as he grunted and began to go faster. I grabbed his hands tighter as he went deeper and deeper. He released one of my hands and rubbed my clit as he began to pump deep inside me. "Mmm" I couldn't contain how good it felt. I finally came as he slowed his pace and released himself. He sat back in his seat
re-fastening his pants. I was still out of breath.
"Move in with me." He said firmly.
"Okay." I said coming down from the high of the orgasm.
"Okay." He repeated.

The Secretary (18+)Where stories live. Discover now