Truth or Dare [h.s.]

34

⚠️TRIGGER WARNING: BLOOD & MURDER⚠️

Louis Tomlinson

After the big argument of me and Leah I felt like telling everyone what really happened to Brooke.

'Guys! Please come and sit down in the living room!' I screamed. Everyone came to the living room and sat down. 'What's up Louis?' Harry asked. 'I'm going to tell y'all the truth about Brooke.' I said. 'Louis but....' Liam said as I interrupted him: 'I know Liam, but I can't hide this anymore.'

Everyone looked shocked, which I understand, but this had to be done. It was now or never.

And I told them the story:

Liam, Brooke and me walked to the other room. We sat down on the ground where an other box with truth or dare cards was standing. 'I will go first!' I said. I picked up a truth card: 'Are you still in love with Leah after she hooked up with Harry?'

I hesitated: 'Yes, but my heart is still broken after what she had done to me. I still love her but less.' I was just completely honest. At this moment I was thinking of breaking up with her. I didn't want to lose her, but she really hurt me and I couldn't act like she didn't.

'Louis, just follow your heart.' Brooke said. I nodded as we went further on playing the game. 'My turn!' Brooke said after she comforted me. 'Truth. Do you think you will marry Liam one day?' She said. We looked at her, cause we were curious about her answer.

She acted like she was about to say no, but she suddenly said: 'Of course! I really feel like he's the love of my life.' She chuckled while saying that.

'My turn now, which one should I pick?' Liam asked. 'Truth is safer Dude.' I said. 'Go for dare, that's exciting!' Brooke said as Liam picked a dare card.

His eyes scanned card as his face expression turned into fear. 'What's wrong Liam?' Brooke asked. 'I-I-I...' Liam said as he stuttered. Something was wrong, this dare could've been worse as we expected it to be.

'Liam, what's on the card?' I asked. 'I don't....' he said. I could see fear taking over his body. I took the card away from him and read it out loud: 'Kill Leah or Brooke, you can choose.'

I looked at Brooke as now all our faces were filled with fear. Brooke started crying, she couldn't hold her tears. She didn't want to die, but neither she wanted Leah to die.

Liam hugged Brooke as he knew he may would kill her best friend in a few minutes.

We looked at each other not knowing what to do. I didn't want him to kill my girlfriend, but nor I wanted to let Brooke die. I didn't know what to do. We couldn't ignore the dare as Elizabeth would kill us all if Liam didn't do it.

Brooke looked at us, she seemed to have a solution. But my expectations were far from what she was about to say.

She hesitated, but finally said something: 'I should die.' Liam looked at her, his eyes filled with tears. 'No Brooke I'm not killing you.' He said. I looked at them as I knew we had no choice but to kill her or Leah.

'I want Leah to live, she never felt the feeling of being alive and I want her to feel it.' Brooke said. 'But Brooke..' Liam said as Brooke interrupted him: 'I've felt the feeling of being alive Liam and I don't want to see my best friend die. I volunteer to get killed. Don't change my mind.' Brooke's eyes filled with tears. She kissed Liam one last time and said: 'I love you Liam, our wedding will happen. But not on earth I guess.' She said as tears kept rolling from her eyes.

Now she walked up to me and said: 'Thanks for everything Louis. Tell Leah I love her and that I will miss her.' She said as she kissed my cheeks.

'Kill me Liam, I want you to do it.' Brooke said. Liam picked up the knife that suddenly laid down on the ground. He walked closer to Brooke as his eyes were red from the tears.

'Do it now!' Brooke said. Liam didn't know what to do and before I could count to ten.... he stabbed her. Blood fell down and so did Brooke. 'I love you Liam.' She said. She screamed from the pain.

Liam caught Brooke as she was now dying in his arms.

Suddenly Elizabeth showed up. 'You guys can't tell anyone about what happened! Not till they all hate you for lying.' She said as she laughed and disappeared.

And then you guys came in.

Back to the present day

'Elizabeth wasn't our biggest problem, but she was the reason we didn't tell anything to you guys. We're sorry.' I said.

I saw everyone's eyes full of tears.

'Thanks for telling Louis.' Harry said. He was the only one who didn't cry yet. I nodded.

At least they knew what happened now.

//