MY MY MY Abyss of Randomness

FNAF THEORIES: Is Phone Guy REALLY the Purple Man?

Here's what I think about the theory that the Phone Guy is actually the Purple Man as well:

------------

FACTS ABOUT PHONE GUY:

- Favorite Animatronic: Foxy
- Least Favorite Animatronic: The Puppet
- Helps you throughout the game via phone calls
- PRESUMABLY dies in night 4 of FNAF1
(there may be more that I forgot about, but these are the only ones that are important to the topic)

FACTS ABOUT THE PUPRLE MAN:

- (Most likely) killed five children (the spirits that supposedly haunt Freddy, Foxy, Chica, Bonnie, and Golden Freddy)
- Killed a child that most likely haunts the Puppet. This was during (supposedly) Fredbear's Family Diner.
- Appears in the "Save Them", "Give Cake to the Children", and Foxy death-minigames.
- Doesn't appear in the "Give Gifts, Give Life" minigame.
- Dismantles all four main animatronics in the FNAF3 after-night cutscenes.
- Dies inside Springtrap. His body is found inside.

* * *

Now, let's assume that the two characters are the same person. We know that Phone Guy hates, and I quote, "that puppet thing." However, his favorite animatronic is Foxy, because he says so himself.

Recall the death minigames. The Purple Man appears in all of them--but one, that being the "Give Gifts, Give Life" minigame, or the one where you control the puppet. Because he doesn't appear in this minigame can support the theory that he ALSO hates the puppet.

But that's not all. Recall the Foxy minigame. You are foxy, running out of what looks like Pirate's Cove to a group of five children (five. FIVE.). However, when you run out the third time, you can see the Purple Man standing in the corner of the room, watching you. And when  you get to the room with the children, they're all dead.

This could mean that the Purple Man's favorite animatronic is Foxy, as he is standing by Pirate's Cove, smiling.

-

Let's move on to the characters' deaths. We know Phone Guy dies on night 4 in FNAF1 (with an unknown cause of death), and the Purple Man dies inside Springtrap in the FNAF1 building.

Again, let's assume that Phone Guy and the Purple Man are the same person.

If this was true, then the places of death are similar, to be the least. They were both killed in the FNAF1 Freddy Fazbear's Pizza.

But the Phone Guy probably died in the office, while the Purple Man died in the back room.

But if that's true, then was Phone Guy's message recorded a while ago? Or was it recently? Because then why is there no trace of his death in the office?

Probably it's because he DIDN'T die in the office...

Remember how in the FNAF3 Night 5 minigame, where you play as the ghost of a child? And then you enter the back room to find the Purple Man and four other ghosts? And remember how the Purple Man looks scared?

And remember the night 4 phone call. Foxy sounded like he was banging on the door. Chica and/or Bonnie's groaning noises sounded in the background. Freddy's music box was playing. And at the end, when the Phone Guy says "Oh no...", you can hear Golden Freddy's screaming.

What if those weren't the actual animatronics, but rather the spirits...?

If that were true, then Phone Guy, or the Purple Man, could've escaped the room before the spirits could get him, running to the back room where Springtrap was. Before he left, he turned off the phone call. The ghosts could've followed him, surrounding him and forcing him into the Springtrap suit, causing him to die and the spirits to be freed.

-

Some minor supporting details:

In the "Save Them" minigame, you can sometimes get killed by the Purple Man, who is holding something like a phone, and the game crashes with a screen that says "you can't". Possibly replying to that demonic voice in the background saying "S-A-V-E-T-H-E-M".

My friend told me that Scott sent someone an email saying "Some helpers aren't as they seem..." Could he be referring to the Phone Guy? He's the only helper, after all... But this could be fake, as we all know from previous experiences.

-

However, there are a LOT of flaws in this theory. And I mean, a LOT.

One. If the spirits are free, then why do the animatronics still try to kill you in nights 5, 6, and 7? And why is it that the night 5 phone call is the voice of (probably) an animatronic?

Two. If Springtrap is in the first game, then why can't we see it? But then again, he might've been in a different room without a camera.

Three. If the Phone Guy died before FNAF3, then where did the FNAF3 phone calls come from? A new Phone Guy? Ancient phone calls? IDK?!

There are a lot more. But that's all I have for now.

----------

So if you want me to do more theories, just tell me which theories to do! 

-Rainstar ;3