When You Were Mine: Joe and Katherine's Love Story (A Joey McIntyre Fanfiction)

26

Joe stands outside the bar. Donnie's long gone but his words still play in Joe's head.

Joe's decided, after several drinks, to see if maybe Ally wants to join him at his place. He thinks Donnie might be right, he needs to just get lost in a woman for the night.

"You waiting for me?"

Joe turns when he hears Ally. "Yeah I am."

Ally walks right up to Joe, she's so close to him now he can smell her amazing perfume. "I was hoping you might be."

Joe suddenly feels so unsure of his decision to wait, he starts to think maybe it would have been better to just go home by himself. But he's here and she's here. And the way she's looking at him is exciting him, in a way he hasn't been excited in a long time.

"Yeah? Well Ally I was hoping maybe you'd like to come back to my place with me."

Ally rests her hand on his chest, Joe actually likes the way it makes him feel. "I'd love to come home with you Joe."

Joe takes her hand in his, "Let's go then." They walk hand in hand the two blocks back to his apartment.

Joe and Ally have a really good conversation on the walk. Joe likes her immediately. She's got a really sweet personality and she's funny. He likes how easily she makes him laugh. By the time they get back to his place he feels comfortable with her.

"Make yourself at home, while I grab us something to drink."

Joe grabs two glasses and his favorite bottle of Scotch from the kitchen and heads back into the living room. Ally's sitting on his couch, her long legs are crossed, which makes her skirt show a lot of thigh. She really is very beautiful.

Joe sits next to her and hands her a glass. They sit together sipping scotch and talking about nothing really. Joe takes in every detail of her. From her long legs, to her ample breasts, to her sexy shy smile and the way her blue/green eyes sparkle when she laughs. He likes how she runs her fingers through her long blonde hair, pulling it to one side, exposing her neck to him.

Joe finds Ally very sexy. And not in a way that she's trying to be sexy. She's just naturally sexy.

Joe sits his glass on the coffee table. "Ally would it be okay if I kissed you?"

Joe notices the blush in her cheeks when he asks this. She sits her glass next to his and turns to him. "I thought you'd never ask. I'd like that very much Joe."

Joe leans towards her, placing his hands on either side of her face. When his lips touch hers, he feels relieved. He deepens the kiss, sliding his tongue across her lips and when she opens her mouth and his tongue mingles with hers he feels hope, because for the first time in a very long time, he doesn't see Kate's face, he can only see Ally.

Things start to get hot and heavy with Ally and Joe really wants to move things to his bedroom. But he feels compelled to be one hundred percent honest with Ally.

Before Joe has a chance to say anything Ally's hand moves over his thigh, then up to his erection. She rubs his cock over his jeans. Ally moves to the floor, sitting on her knees in front of him. She makes quick work of getting his jeans off. "Oh wow" is all she says before she takes his generous length into her mouth. All thoughts leave Joe's mind. Ally's good at this, very good. He moans as she's moves up and down him. Ally looks up at Joe and their eyes meet. If Joe thought Ally was sexy before, now he thinks she might be the sexiest woman he's ever seen. Watching her, watching him, as her mouth does these amazing things to him is intoxicating. It's almost too much for him to take when she starts using her hand along with her mouth.

"Oh fuck Ally, that feels so good. Damn you're going to make me come." She moves her mouth and her hand faster. "I'm serious Ally, I'm going to come." He looks down at her and she nods at him. So he stops fighting it and let's go. He comes hard, it's the best feeling he's felt in a while. When he's does Ally stands up, and heads towards the kitchen. "You want some water?"

Joe's head is spinning. He can't believe he was able to let go like that with someone who isn't Kate. Joe's been with a lot of women since he and Kate broke up. But he'd never been able to feel this good after any of those encounters. It was like he always felt guilty afterwards. But not tonight. Tonight he only feels a desire to be with Ally.

"Here you go." Ally hands Joe a glass of ice water. He takes a long drink of the water as she sits back on the couch with him. "I can go of you want me to."

"Go? Why would I want you to go? I was hoping you'd stay. Maybe we could move this into the bedroom. If you wanted to." Joe takes another drink of his water. Ally doesn't say anything she just looks at Joe like she wasn't expecting him to want her to stay. He stands up and offers her his hand.

He pulls her to her feet when she takes his hand. He leads her into the bedroom where they proceed to have the time of their lives together.

Joe doesn't see Kate's face once while he's with Ally. Hell she hardly crosses his mind all night.

It's a different story in the morning though.