The Owl House x Reader Scenarios and One-shots

Confessions

Luz

Her confession was quick but also full of reasons why you shouldn't date her. After a bunch of self-deprecating comments, you would shut them down and tell her that she is perfect the way she is. 

If you accept her feelings she will engulf you in a hug and thank you a million times while jumping up and down.

If you reject her she will just look down sad and say "Oh... okay."

Eda

Eda's confession was blurted out in a daze. She confessed after you helped her in the owl beast form. She realized how much she needed you and it was one of the few times that she would let anything she was feeling slip. Once she realized what she said she added that you didn't need to feel the same way if that was the case.

If you accept her feelings she will give you a genuine smile and hold out her hand. When you put your hand in hers she will pull you in for a hug. You are now her official partner in crime.

If you reject her feelings she will just stare at you for a bit and then say "Oh".

Willow

She would have a note tied up to a plant she made for you and would confess in a secluded area with a bunch of other beautiful plants she grew. She would be shy trying to give it to you but she is very proud of her work.

If you accept her feelings she would be very glad she would hug you excitedly and announce it to Luz and Gus who were in the bushes spying on you two.

If you reject her feelings she would take the plant back and look at you sadly before saying "A-Are you sure." After you walk away Luz and Gus would comfort her but she would be very mature about it and say that she is okay and will always be okay as long as you two are friends.

Amity 

She would be flustered during her confession. She was able to get permission from Lilith and took you to the most beautiful part of the Isles she could find. She was flustered since it was the first time that she had you all to herself. You both were alone. She stated her feelings but then went off course and started talking about everything she liked about you, your personality, your looks, and how you made her feel. It was bliss for her.

If you accepted her feelings she would stare at you with all the admiration in the world before asking if you two could hug. 

If you rejected her feelings she would be devastated and start saying that it was expected since someone as amazing as you deserves better.

Gus

He would confess as a human would, and by a human, he means a human in the books he reads. He planned a very detailed and dramatic confession in the auditorium with Luz and Willow as his helpers. He wears his grom outfit during everything and tries to keep it clean. He gets nervous and he freaks out once he hears that you're coming. It turns out it's not you and a monster comes in and crashes/wrecks the place. While Luz and Willow try to hold the beast off, Gus is desperately trying to fix all the decorations and accidentally gets caught by the monster. You end up fighting the beast and saving Gus. Once you ask what all the decorations were about he confesses. 

If you accept his feelings he will squeal and try to dip you but it ends up with you dipping him. He will still be happy and squeal, saying "This is just how humans do it!"

If you reject him he will immediately start asking if it was about the decorations and that he could fix them at any time. He tries to do an illusion to cover up the mess but since he is stressed it fails and once you walk away he drops to his knees. "This isn't how it was supposed to go."

(I want to write a one-shot about this. If I do, do it, it will be the accepting feelings route)

Hunter

It was another day that you arrived and continued to fight him. He started the fight this time. But ended up losing, as usual. This time before you left he asked you if what you meant was true. Would you really be willing to become someone with him? Would you really be willing to become a powerful duo? When you say that you meant what you said he would confess and tell you that he thinks he loves you but since he has never really been taught about it he doesn't know if it is true but he thinks about love every single time he remembers your words. 

If you accept his feelings he would look at you dumbfounded and gives a weak laugh. He asks if you're being serious. Just to make sure of course. He feels like the moment is fake and can't help but feel relieved that the person he loved, loved him back.

If you reject his feelings he will just stop. He feels embarrassed. In all honesty, he expected it though. He will just look away in shame. "I-I guessed that would be your answer."

Collector

It was a similar day to all the other ones before. You wake up eat and do whatever the Collector wants to do. Nothing special at all. At least that you know of. The Collector was putting together a small little setup and cleaned up his mess in the little pocket dimension he created for you two. He had signs covered in glitter glue and markers that they made themselves. Their confession was them admitting that you're the first person they knew that stuck around and decided to play them. They knew they couldn't live without you so they hoped that becoming your partner keep you around.

If you accept their feelings he'll jump and fly around in happiness and give you a small ring made out of whatever art supplies they had. He claims that he's seen people give rings to the person they care about.

If you deny his feeling he'll just throw the ring and on the floor "Yeah, yeah that was... expected but we're still friends right?" They don't care if you accept or reject them since they really just want you to stay around forever.