blue bird ⋆ it, fear street, and st cast preferences ⋆

125. who asked you out first?

in honor of this dude asking me out <33 lol

jaeden:
- jeremy
- jaeden got it flashbacks
- you declined jeremy's offer anyways

wyatt:
- sophia
- you dated for awhile before breaking up
- it just didn't work out

chosen:
- wyatt
- you declined his offer
- chosen was so happy he'd ask u out right after

sophia:
- jake😭
- her own brother damn
- you declined and she was so happy

finn:
- caleb
- you guys dated for awhile before deciding you'd be better as friends
- win for finn

caleb:
- sadie😳
- he wanted to give up
- but then found out you guys didn't end up dating (or did you?????)

sadie:
- millie
- you guys dated for a few months
- made it very complicated between you and sadie

gaten:
- caleb
- he gave up
- but u decided to date gaten instead 🤞

noah:
- finn
- finn asked you out as a prank (asshole)
- so noah asked u out right afterwards and it made u not feel bad at all baha