I was looking through my phone today
To find a particular picture of a coffee cake I once had
Instead I saw your eyes
Staring back into mine
A photo from Spring 2019
You had your hand around my waist and
I had wrapped my body around yours
The bile rises in my throat before I can catch it
I thought I scrubbed my phone clean
Of every trace of your existence
But seeing your eyes for just a second
Makes my body go red-hot with disgust
And it's not that I hate you or that I regret dating you
Just that I was someone then and someone else now
I'd try to explain it
But I have no more energy left for you
Seeing your face reminds me
Of the two unanswered essays still sitting in my inbox
That you sent me over the months we've been apart
A torrent of your feelings and your feelings and then more feelings
And I know I should respond
Maybe throw in some comforting platitudes
"It's not you, it's me" seems like it might work
Though the truth is, it was definitely you and not me
When we were together
I tried very hard
To be the best version of myself
Patient, kind, empathetic, self-abnegating to the extreme
Instead I became a sort of monster
With a bottomless pit of rage in my stomach
Unleashed on you every time you touched me or spoke
Or even breathed too close for comfort
We argued all the time
Over the phone, in empty rooms, in your car
The only time we were ever really at peace
Was late at night in bed together
And it wasn't that the sex was good
(it wasn't)
It was just that when we lay next to each other
We didn't have to speak, pretending to sleep was good enough
Loving you was exhausting to the nth degree
Mostly because I didn't actually love you
And pretending that I did took up much more effort
Than either of us ever realized
I didn't know I wasn't in love with you back then
You were in love with me
And for a girl who had never been loved before
That was an incredible feeling
You took the time to count all my birthmarks
You listened to my stories and remembered things about me
You made me feel like I was so beautiful and captivating
A real goddess of a woman
Though the truth is, I'm not very beautiful or captivating
Certainly not a goddess by any stretch of imagination
You loved me so
But didn't know me at all
And I spent all my days and my nights
Trying to be the woman you loved
Because I wanted so badly to be loved
But I guess, just not by you
YOU ARE READING
Last Summer
PuisiA collection of poetry about being in love and falling out of love.