A R T < 3 (Reader x Art)

4

After arriving back at sienna's apartment you all fall asleep almost immediately. You and Ryan crashed on the couches.
~

The next morning comes.

"Ugh I feel like shit."
Sienna walked out of her room and sat on the couch beside you.

"Did you have fun tho?"

"Yeah actually."

"So it was worth it." You smiled.

A light knock at the door interrupted the conversation.

"It's probably Stacy coming to apologize." Sienna said

"I hope not." Ryan groaned half asleep

The knocks got louder.
Almost as if a police officer was waiting behind the door.

"I got it"
Sienna walked towards the door and looked thru the peep hole.

"Um whoever it was left."
She opened the door.

"Hello? .. Must be the neighbors kids again."

"What's that on the ground?" You asked

Sienna looked down and picked up a little black box neatly tied with red ribbon. Shutting the door behind her.

"The tag says for (Y/N). Stacy either actually has a heart and felt bad or you have a secret admirer." Sienna laughed.

"How would they know I was here tho?"

"Good point." Sienna said concerned

"It's probably just that Stacy chick." Ryan said trying to reassure.

"Yeah. Whatever it is I don't want it. I need a break from her after last nights bathroom incident." You laughed and untied the ribbon.

You dropped the box.

"Sienna, is that what I think it is?" You asked

"Jesus Christ." Ryan said in disgust

"That looks like a fucking human heart."

Sienna looked closer. Her face got pale.

"That's.. because it is." She said with disgust

"Who would send me that?"

You got nervous. Worried it was like a hit or something, but who would take it that far? It's not like you fucked anyone over.

"Could Stacy be mad at me?"
You knew that was crazy but you weren't exactly thinking straight.

"She could be, but in what world could that girl obtain a human heart?" Ryan asked

"You're right. Maybe it's fake."

"It's not fake." Sienna said bluntly

The knocking returned. Sienna grabbed a sword from her room and went to the door.

"Whoa that's a bit much don't you think?" Ryan asked

"You just saw a literal human heart and you're questioning if this is too much?" She scoffed and looked thru the hole.

Again.

"No one."

She went to open the door.

"Sienna stop. Don't you think you should call the cops instead of the trying to take matters into your own hands?" You asked

"Wouldn't be the first time."
She opened the door.

"(Y/N) come here." She said

You walked over there to see dead (same flowers you picked earlier) covering the floor.

The wall was smeared with blood it read
' A R T <3 '

"He's back."

"Sienna you killed him." You said

She slammed the door shut then locked it.

"What are those flowers (Y/N)? I saw you holding them outside last night at the club."

"Some guy who happened to be in a clown costume was taking out the trash and kept handing me flowers. Then I saw him again in the bathroom when I ran there out of embarrassment."

"What happened in the bathroom?" She asked concerned her face still pale.

"Nothing."

"You need to tell me. What happened in the bathroom (Y/N)?" She demanded.

"Nothing! I was upset so he did the old flower trick on me and it squirted prop blood onto my face. We laughed for a minute and I started to feel better until Stacy came in and treated me like shit per usual."

"Then?"

"Then nothing! She was being a complete bitch and embarrassed me even more than I already was in front of a friendly stranger so I stormed out to find you and we left. That's it!"

"He didn't hurt you?"

"No Sienna. He didn't hurt me because it was just someone in a costume at a Halloween party.  I was alone with him long enough that if he wanted to hurt me he would have. If it was the guy you told me about I'd be dead by now." You responded annoyed.

"The most he did was put his hand on my cheek to wipe off the mess that the trick flower made and that's when Stacy came in and started to berate us. He looked as upset as I did."

"Then why are the same dead flowers I saw last night outside of my door right now?" She asked

"I don't know Sienna. Its probably a coincidence."

"Did Stacy follow you out of the bathroom?"

"I don't know and I don't care. I didn't see either of them after that because we left."

"She probably tried to sleep with the clown too." Ryan cut in with a smirk

"It's not funny. I'm calling her." 
Sienna took out her phone.

"What's with you and this clown Sienna? Lighten up." Ryan said

He knew nothing about her history.

"Fuck you. She's not answering. I'm going over there."

"Where?" You asked

"Her house. Then to the club."

"I'm coming with."

"I am too. My cars still there." Ryan said

"At your own risks." Sienna responded and threw on a jacket.

You guys were all still in costume from the night before. You haven't had a chance to change before sienna rushed out the door.

~