The Eyes Have It: Final Part

290 8 7
                                    

Even as the officers take all day to scour the streets for the unsub, they don't find anything. It's not until the next morning that two more people are murdered. A male and a female. He's back to murdering two people. However, there is something different about this crime scene compared to the other ones. He murdered them at their house, so he cut the wires in the electrical box and killed all the lights. If they can't see then they can't fight him back. He probably used some night vision aid of some kind in order to kill them.

The perfect hunt.

The woman's carotid was severed and her eyes were missing, just like the others. However, the man's eyes are still intact. He didn't take them. Why? Why is he different? Upon closer examination, there is a laceration on his left eye but not his right. He probably fought back trying to save the woman and the unsub ended up cutting him accidentally.

They theorized that the unsub could be collecting them but what if he needs a set? An injury like that ruins the collection. They're trophies. Someone who collects eyes could be into taxidermy, and that is something the team can use as a lead.

"A taxidermist?"

"Morgan might be onto something. The unsub's collecting sets of eyes that need to be flawless because he's preserving them as a trophy of some kind."

"We said he was a hunter. What do hunters collect for trophies?"

"What if we're wrong about him being a doctor?" Spencer asks. "It makes sense. A taxidermist has all the skills and supplies needed to preserve eyes and other body parts."

"Do they know how to surgically remove eyes like this?"

"Yeah, they have anatomy knowledge. They have to cut through muscle, tissue, and nerves to remove hide. It's the same thing for eyeballs."

Penelope calls JJ who places her on speakerphone.

"Garcia, you're on speaker."

"Comrades, I cross-referenced John with Okie City animal stuffers. Turns out, he wrote a $250 check as some sort of deposit for Lloyd's Wild Game Shop six weeks ago. Now, this place is scant miles from the farm road where our first victim was dumped."

"Does Lloyd have a record?" Phil asks.

"Lloyd Bulford has one recent record from the city, and it's a death certificate. He died four weeks ago of emphysema."

"Did he have any employees with criminal records?"

"He's got no employment records at all. He has a twenty-eight-year-old son named Earl who lives with him. He has a petty crime record and counts of animal cruelty."

"Garcia, get everything on the son."

"Okey-dokey."

Penelope takes a few moments to look the information up.

"Is there any record of mental illness?" JJ asks.

"No, but his mom had a degenerative eye disease called Retinitis Pigmentosa which would eventually lead her to go blind. Considering his crimes, that's super weird, right? Anyway, she died in a car accident when he was eight. Then, he gets expelled from school for getting in a fight with a kid and trying to gouge the kid's eyes out. I have no record of him returning to school, he has no employment records, he's never filed for taxes, and he doesn't have a credit card in his name. Besides his driver's license, there's no record of him at all."

"That's probably why he didn't show up on any of our lists," Derek says.

"Sounds like he's totally dependent on his dad. When his dad died, there's no one left to check up on him."

Criminal Minds Series Rewirte: Season FiveWhere stories live. Discover now