We Were Infinite

Do you guys like pumpkin pie?

Me and Elijah were walking around before I spotted something. "Eli, Elijah, Elijah! Boy in blue." I said, tapping Elijah's shoulder.

"Hmm. Yeah, Y/N?" Elijah calmly turned around as I pointed at the pie on the table Elijah gasped "Are you the imposter?" He quietly asked me.

"No" I told him.

 "Ok." Elijah nodded. He gasped again, now knowing that I didn't do the crime, "Wait, why don't you report it?" Elijah asked me.

 "My mom took my megaphone after it went off yesterday last night." I explained. The ringing sound from the megaphone was still playing.

"Oh, here you can have my spare." Elijah gave me a spare megaphone.

"Why do you carry two megaphones?" I asked him. 

Elijah looked at me "Why? Don't you?" He asked. I facepalmed as he reported the crime.

 "Where? Where?" Everyone at the meeting asked. 

"Some one took a sli-" Elijah started before looking up at Micah.

"Who's that?" Elijah pointed at Jocelyn, who was on Micah's shoulders "I'm babysitting the neighbors kid!" Micah exclaimed.

"You guys don't know Jocelyn?" I asked, "Micah, I thought you told them!"

"I thought YOU told them!" Micah pointed to me.

"Okay!" Elijah shrugged "Someone took a slice out of the pumpkin pie!" Elijah slammed his hands on the table. "But only the middle part."

 Everyone gasped. "Anyone sus?" Daniel asked.

"Reds sus!" Britney shouted, slamming her hand on the table with a smirk.

"Aha!! You finally came to your senses! Red is suuu-" Judah exclaimed, stopping when I nudged him and pointed to his onesie, "Ahhh! You stole my colour?!?" Judah shouted at Britney.

 "Yep." Britney nodded.

 "Guys... I think I'm sus." Judah looked worriedly at us/

 "No no. Noo. Judah." 

"Just because you're red doesn't mean you're sus." Elijah explained.

"Maybe you're right." Judah nodded. "Britney's sus!!!" Judah slammed his hand on the table 

"Nooo! Okay Judah!" We all groaned.

"Okay, there's not enough evidence. So I say we skip." Shiloh explained.

 "Skip. Skip. Skip." People skipped "Skip." Jocelyn said, I smiled up at her Judah pointed at Britney.

"Alright everybody mom gave us each a list of tasks to do at the cabin. So get 'em done." Shiloh told us as she handed out the task cards.

"And remember there's still two imposters!" Elijah exclaimed.

"Only two??" Daniel smiled.

 "Haha! We got this!!" Micah laughed.

"It's gonna be easy!" Daniel and Micah exclaimed as they fist bumped "Whooo!" They cheered as they ran off.

Me and Shiloh ran off, leaving Elijah/ I looked back and Elijah looked left and right before running off. 

"Check your keys, everyone!" We were at the door, checking our keys as a familiar black onsie made its way through the crowd.

"Comin' through!" Josiah, gently pushed passed me.

"Josiah?!" I exclaimed.

"Where have you been?" Shiloh asked.

"Doing wires. Why do you think I was gone too? I had to help him." I sighed as Josiah simply smiled.