C.C./Evan x Cassidy

First hang out/My AU pt2

Evan's POV:

We made it back to my house and Cassidy's dad tagged along. When we made it to my house, both our dads spoke with each other while Elizabeth and Cassidy played with our Fredbear toys. Mikey chose to stay with his friends at the park and come back at a later time.
"Wow Ms. Spring Bonnie! What lovely tea you brought!" Elizabeth said to Cassidy.
"Ah yes! I got it from the local supermarket!" Cassidy responded through her toy. Cassidy had spring Bonnie, Elizabeth had Chica, and I had Fredbear! Cassidy said she also really liked Fredbear but she really likes bunnies so she chose him instead. Understandable. A bear could eat you while a bunny would be the one getting eaten. They're far less scary and cute. We continued to play for hours until her father got up to go.
"Come on, Cassidy. It's time to go." Her father said sternly. Cassidy looked a bit upset and sad.
"But we just got here, daddy!" She protested. Her father took a deep breath before calming down enough that he felt he could try to reason with her.
"Cassidy, we've been here for 4 hours. We don't want to out stay our visit." Cassidy then gave a pleading look to daddy who then looked at her dad for how he should respond. Her father sighed and looked at my dad and started talking to him.
"5 more minutes?" Mr. Boseman asked. My dad chuckled in response.
" Haha, she could spend the night for all I care. Evan and Elizabeth look like they're having fun and so does your girl. As a matter of fact, this is the most fun as I've seen Evan have in a long time. So please, if you wish to stay longer, it's fine by me."Mr. Boseman thought for a minute before speaking once again.
"Fine. But you better protect her as if she's your own, you hear me, Afton?" Mr. Boseman threats.
"Loud and clear, Boseman." My father smiles.
Her father huffed, kissed Cassie goodbye, and left, glaring at mine as he walked out of the door.
Daddy then came over to us and sat down. "So, what are you guys doing?" I got excited and almost jumped cuz I really wanted to tell him. I really liked my dad. He always made things super fun! Even the animatronics that I was terrified about. Daddy's original design for Bonnie was simply a fabric costume which was a bit scary but he always played such a funny and caring character with it.
"We're playing Fazbear and friends, daddy!" I said excitingly. My daddy got a smile on his face and scooted closer.
"Oh? And what's happening in this little game?" He asked.
"We're having TEA!!!!!" Cassidy chuckled. I look over a bit confused at what she's laughing at. She looks at me amused.
"Ofc you're excited about tea." She smirks. I give an even more confused look. "....cuz you're British." She explains
I look over at daddy confused. He chuckles and shakes his head. "Forget it, Evie." I look down. Cassidy is quick to change the subject.
"So Mr. Fazbear, would you like sugar in your tea?" My eyes light up at the resumed game. I nod fast.
   "Yes I would love sugar in my tea, Ms. Bonnie!" I say in an exaggerated gentleman voice. Cassidy nods and places an imaginary sugar cube in my teacup.
   "May I have some too?!" Lizzy nearly shouts.
   "Of course, Ms. Baby." I say, dropping a few cubes into her cup. I was jealous of her "Circus Baby" doll. Daddy made it just for her. I wish Daddy made me a special doll. But it's fine because I have fredbear! I love Fred Bear a whoooole lot! Lizzy looks at me and giggles.
   "Thank you Evie!" Seeing her smile washed away my jealousy. I loved her smile. It put me at ease. I look at everyone sitting at the table and realize that daddy wasn't playing with us. I look up at him.
   "Do you want to play with us daddy?" I looked up at him with wide eyes, knowing I'll get to him and get him to bend to my will.
   He sighs and shakes his head with a smile before sitting next to me. I crawl into his lap for comfort. He puts his arms around my hips, resting his hands in my lap. "I think I need a cup Evie." I gleam and burst up to grab a cup but my arms are too short. Cassidy and Lizzy see this and go to help me! When they saw each other's hands, they froze. They stared at each other for a minute before Lizzy glares at her and quickly grab the cup.
   "Since he's my little brother and my twin, I will give him the cup!" Cassidy huffs and crosses her arms. She looks away and practically snarls at her.
   "Fine." Lizzy smirks at her defeat before quickly handing me the cup. I stare at the cup then back at the girls. Then I look at to daddy.
   "Why do they hate each other?" Daddy doesn't answer and simply messes with my hair. He stops when we hear a knock at the door. Daddy picks me up and walks to the door. He opens the door to see a very tired Henry! "Uncle Henry!!!" I cheer.
   "Hey there, kiddo. Uh, William, I hate to bother you this late but I believe that Charlie left her doll here. Y'know her. Same as Evan. Can't sleep without that doll." I always hated her doll. It was terrifying. The design was made my Charlie herself. A lanky figure with a white mask, creepy smile, and a striped black and white clown looking suit. I would choose Fredbear over that nightmare any day.
   "Oh, yeah. I think I put it in my closet. Oh, come in! It's freezing out there, no?" Uncle Henry walks in and sits on the couch.
   "Thank you, William. I'll get out of your hair fast though. Looks like you got your hands full. Is Clara coming home tonight?" Daddy freezes for a second. He wasn't a fan of Mommy leaving to visit her family. She did almost every weekend and usually stays the night. Daddy but his lip before taking a deep breath.
   "Unfortunately, no. Apparently her parents wanted to bring her somewhere and needed an extra day to do so." Daddy clearly wasn't pleased. Henry noticed his discomfort and cleared his throat.
   "So uh.... Michael asked if he could stay the night. I told him I'd ask when I came." Daddy shrugged before looking at Henry.
   "Sure. But why?"
   "He said he didn't feel like being in a house with another little kid. Y'know, he's getting to his teen years, getting more irritated over little things" he chuckles. Daddy breaths out a little laugh
   "Yeah. Oh! I'll go get the toy. Your wife is gonna make you sleep on the couch if you take too long."
   "That would be very appreciated." Daddy brought me to Mommy and Daddy's room and goes into his closet and grabs the toy. I cringe at the sight of the doll and hug Daddy tightly. He gives me a little squeeze and kisses my forehead. We walk back out.
   "Here you go, Henry." Daddy smiles warmly at Uncle Henry and he smiles back. Uncle Henry stands up and gives Daddy a side hug so I'm not squished. After giving each other a firm huh, Henry heads for the door.
   "Thank you, William. Good luck with the kids!" Daddy laughs and waves him goodbye.
   "I'll need it. Have a good night." Henry leaves and Daddy closes the door. Daddy turns to Cassidy and Lizzy. "It is getting late. Where do you guys wanna sleep?"
   "Oh. I thought we were just gonna sleep in Evan's room." Both me and Lizzy look at Cassidy like she just cursed us.
   "Absolutely not! Evan is terrified of sleeping in there! Are you crazy?!" Lizzy lashes out at Cassidy. Daddy quickly barges in.
   "Elizabeth. That was uncalled for. Apologies to Cassidy."
   Lizzy crossed her arms. "Sorry." Daddy apologizes to Cassidy.
   "How about....the living room?" I say softly.
   "I'm.... I'm okay with that if everyone else is...." Cassidy also says quietly. I look at daddy to see his opinion.
   "That sounds like a great idea. Elizabeth?" Lizzy huffs.
   "Fine." I smile at Cassidy.
   "Daddy, can you help me get blankets and pillows?" Daddy agrees and we gather blankets and pillows together. Daddy tucks us in.
   "Good night, Elizabeth." He kisses her forehead. "Good night, Evan." He kisses my forehead. "And good night, Cassidy." He ruffles her hair. He gets up and before he leaves I speak.
   "Daddy.....?" He turns around.
   "Hm?" He walks over to me and squats down.
   "Can you pray?" I squeeze Fredbear and smile softly. Daddy's expression softens as he smiles too.
   "Of course." He strokes my nose. "Now I lay me down to sleep, I pray the Lord my soul to keep. His love be with me through the night, and wake me in the morning light. If I die before I wake, I pray the Lord my soul to take. Please let Elizabeth, Evan, and Cassidy sleep well tonight, and in Jesus' name," All Daddy, Lizzy, Cassidy, and I collectively say, "Amen." He kisses my head one more time before getting up. "Goodnight, my lovelies." Daddy then leaves us to sleep.

OMG I FINALLY GOT TO A SPOT WHERE I CAN STOP!!! I'M SO SORRY IT'S TAKEN ME FOREVER TO GET THIS DONE!! ANYWAYS, THANK YOU FOR READING!!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Rereading this, I switched the tense half way through the story. I'm sorry 😭😭😭 I'm not fixing it right now though. I'm tired.