𝙈𝙮𝙨𝙩𝙞𝙘 𝘽𝙤𝙤𝙠 𝙍𝙚𝙫𝙞𝙚𝙬𝙨 | OPEN FOR ALL

{Jade}✨ Ethereal Enigma

If you're looking for a gripping thriller that will keep you guessing until the very last page, 'Ethereal Enigma' is the perfect choice.

Cover Design: 8/10
The cover effectively captures the dark, mysterious tone of the story. The red, dripping "HELP" text against the black background immediately grabs attention and suggests danger and urgency. The shadowy hand print adds an eerie, unsettling element. The title and author name are clearly displayed. Overall, it's a striking and appropriate cover for a thriller.

Blurb (Book Description): 7/10
The blurb does a good job setting up the stakes and teasing the twists and turns to come in this sequel. Phrases like "web of deceit", "shocking revelations", and "unexpected alliances" promise an intriguing mystery. Mentioning Aryan's past raises additional questions.
However, the blurb could be more specific about Aryan's goal and the central murder mystery to give readers a clearer hook. Some of the language is a bit cliché ("edge of your seat", "rollercoaster ride"). Tightening the text and teasing a few more concrete plot details could make it even more compelling.
Here is my comprehensive feedback on the story "Ethereal Enigma" based on the criteria provided.

Title: 6/10
The title "Ethereal Enigma" is intriguing and hints at mystery, but it's a bit vague. It doesn't give a strong sense of the genre or plot. A more specific title that teases the murder mystery aspect could be more effective at drawing readers in.
Characters: 5/10
The large cast of characters, including Aryan, Maya, Nisha, Ravi, Meera, Ayeisha and others, don't feel distinctly developed. More characterization is needed to make them compelling individuals. Protagonist Aryan in particular needs clearer goals, motivations and flaws. The character relationships and dynamics could also be strengthened.

Plot: 4/10
The serial murder mystery plot has potential for suspense, but the storyline is hard to follow. Multiple murders happen without enough context. New suspects keep appearing without satisfying payoffs. The mastermind's motives remain unclear. More coherent set-up, investigation, and resolution of the central mystery is needed. Subplots like Aryan's past with Ayeisha need to tie in better.

Grammar & Vocabulary: 5/10
Frequent grammar errors, especially with verb tenses and sentence structure, distract from the story. While the vocabulary is decent, more proofreading is required. The informal tone of the narration could also be revised to better match the serious subject matter. More "showing" details and action, rather than "telling" summary, would strengthen the writing.

Overall Impression: 5/10
The story has the bones of an interesting investigative thriller, but significant revision is still needed, especially to the plot, characters and writing. The "shocking twists" currently come across as more confusing than compelling. With more polishing and coherence, this could be an engaging read.
The twist ending of Aryan being the murderer mastermind has potential, if properly set up, foreshadowed and justified. But it feels unearned based on what has been presented so far about his character and role.
In general, I would suggest streamlining the plot, deepening the characterization, clarifying motivations, and tightening up the writing. Focusing the core mystery could help all the other elements fall into place. With revision, "Ethereal Enigma" could become a gripping page-turner. I commend the creativity and effort so far, and encourage you to keep developing this intriguing story!

Reviewer : astronomist
Author of the book : LUCI_FER_1997

■□■□■□■□■■□■□■□■□■