Old Problem, New Grudge [FNaF What-If]

Chapter Ten; Come to Your Senses

Decided to make multiple chapters in a day bc for once I felt actually motivated to do something. This chapter will be for the FNaF 1 group, and a separate chapter will be made for Mike.

----------------------------------------------------------------

First Person PoV... Person will be revealed later...

----------------------------------------------------------------

Cassidy stood in front of the other animatronics as I watched from behind the corner. She looked troubled, angry... In any normal situation, I would have come up and asked what was wrong; however, I knew this was about the nightguard surviving the night.  I don't know why she always tries to kill the nightguards, but it is really important this one survives... I- I wouldn't know what to do with myself if he died.

He was forced to do it! Why couldn't Cass.. just.. understand? Sure, I had been with her when she wanted to springlock William, but that was different! William had killed people on purpose.

Should I be mad? I was at first, but it's been years.. he regrets it a lot... I know he does. I know he's changed, yet a part of me wants to stick with my friend, wants to think that he hasn't changed at all just so that Cassidy would be right in the sense we should kill him.

But he has changed. I know he has.

I start to pay more attention to Cassidy's directions. I figured out that Freddy was supposed to come out tonight, and I heard the pattern he was supposed to go in. I made a mental note then quietly got away. I don't want Cassidy to know I knew her plan.

I was going to save him.

Even if it made Cassidy mad.

...

...

...

Family

matters

more.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Cassidy's PoV

----------------------------------------------------------------

Cassidy sighed, finally happy with how the plan would work. There was no way Mike was going to make it out alive tonight!

 She was certain Evan would try to mess this up somehow. Why not pay him a visit? Try to get him to understand! She found her way to where he usually hung out, she stood in the doorway, calling out his name to get his attention. "Evan!"

"What?" he asked, walking to where she could see him. The room he usually stayed in was a secret room in the space between the two hallways, in front of the office. There was a small hole in the wall that went through a hole in one of the security monitors, just enough space for an animatronic arm to reach through, grab the survival logbook, write in it, then put it back. That had been how Cassidy had been communicating with Michael, after all, using the Golden Freddy suit. At first, she had been skeptical changing Fredbear's name to Golden Freddy, after all, Fredbear was Cassidy's favorite animatronic, but after Evan told Cassidy why he was so persistent on changing it, she understood.

It was all Michael's fault that Evan had wanted to change the name of the suit.

Soon, he was going to know what death feels like...

"Uhhh Cass? You there?" Evan waved his hand in front of Cassidy's face, snapping her out of her train of thoughts. "Oh, yeah, sorry. I zoned out."

"Yeah, no kidding. Anyway, what brings you here?"

"Well, I wanted to talk to you, about Mike." Cassidy stated, her eyes gleaming in determination.

"For the last time, it was an accident! I forgive him, you don't need to take revenge on him!" Evan exclaimed, seemingly fed up with Cassidy's nagging. That wouldn't stop her though. "You need to come to your senses! He killed you! You can't forgive him!" (Title drop! :D) "That was years ago. In fact, four years ago! You killed William a day after you went missing. There's a difference between wanting revenge and just being petty." Cassidy sighed in frustration. There was no changing Evan's mind once he was set on something. It took two years. TWO YEARS. For Cassidy to convince him that the nightmares he had were just dreams. Although, she had to admit, something was up with those nightmares. She had seen the same nightmarish animatronics sketched into Mikes logbook. Yes, perhaps she had been snooping, but she had to take safety precautions!

"Fine. Try to save your dimwitted brother." She said with a huff, walking out angrily. She would have to convince him another time. Just in case Mike survived tonight, she began thinking out a plan to get him killed. He would have to survive until Friday for the plan to work, but she was certain he wouldn't.

Yes.

He won't leave this building alive.

Her friend will be avenged. 

----------------------------------------------------------------

Four years ago, 1983, 10 days before the party.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Cassidy wandered around the park, she wanted to find someone who would play with her. She was constantly picked on for being a girl by the older kids. She saw someone sitting on the bench, couldn't have been much older than her, and he seemed lonely.

She walked up, holding her breath as she approached him. "Hi! My names Cassidy, what's yours?" She asked in the friendliest tone she could manage.

He looked up, he wore a striped grey and black shirt, his hair was a brown and he had one green eye and one blue eye. Cool!

"My names Evan." He replied, seeming to be curious about Cassidy. It looks like he hasn't had someone tell him their name in a friendly way in a long time as well.

At the same time, they both asked each other, "Wanna be friends?" The two both seemed shocked for a bit, surprised that some actually wanted to ask them to be friends, before they both started laughing. Once they stopped laughing, Cassidy said, "Sure. Wanna go play on the swings?" Evan replied in a heartbeat, "Yes! The swings are my favorite!" Cassidy gasped dramatically, "Mine too!" Soon, the two little kids were playing together as they talked, finding more and more similarities the two of them had. They were both 9, turning 10, and both had birthdays the same month. It was awesome!

However, as they got older.. things didn't stay the same.

Evan was 9, Cassidy was 9.

Evan turned 10, Cassidy turned 10.

Cassidy turned 11, Evan did not.

Cassidy turned 12, Evan did not.

Neither.

Turned.

13.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

When in doubt on how to make your chapter longer, FLASHBACKS ARE HERE FOR YOU!

I feel like it was so painfully obvious who was the person in the first-person PoV part of the story- but I just gotta live with it T-T

1055 Words.