My Sister's Best Friend || Sadie Sink

take back what's mine

Chloe's pov

Madison and I sat together up on a hill while having a picnic. I stared off into the distance, watching the sun set. I picked a strawberry out of the container, eating it.

"I'm really glad we're doing this, Chloe." Madison said as she looked at me. "I love you."

I looked at her. "You do?"

She nodded. "I do."

I opened my mouth to say it back but I just couldn't get the words out. I froze up. I mean, Madison was the perfect girlfriend. She was sweet, funny, a gentlewoman, and we never argued. But she isn't Sadie.

"I... I'm sorry." I said causing Madison's face to soften. "I love you Madison, I do."

"But you're not in love with me." She finished and I slowly nodded. "That's okay. I saw this coming from a mile away."

"Saw what coming?" I furrowed my eyebrows.

"That once Sadie got back from London, you'd go back to her." Madison said.

"No. No, Madison, it's not like that." I shook my head.

"It's okay, Chloe. Really." She assured me. "I'm not mad."

"You're not?" I furrowed my eyebrows.

"No. We've only been dating for a couple months. Better I find out now than in 1 or 2 years, right?" Madison asked as she stood up. "It was fun while it lasted."

I stood up as well, watching as Madison cleaned everything up and walked back to the car. I followed her and got in the passenger's seat while she put the stuff in the backseat.

"Are you sure you're not mad?" I asked.

"I'm sure." Madison answered as she started up the car.

"I'm sorry again. I'll start moving my stuff out the second we get home." I told her, assuming she didn't want me to live at her house anymore.

"You don't have to do that." She told me. "You can still live with me. If you want."

I slightly smiled. "Thank you."

After a few minutes, Madison pulled up to Sadie's house and put the car in park. I furrowed my eyebrows as I looked at the house, looking back at Madison.

"What are we..." I trailed off.

"Go get her." Madison told me and I just stared at her. "Go on. I know she really misses you too."

I opened up the passenger door and got out the car. I watched as Madison put her car in drive. She gave me a small smile before driving off.

I looked at Sadie's front door, letting out a breath before walking up to the porch. I hesitated before knocking on the door. She opened it after a few seconds.

"Chloe? What are you doing here?" Sadie asked me.

"I... Madison and I broke up." I told her.

"Oh... how- how come?" Sadie wondered.

"I don't love her the same way that... The same way that I love you." I admitted. "I want you back. I want everything to go back to the way it was. Back when you and I were happy together."

Sadie stared at me as I slowly leaned in and placed my lips on hers. I wrapped my arms around her neck as she placed her hands on my hips and melted into the kiss.

We made out for a bit before Sadie slid her hands down to my ass. I jumped up and wrapped my legs around her waist. Sadie turned around and kicked her front door shut before she carried me up to her room.

Sadie placed me down on the bed and hovered above me. Sadie pulled away from the kiss and looked down as my hand made its way to her bulge. She let out a moan as I started to palm her.

"I miss your big cock inside of me." I seductively said.

"Shit, Chloe." Sadie whispered before she started to pull down her sweatpants.

I smirked as I took off my shirt and bra along with my shorts and underwear. Sadie took off her shirt and bra as I leaned my back against the pillows.

I watched her pull down her boxers, her hard dick slapping against her stomach. Oh, fuck I really missed her.

"Are you still on the pill?" Sadie asked me and I shook my head no. Sadie pulled open the drawer of her bedside table and pulled out a condom. "Good thing I always keep a spare just in case."

Sadie tore open the condom packet before slipping it on and stroking her cock. She let out a sound that was somewhere between a relieved sigh and a moan.

Sadie hovered above me again, running her fingers through my folds and collecting the wetness. She aligned her dick with my hole before slowly thrusting into me causing me to moan.

She waited for me to adjust before she started to move. I wrapped my arms around her neck as I moaned.

"Oh, god, you feel so good." Sadie groaned as she threw her head back.

"Harder." I moaned.

Sadie lifted up my legs and wrapped them around her waist, fucking me at a new angle. She thrusted harder and faster inside of me. I let out a scream of pleasure once she started to hit my g-spot.

"Fuck, Sades! Right there!" I moaned.

"You like that?" Sadie smirked as she thrusted all the way inside of me.

"Fuck, yes!" I moaned as I looked into her eyes.

"You missed daddy's dick destroying your pussy?" Sadie asked me.

I moaned in response before looking down. I could see her dick imprint in my stomach every time she thrusted in.

I reached down and started to rub fast circles on my clit. Sadie looked down to watch. I felt her dick twitch inside of me before she let out a final moan and came in the condom.

A wave of pleasure suddenly washed over me as I reached my orgasm. I let out a gasp, moaning loudly as my eyes rolled into the back of my head.

"Sadie! I'm cumming!" I moaned as I came.

"Yeah? Good girl." Sadie praised.

When we both came down from our highs, Sadie pulled out of me. I panted as she got up and threw out the condom, getting in bed next to me.

"Oh, fuck, that was amazing." I told Sadie.

"Yeah. I told you I always take back what's mine." Sadie gave me a small smirk. "You're mine, Chloe. You got it?"

I blushed. "Got it."