Joel Miller X Reader Imagines and short stories

The babysitter*

Theme: Pre-outbreak! Y/N has been Sarah's Babysitter ever since she was 4, now it's been 10 years and Sarah believes she doesn't need a babysitter but Joel insists, for reasons he can't explain

TW⚠️: SMUT!!! Age gap (21 & 35), fingering, oral (male receiving), unprotected sex (Joel!Dom), spanking, choking, doggie style, begging, praise, degrading, slight arguing

Word count: 2407

~~~~~~~

"Dad I-," Sarah try's to say to her dad but he doesn't listen

"Enough, Sarah. That's that. She is going to continue watching you whenever you're home and I'm not." Joel says

"Why! Why does she have to!?" She says raising her voice

"Because I said so! Now end of story. Get in the truck so I can take you to school."

"Whatever" she responds, rolling her eyes

Joel lets out a scoff but chooses not to say anymore.
~~~~~~

School ended and Sarah just arrived home, she walked in and saw me, her babysitter.

"Hey Sarah!" I say to the teen

"Hi Y/n" she says back, barely any energy or enthusiasm in her voice

"How was school?" I ask trying to make small talk

"Fine I guess" she says as a quick response

I understand her frustration about me being here. Yes I know that she doesn't hate me, but me being here makes her feel like she doesn't have any freedom

Joel always tells me about how upset she gets about it and it kind of hurts. And it's not like he can just tell her why I'm here all the time

I begin to get pots and pans out and start making dinner for us both

Sarah is sat at the kitchen table doing her homework
~~~~~
After we got done eating we watched a movie on the couch together and she fell asleep half way through

I hear the jingle of keys outside the front door

The door opens and Joel emerges from the darkness of outside

He looks as handsome as ever

He walks into the living room and sees Sarah sleeping peacefully beside me

He looks at me, his eyes scanning up and down my body with a look of hunger

He's told me before that he feels like it's wrong for someone my age to be with someone as old as him but honestly I don't see what's wrong with it. We are both consenting adults and we have feelings that need to be met

"Fuck," Joel says with a quiet tone "I'm gonna go take her to bed and then we need to talk. In my room."

I nod in agreement and soon after Joel picks Sarah up with one arm under her legs and the other holding her up by the top of her back

I follow up the stair and continue forward to his room once he turns down the hall to take her to her room

I walk in and close the door behind me then go sit on the edge of the bed bed

A few minutes go by and Joel walks in and just at the pure sight of this man I feel my inner thighs dampen with arousal

He walks into his bedroom and locks the door behind him

"Hey baby" he said in a very seductive, low voice

I don't say anything and continue to look at his large frame as he walks closer and closer to me