Preferences and Imagines

Not So Secret Anymore (Theo Imagine)

Request: Your Scott's sister and dating Theo. The pack is angry when they find out.
I was hanging out with my brother and our friends at our house. We were just chilling getting ready to play a game, but we were just waiting on the pizza to come. In the meantime I was texting my boyfriend Theo who I have been dating for a couple months now. I wish he could of been here, but there this little feud going on with my friends, not really feud they just don't trust him. Apparently he is some bad guy who claims he is Theo Raeken but it's not the Theo they remember well Stiles mostly thinks which has Scott almost convinced. I on the other hand don't think that, I've gotten close to him and have gotten to know him pretty well and he has never shown any kind of sign he is a bad guy plus he does not try and hide anything or act suspicious in any way. They just got the wrong idea of him . This sucks because it has lead us to date secretly which is a challenge. The doorbell had rung so I'm guessing the pizza guy was here "Y/N can you help me get couple drinks and plates" Lydia asked and I nodded leaving my phone on the couch. We got a plate for each of us and drinks and headed back to the living room only to find my brother with my phone in his hand. He looked at me shocked was written all over his face with a mixture of pissed off and a little dissappointment, I already know what he has seen why did I leave my phone the couch why why why. "Scott..." I started but was cut off by him "YOU'RE DATING THEO!" Scott yelled the rest of the pack looked at me with the same expression as Scott "before you-" "Really Y/N, really we warned you about him you were there with us when we talked about him how can you do this" Stiles cut me off "yeah (your nickname), how can you do this we don't know what he can do. For all we know you can be part of some plan he is planning" Lydia said shaking her head. "Okay stop criticizing my boyfriend and let me speak what's the big deal I'm dating Theo so what and he's not like that Lydia" I said this was just stupid this was the reason I wanted to date him secretly because I know they would of reacted this way. As challenging as it is I prefer that then them being all judgmental "what's the big deal what's the big deal Y/N your dating Theo who for all we know is some crazy psychopath because that is not the Theo we know" Stiles said throwing his hands in the air "you know you are acting like a crazy psychopath Theo is nothing like that. I don't know what makes you think he is bad but you need to seriously chill because your blowing things out of proportion" I said already getting a little mad "we didn't mean to upset you but Stiles is right we don't know anything about him and if he's questioning his identity don't you think there might be something up" Kira said "yea I mean when Stiles and I went and followed him he did seem a bit suspicious up at a lake I got a suspicious vibe from him" Liam said I turned my attention to him then Stiles who was giving a look that basically said 'really you weren't suppose to mention that' "wait you two stalked my boyfriend what the hell if your so suspicious about him how about fucking confront him and not stalk him seriously I can't believe you two" I said crossing my arms "Y/N he won't just say what he's up to if we just ask him we have to catch him in the act" Scott said to which I just rolled my eyes "so what my happiness doesn't matter he makes me happy why can't you all just accept that. I mean I never really trusted Malia in the beginning but did I accuse her of crazy nonsense no. By the way no offense Malia" I said from everyone here she was the only one that was quiet about this situation "Y/N it's just-" "no I heard enough fuck this game night shit we were gonna have its obviously ruined now" I said and with that I grabbed both my phone and coat and left my house. I can not believe them. I knew they were gonna be angry when they found out eventually but I didn't know they where gonna be this angry and this judgmental.