Creepypasta One-Shots

Ticci Toby

Requested by Romina1234

Just in front of the woods, there was an opening to the town next to it. No one dared enter these woods as the Legends of the Creepypasta living in them had them all scared to go inside.

"Fucking pussies," Y/n muttered to themself. "I'm not afraid of some horror stories."

They stood just at the entrance of the woods. Taking a deep breath in and exhaling with a sigh, they took one step into the woods and then began to walk more into them. The woods were peaceful. Birds were chirping their happy songs. Leaves from the trees and above Y/n swished in the wind. Some falling from the branches as it was fall and leaves were beginning to turn colors of red, orange, yellow, brown or a mix of the colors combined. The leaves crunched beneath their feet as they walked.

Just when Y/n was going to doubt everyone all because of their own fear, they heard something in the bushes make them rustle. Instantly, they turned heel and began to make their way back to the town. They didn't care what it was, they were not going to become a victim of some fictional serial killer that may be real or some hungry wild animal who thinks that they're food. Their legs moved fast, feet gripping the ground to give them a boost, their arms pumping as they rushed to get out of the forest.

"Calling everyone pussies... Who's the pussy now?" Y/n asked themself in disappointment and shame.

Because they wasn't paying attention, they ran into someone. The impact sent them both to the ground. Y/n groaned slightly and sat up, holding their head. "Ow..." they mumbled before realizing that they ran into someone. Quickly, they got up and went over to them. "Oh my God, I am so sorry."

They offered a hand to help the person up. When he accepted their hand, he pulled himself up onto his feet before one of his tics took over him, making him shrug his shoulders and jerk his head to the side. Y/n's eyes narrowed slightly.

"Wait... You're not from town," they said, realizing who this stranger was.

"No. I am not," he said, looking at Y/n. "I'm known as Ticci Toby."

Y/n looked at Toby in silence for a bit before responding. "How about I just call you Toby? I think Ticci Toby is insulting because of what you have," they said softly.

Toby looked at Y/n with surprise in his eyes behind his goggles. "You... You just want to call me Toby?" he asked, almost uncertain before another tic came over him again, a vocal one this time.

Y/n nodded their head. Toby went silent, his shoulders lightly falling as he felt relaxed before he held out his hand. "C'mon, let me show you around the forest," he offered.

Y/n almost hesitated before taking Toby's hand in theirs. He began to lead them into the woods. For reassurance that he wasn't going to kill them, he threw his hatchets at a tree which made them stuck into the trunk.

"This place is more dangerous at night. You're lucky it's just me out here, or at least I think it's just me," Toby said as he continued to hold their hand.

Y/n looked at Toby as they walked side by side. "So... Since you're Slenderman's proxy, what does that mean?"

Toby didn't speak for a bit. "Well... I'm supposed to not reveal my identity, which I obviously did not follow in doing so. And I'm supposed to be killing for him, but I'm not."

Y/n's gaze softened slightly. "Why? Why haven't you killed me yet?"

Toby did not speak again, only to let out a sigh. "I... I'm not sure myself. It's like you're different in a way, I supposed."

Y/n gave Toby's hand a slight squeeze.

"Whatever happened to you, it's not your fault," they said softly.

Toby practically stopped at that, only to look down at Y/n. They looked back at him. Slowly, they brought their hand up to take off his hood, revealing his hair. Next were setting his goggles up on his head, revealing his eyes. And last of all, they gently pulled down his mask, revealing the scar on his face. Y/n did not seem disgusted. They only traced the scar with a tenderness that caused Toby to let out an audible shiver, his pupils widening just slightly.

Then, without a moment's thought, Toby grabbed Y/n by their waist, pulling them closer before pressing his lips against theirs. They were very surprised by his actions. After a couple of seconds, they closed their eyes and held him by his shoulders.

After a bit, they both pulled away for air. Toby rested his forehead against Y/n's as they opened their eyes to look at him.

"You're perfect," Toby whispered, making Y/n smile.

Their smile didn't last very long when they heard voices yelling out for their name. Y/n's eyes widened in panic. A search party? Why?

Toby looked alarmed as well. He quickly put his goggles, mask and hood back on. Y/n was sad that he had to leave. Before they could say anything he was already leaving. They stepped forward and grabbed his arm.

"Wait!" They said, making him look back in worry. Words caught in their mouth before they finally formed a sentence. "Will I ever see you again?"

Even with his face covered by his mask, Y/n could tell that Toby was smiling. "When the time is right. I promise I'll find you again," he responded, pressing his mask covered lips to their forehead before running off from sight.

Y/n only stood there with their hand on their chest. The search party looking for them was background noise.

"Goodbye, Toby. My dearest Toby..."